George Martin's Strip Steak
appreciate a true upscale steakhouse experience offering savory,
dry-aged steaks as well as a multitude of chops, seafood and house specialties that are sure to be palate pleasers.
Strip Steak is situated in a turn of the century house in Great River, a
stone's throw away from the Great South Bay. The sophisticated, rich
design is vibrant yet intimate with an art deco style that mirrors the 1920's,
which is evident in the period artwork as well as existing architectural
Gluten free options
Al fresco dining
Live entertainment weekends
12oz signature molasses and soy marinade
GM NY Strip Steak
20oz on the bone
Porterhouse for Two
Birthday dinner for my wife. The food and service was excellent as usual.
Bria !!!!! And Patty.
These two servers are the epitome of professional and personal. Bria was extremely knowledgeable of the menu and associated wine pairings. She made us feel welcomed and comfortable like we had been regulars who have frequented the restaurant 100s of times. She was prompt and attentive to all our service needs. I look forward to Bria’s stellar service the next time I attend George Martin’s.
The food was excellent and a very nice selection on the Price Fixe menu. We were all pleased with our meal.
Excellent food and service! Andrew is a fabulous waiter
As always the food and staff were amazing. No long waits. Top notch service!
George Martins never disapponts. Pricey but it is always worth it.
Phenomenal dinner, steaks were all PERFECT. Service, as always, was great too. That au poivre sauce is irresistible (chefs kiss).
Lovely, beautiful place. Service and food excellent
This amazing Steakhouse isn’t just a place to get a great steak. It’s a Good Vibe, a place to gather, whether you’re a party of one or a party of 10, you feel welcome. And that’s because of the staff. Our server Briar was upbeat and fun, an absolute pleasure. Upon her suggestions we ordered the chili Pop Shrimp, similar to Rock Shrimp but on another level, sweet/spicy so good. The Fondue was creamy and cheesy with crispy toasted bread for dipping.
For our entrees … two Giant Sizzling Cowboy Ribeyes, and a 40 oz Enormous Porterhouse All cooked to perfection. For those of you with a sweet tooth, all of the desserts are made in house and you can taste it. By the end of our meal we were planning our next visit to this outstanding restaurant.
Touché GM StripSteAk …. Bye bye Tellers
I can't even count the amount of times we've had had dinner at Strip Steak (as we celebrate every anniversary, birthday, promotion, and life event in-between at the restaurant) and the food is always top notch and fantastic, however this time around we were displeased with some of the service.
When we arrived the group of hostess staff were rude and just told us to have a drink at the bar, we had a reservation and we were sat 25 minutes after our reservation time. They didn't even come and get us to seat us, they actually had our server do it which was strange and unique considering we've never had that happen at GMSS before, when she brought us to our table it wasn't set so she quickly had to scramble and I felt bad as that is not something she should have had to worry about. The music was way too loud and we were sat right beneath it, at one point we saw the manager ask the host to walk in and check the music but nothing changed.
The food is always delicious and our server was great but overall I can't say this was a 5 star dinner to celebrate a birthday. Unfortunately they have some service level issues they'll need to work on before we go back again.
Food and staff were very good.
Would highly recommend to eat there
Still noisier than I'd like it to be
Especially when the filled.
Always our place to go for a nice, relaxing, Quiet dinner with family.
Sitting outside was beautiful. Heat lamps made it the perfect temperature. The service was amazing
Our porterhouse for two was delicious!!!
Cant wait to go back!
Everything was perfect. Make sure you have a reservation as I did.
Everything was great- especially the food! Haven’t had a skirt steak like that- delicious- and m husband’s strip steak was the best he ever had!
The prix fixe option is definitely worth it and the food was delicious. We sat outside on the porch and enjoyed a great meal. Christine, our server was terrific!
A wonderful meal! The seafood trio was excellent as was the crab cake stuffed shrimp! Calimari and french onion soup appetizers were perfect as was our waitress, Christine. Nice attention to detail with a celebratory glass of champagne for our anniversary.
As always, great food and service!
Skirt steak cooked just right and cream spinach was delicious 😋
It was our first time here with friends. We absolutely loved it!! Food was incredible, singer was amazing!! Very romantic as well. We will definitely be returning!!
The service was spot on, the food was cooked to perfection and everything arrived timely. The waitress was very knowledgeable and friendly.
Food was amazing!!
Outside seating was great along with the food, service and wine.
Steaks and sides were great. Waitress was nice. Atmosphere was nice.
Everything was outstanding g
My husband and I went out for a long overdue date night and we definitely picked the right place. We were greeted by 2 smiling hostesses and were immediately escorted to our table in front of a beautiful fireplace. Our waitress was very friendly and attentive and gave us great recommendations. Everything we ordered was delicious! We will be visiting again, hopefully sooner than later!
Everything at George Martin's Strip Steak is above and beyond! The food and service are both outstanding! This is why it's our favorite restaurant!
The Price Fix menu is a deal. One dinner took that dessert home and ordered the tower of chocolate cake!
Another great experience at GM! The filet melts in your mouth, simply amazing food.
George Martin never disappoints. The food, the setting, the staff always comes forward with panache. You'll never go wrong bringing someone you care about to this place.
This is one of the best kept secrets in regards to steakhouses on Long Island. Between the pricing , service and ambience it is by far the best steakhouse on Long Island. Highly recommend it and encourage people to try it.
Always a great experience!!
A consistently reliable dining experience, George Martin Strip Steak never disappoints. The food is cooked to perfection every time, the staff is professional and friendly without being obtrusive, and the ambiance is cozy without feeling cramped. Overall, a hidden gem that is a go-to for special occasions or just a quiet dinner. Highly recommend!
Excellent food and service
I would like to offer a bad review so I can keep this gem all to myself, but I'd be lying.
Consistently excellent food and service. Always love coming here, especially for date night.
Outstanding as usual
Me and my boyfriend come here once a month it’s always phenomenal.
George Martin's Strip Steak offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (631) 650-6777.
George Martin's Strip Steak is rated 4.8 stars by 2795 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.