From the moment you walk into George Martins Strip Steak you know you are somewhere special. The waitstaff is friendly and there to assist you in every way. The menu is amazing and the quality of food is second to none. Truly one of the best restaurants I've ever been to. The ambiance is amazing.
Food was very good as well as the drinks at the bar. Great value for the fixed price dinner but skip the dessert that comes with the meal that was the only low point the chocolate moose was not good at all wish they would change it for almost anything else. It's a shame that is your final impression before departing next time i will tell them to keep it.
Recently tried this restaurant after several people recommended we were happy to have such an outstanding dining experience. We went on one of the "special" notes & had filet mignon which was delicious. Although my meat was not medium, the server was most accommodating & had it returned & cooked to my order. The wait staff is friendly & attentive plan on going back soon!
I dined here for Restuarant week and booked a table for 4 on a Tuesday, our dinner was planned on Friday evening at 6:45, later in the week 2 more friends decided to join and after calling the restuarant they were happy to accomodate us. The ambiance was as always spectacular, we were promptly greeted and seated in a leather red booth which was very iconic. The waitress was a pleasure, very attentive, bubbly and attention to every detail was exceptional. As always the drinks were top shelf and unique, fresh and worth the experience on their own. My only wish is that the $27.99 fixed price menu had a steak to enjoy so that my friends who were new to the restaurant could have experienced the steak. The steak was provided on the menu but at a $49 price point. I understand the steak at this fine establishment is top notch, however it would have really been nice to enjoy a steak during restaurant week on the $27 fixed price point! I am sure to return again as this is one of my favorite spots on the Island.
The food was good, solid - nothing special. (The service, however, was excellent) The crispy artichokes were not so crispy - basically just breaded and baked artichoke hearts..... My husband had the 20 oz. strip steak, which was served with roasted potatoes and grilled asparagus - solid but nothing special. I had the crispy duck - again, not so crispy. It was glazed with a sauce supposedly made with Thai chilies, but I couldn't taste anything remotely spicy, tasted more like Chinese duck sauce to me. Dessert was cheesecake and wild berry cobbler. The cobbler was made with berries that were definitely not ripe - very sour taste, despite the ice cream and whipped cream served with it. Maybe, because we went during restaurant week, they were taking short cuts?? All in all, an average meal and over-priced....
Great steaks and great atmosphere. The restaurant is in a residential neighborhood near a golf course giving it a rustic home style feel to its décor. the interior is lit softly and the upholstery is red-themed for a romantic feel. The art on the walls adds to the old-home vibe (lots of old photos of burlesque dancers aka strippers). I would recommend for a romantic dinner, but not for the kids. Food was great, service was very good also. I would go back again for a steak.
If George Martin's Strip Steak is one of the best steakhouses on Long Island, we are in trouble. Yes it was restaurant's week and 2 out of every RW experience we've had have been disappointing. But we selected the 49.95 (steak) menu and expected better. The waitress was pleasant, but seemed to be in another world. Our entrees were good (crispy artichokes/shrimp bisque) as were the desserts (cheesecake/wild berry cobbler). But the steaks were a big letdown. My Chairman's Reserve Boneless NY, ordered rare, was delivered medium, charred on the outside and overseasoned. The website promises savory dry-aged steaks, the reality is quite different. My wife's Delmonico (black Angus boneless ribeye) was under cooked and lacking in flavor. We had better steaks at Applebee's for half the price. Fortunately my 2 glasses of Estancia Estates Paso Robles Cabernet Sauvignon helped me forget the unremarkable meal. I will not recommend the Strip Steak.
Had a nice private table for 6 while dining with some out of the area friends. It was restaurant week so we a choice of two price fixed menus and the main menu. Service and the food was excellent.
My husband and I decided to visit Strip Steak for a second time. Our first experience was rather pleasant. We were even more pleased during our second visit. We took advantage of the special which consisted of a choice of appetizer , entree and dessert our dinner selection of the filet mignon and skirt steak was just superb Our wait staff was very attentive. After another wonderful dining experience we will most definitely return
The atmosphere is just perfect for an evening of great food, excellent service, and really good drinks. You feel special dining here. The decor and ambience brings you back to an elegant time but without any stuffiness. The seating is very comfortable and you are not rushed. The service is professional and friendly. As expected for this upscale restaurant, the food was of good quality and well-prepared. We will be back!
The evening was great as we were celebrating two birthdays. Food and atmosphere was excellent. No complaints about the service but for this level of restaurant with the bill at $600 with tip for 5 people.... I would have expected a more professional level for the wait staff and that is not to say the service was bad it certainly was not. I would definitely go back!
The prime rib was so bland. It had no flavor what so ever. It was almost like eating boiled meat. My husband's pork chop was also bland. The rolls were cold. The cheesecake was warm.
The atmosphere was pleasant. Nice music playing in the background.
I have been looking for a place like this for a while now. All 4 of us enjoyed the food the service and the decor . I will definitely go back. Great place for a special occasion.
An excellent steak restaurant off the main road. Service was excellent. Found the steaks were of high quality and cooked to order. Side dishes were plentiful. Ambiance great for either a romantic dinner or a small group setting.
Great restaurant smack in the middle of a residential area in Great River. Beautifully decorated and a wonderful, romantic ambiance. Waitstaff was amazing, as was the food!
Everything was perfect! My wife and I will definetly be returning soon.
