George Martin's Strip Steak
appreciate a true upscale steakhouse experience offering savory,
dry-aged steaks as well as a multitude of chops, seafood and house specialties that are sure to be palate pleasers.
Strip Steak is situated in a turn of the century house in Great River, a
stone's throw away from the Great South Bay. The sophisticated, rich
design is vibrant yet intimate with an art deco style that mirrors the 1920's,
which is evident in the period artwork as well as existing architectural
Gluten free options
Al fresco dining
Live entertainment weekends
12oz signature molasses and soy marinade
GM, NY Strip Steak
20oz on the bone
Strip Steak Sundae
Vanilla bean ice cream, bulleit bourbon pecan crunch, drunken cherries, warm chocolate ganache & fresh cream
I would like to offer a bad review so I can keep this gem all to myself, but I'd be lying.
Consistently excellent food and service. Always love coming here, especially for date night.
Outstanding as usual
Me and my boyfriend come here once a month it’s always phenomenal.
It was OK. It is a pretty restaurant and the ambiance was nice. Food was good but not excellent. Service was slow but polite. We sat outside and that may have been a mistake. The inside tables might have been better. I would try it again and sit inside. There was live music inside.
Overall really good
I just think for the prices it should come with a small side or two with the steaks
Always a great meal..
It was fabulous!
Terrific experience as always . The 4 of us enjoyed our meals and our server “Philip” was excellent. !! 👍
Always a pleasure when eating there. Can’t wait to go back!
Food was excellent. Server great. Had a wonderful time with good friends.
A great gem on Long Island. They have steak specials on Wednesday and Thursday, and the menu on those days is not what "doesn't move". The bar is great, and the service is excellent. Can't go wrong eating here.
We were celebrating my 75th birthday and as always the meal was excellent and our server, Danielle was attentive. We are only on Long Island 4 months a year and try and get to George Matin’s Strip Steak for our Anniversary and my Birthday in addition to other times
Waiter was excellent ! Very accommodating! Never disappointed there
Great food and great service
The place isn't open on Mon. and Tues., so everyone want to dine there on Thurs. Fri. , Sat and Sun. That makes for crowding. Chef likes to use pepper too and there is no need to do so as there is plenty of pepper in Pepper mills and pepper shakers. I don't like pepper and it's very frustrating to have pepper placed in my food when I don't want it.
We were disappointed, we have been there numerous times and never had this experience. A non attentive waitress. My wine was empty for some time and I had to track her down. Water was not refilled until I requested and lastly and worst my brother in laws meal did not come out till we were ALL done eating. She did take it off the bill but if it was my 1st time I would not come back it was unacceptable
A great restaurant for great times with great friends, always exceed expectations.
George Martin Strip Steak in beautiful Great River. 🇺🇸
It was my first time there
But not my last
My parents first time and they thought this place was out of this world! Never disappoints!
Food great as usual, Shawn our waiter was efficient,courteous and attentive. Thank you for a wonderful birthday dinner.
We have been to George Martins before and it doesn’t disappoint! This time was to celebrate my husband and daughter’s birthday! We were a fairly large group and was seated in the enclosed booth. It reminded me of a train car booth, very nice and private! Food is always good.. cooked to perfection and service was great! My only negative and it really wasn’t a negative, is the live music , as I really enjoy live music , I feel like it’s not the right ambiance. Also a very tight space for the music! But it wasn’t bad! Highly recommend this place!
Shawn was fantastic. Food was excellent. Thank you!
Our food was delicious, our waiter was terrific, and Sean the manager, was outstanding with his customer service even though they were very busy this evening. He still found time to make sure that we were content with our meal.
The food was perfectly cooked and prompt
The waiter was very nice and helpful
This place is our favorite special occasion restaurant
You will love it
We had a very peaceful table outside. There was live entertainment inside which would have made it harder to converse.
The food was delicious and the live singer was very talented and not too loud. Would definitely recommend!
Always a great meal with terrific service
Sean the manager is outstanding
Highly recommend this restaurant
Great Food - Great Price - Great Service - Great atmosphere. LOVE this place!! It was my birthday and I was given a $25 gift card towards my next visit.
Always a pleasant experience to visit this nice steakhouse. The food, service, and ambiance are all top-notch. Great restaurant for all occasions.
This was our first visit to George Martin's Steakhouse and was an incredible good dining experience. I would certainly return. The Wed/ Thur price fixed menu is an outstanding value!
Excellent food excellent service. Love to come here!
It was my birthday dinner. Service was above and beyond!! We ordered an appetizer that wasn’t what we expected. We figured oh well we made a mistake. Our waiter John asked us how it was and he cook tell we didn’t like it immediately he got his manager and they took it off the bill. We weren’t looking to make a big deal but they really wanted to make us happy. They suggested a great option for apps and nailed it. Free birthday dessert and they gave me a birthday $25 gift certificate. Mind blown how awesome they are. We will definitely be back. Everything else we had was amazing!!
Overall we had a wonderful dinner. Service was fantastic, food excellent. Noise level was intense. Should have sat in the outdoor seating.
Food was outstanding, loved everything we had. Service was excellent as well.
This was our first visit and we were not disappointed. First we were greeted by the host/hostess and they all were very pleasant. Our server Andrew was great. Very nice and was very helpful with our selections. We made our reservation for 5:30 on a Saturday and we were seated once we arrived. Andrew made sure he stopped by our tables several times to see if everything was going well. We never felt rushed at anytime and all our food courses were spaced out accordingly. For starters we had the Calamari with Pepper rings & the Chili Pop Shrimp. Both of these were amazing The calamari was very crispy and very tender. The shrimp had just the right amount of kick . Our salad was fresh and crisp… Our entree was The Chateaubrand Dinner for Two. It was cooked to perfection. The vegetables and roasted potatoes were delicious. The potatoes were a highlight…. Thanks
You can feel Humphrey Bogart and Frank Sinatra have Martinis here!
Just fantastic all around.
We went for the Wednesday-Thursday Prix Fix Dinner. It was excellent and we could not have been treated any better by the Staff. Food was hot, fresh and prepared exactly the way we requested. We are going back again very soon
Our server may have been having an off night. We had an early reservation (5:30) and the restaurant was more than half empty, so hard to understand why service was so off. Here are some examples. My glass of Sauvignon Blanc was warm. When I mentioned it, she offered to bring me ice, rather than a new glass. I had only had a sip or two. I told her not to bother with the ice and she came back 20 minutes later with a glass of ice. My spouse ordered a crab cake appetizer, and she even asked if he wanted the appetizer or dinner portion. What was delivered to the table was crab cocktail. When we pointed that out she apologized and replaced it with the crab cake. When the bill came, crab cocktail was included rather than the less expensive crab cake. She saw me reviewing the bill and said something like, “Oh, I have to adjust that.” She was perfectly friendly and polite, just not very good that night. And by the way, we ordered off the regular menu, rather than prix fixe. With one (warm) glass of wine and no dessert, the bill was around $200.00
One other thing, I put in the Open Table reservation remarks that this was a 70th birthday celebration. It was never acknowledged.
We’ve been to GMSS 6 or 7 times, and this was a most disappointing visit even though the food was quite good as usual. Overall, we feel the food and service at Tellers is superior.
George Martin's Strip Steak offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (631) 650-6777.
George Martin's Strip Steak is rated 4.8 stars by 2770 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.