My husband and I dined here on a Saturday night. We had a reservation and when we arrived our table wasn't ready. We told the hostess we had a reservation (she never greeted us) and left us standing there by the desk. Then she said "your table isn't ready you can go to the bar". Gave us no time frame and did not apologize for the table not being ready. So we went to the bar, then someone came over and brought us to our table which was set for four (our reservation was for two). We were brought our bottle of wine we had purchased at the bar by someone (who did not introduce herself), she dropped off the wine and left. After a while she came back to take our order (again....not introducing herself). She tried to tell us the specials but couldn't remember all of them. So.....we placed our order and she left. Our dinner was delicious but the service was not what you would expect for the price you're paying for dinner. We have been to many other steakhouses which are similarly priced and received much better service! If you're paying $200 and up for dinner for two, I would hope the service is better than you receive in a chain restaurant. This was not the case!
I would recommend George Martins Streak House as a great local find service is friendly and helpful. Good food . Need to make reservations parking is limited.
I have worked in the restauraunt business for 23 years. Witht that being said I apreciate good service and food. The service was impecable. I love the attire that the staff wears. it is a clean attractive , professional look. the food was outstanding and it has now become my number one go to place.
We had a fabulous night celebrating my husband's retirement. Loved the red room and did not even request it....we will request the next time.....filet and lobster just delicious as were the drink specials....just a fabulous place....perfect for special occasions....highly recommend!!!
Love this restaurant. We used to go to Tellers but the ambiance at Strip Steak is relaxing and cozy. Wonderful menu and food always perfectly prepared. Love the nitro ice cream. Just wish we lived closer but so worth the 45 min drive.
What a great find! Started with the carpaccio app and seafood bisque. Although the carpaccio was sliced thicker than expected it was delicious. The bisque was so chock full of lobster and crab my husband couldn't finish his scallop and shrimp entree. I had a filet mignon special with blue cheese crust and demi demiglaze that had me chewing the first bite with my eyes closed! Service was attentive and prompt. Seated by the bar and guitarist made for a bit of a noisy meal but certainly not a deterrent from returning.
We went for a beer pairing dinner special and it was great. The beer and food were great. Excellent cheese board to start and a Large 14 oz strip steak to finish the meal off. Service was excellent and always is excellent. We will be going back.
First time there, food and service were great. Really extensive wine list too. Will definitely be back.
Went on a Sunday night for the Prime Rib special. Rib is cut up for 2, some pieces were tasty, however
the majority were too fatty and we did not eat them. Sides were plentiful and tasty.
Food is exceptional as well as the service and staff. That is why we continue to go back.
place was great-service, food everything....................................................................
The food was amazing as well as the service. Expensive but definitely worth it for a special occasion. It was very cold inside but they did offer to move our seats away from the window because there was a draft. The music was also so low I felt like everyone next to me could hear me talking. It was almost too quiet. The overall experience was definitely 5 stars though!
Ordered filet mignon and skirt steak with one cocktail, a coke, 2 appetizers and 3 side dishes. Side dishes were family size and appropriate for sharing. Food was delicious. Server was extremely friendly and attentive. Negative: live music band was extremely loud....hostess could not hear me announce my name for my reservation, had to repeat it several times. Felt like a rock concert. The dinner became much more pleasant after the live band finished for the night. Would go back again, but would try to coordinate when live band is not present.
We are huge fans! We've never been disappointed! The steaks are scrumptious! Our favorites, the skirt steak and ribeye are mouthwatering! Lobster mac and cheese is yummy too! Nice portions, good service and amazing food! What more can one ask for? George Martin's is a definite "must try!"
Date ordered Skirt Steak that was fatty.....seating was tight due to adding of additional tables and staff seemed motivated to get your in and out as fast as they can for the next seating.
Music and Ambiance were the highlights....
Quiet Relaxed atmosphere, Excellent food, Generous portions, great varied menu
This restaurant converted home is unique, the food is pricey but we'll thought out and nicely presented and tasty. Service is very good, the atmosphere is a bit noisy buy the bar. The setting is not appropriate for children as its theme is of a red light district brothal adorned with pictures of roaring 20's women with exposd breasts. Seating by the front was a bit cold as door draft keeps your feet cold. Overall a nice dining experience with exceptions. Updating the theme would be sugested.
Our server Rosalie was GREAT! I had the specials corn chowder soup large pieces of chicken cream corn tasty delicious! My husband had steak fork tender cooked to perfection! I had pan seared scallops with shrimp over rice once again perfection! Scallops were succulent shrimp tender! The server gave is enough time never felt rushed! She knew the menu perfectly. Anyone going to the restsursnt should ask for her!
We have been coming here for over 4 years now and it never disappoints. Good food, great service always. It can get a little noisy in the main room, but if you want a more intimate setting, ask for the room in the back with the fireplace. Nice and quiet.
Great place, salads,apps,steaks, all top knotch- you have to try it!
The mid week price fix steak special is a great deal. We went on a Wednesday so there place was quiet. Staff was friendly, service was great. We had wedge salad, filet, fries and dessert, all were excellent.
George Martin's Strip Steak always a good bet for great steaks and fine cusine, My son and I had the porterhouse for two that was perfectly grilled and exceptionality flavorful.
We truly enjoyed celebrating our same day birthdays with the attentive staff at Strip Steak.
We easily made reservations online and was seated in the room that we requested (Fireplace Room). The food and service was excellent. The staff was very attentive and we never had to wait. It was a wonderful night out with my wife and I highly recommend George Matin's Strip Steak to everyone.
We love going to Strip Steak! I highly recommend trying their specials... They never disappoint!! We really enjoy sitting in the Back room. With only four tables and a fire place, it is the best seat in the house! Service is always sensational. We had an amazing dinner.