Excellent host Justin and our fantastic waiter Michael. Many choices of steak and specials. Each course starting with our salad then appetizers and steak is what you should expect; fresh and delicious. Will definitely be back for Gallagher’s soon!

Locale dal sapore retrò, con personale molto preparato ed efficiente. Sia gli antipasti che la portata principale erano eccezionali.
Peccato solo che al tavolo dove eravamo noi era necessario coprirsi per il gran.freddo dovuto all'aria condizionata, che invece era gradevole in altre zone del locale.

I was not expecting to like or appreciate Gallagher's, went with a friend and thought, 'ok, another hackneyed steakhouse experience'. I was very delighted with the sparkling atmosphere, the funny charming helpful waiter - and the food was great. On the menu it sounds a bit retro, but it was delicious, the wine by the glass excellent and I had a great time chatting with the father/son at the next table. I'm singing the praises all over town. I'm a food snob and have had mediocre experiences at some of the more trendy expensive places and this was my favorite meal on this trip.

Wow... What an incredible dining experience. We visited Gallagher's having extensively researched great food options in the Midtown area for our NYC trip. It lives up to every spectacular food review it has received from Eater NYC and more! The service was simply spectacular, the speakeasy ambiance and history of the place set the tone for an NYC classic dining experience and the food was amazing. Our server took the time to make some great recommendations including Mac and cheese special and bone marrow crusted filet... Wow. Highly recommended! Thankyou.

Gallagher's is a classic. Besides being a great steakhouse, it is an excellent choice for a nice lunch, at a moderate price for the neighborhood. Service is great and the atmosphere is very "New York," and very relaxing. It's easy to overlook it, tucked away on the side street. But don't forget it's there!

Once again amazing dinner with mom :D I had cowboy steak, and my mother had chicken. Overall very good!

Memorable evening in a fabulous restaurant.

Daughter’s engagement

Great service. Incredible food.

Great evening and food. Nikki and Andrew were super with recommendation and attentive service. All was great

We dined on a Friday evening at 8pm. The restaurant was very lively and very busy however we were greeted quickly by our very handsome waiter. He introduced himself as Randy. We were served promptly but not rushed. We ordered lamb chops which were FANTASTIC! I wish I had taken photos but I was enjoying them too much! We had started with a salad, chopped wedge with Russian! (We requested). We also got a side or pork belly for the salad. That’s the big secret! It’s beyond deeeeeelicious! The evening was a continuous, lively club like atmosphere. Can’t wait to come back!!!! Francis and Darius were also quite in tune with us and asked more than once if we needed anything. Wonderful and very enjoyable evening. These are very skilled waiters and it seems to be run like a very tight ship! Nice job!

As always Our dinner at Gallagher’s was amazing. The staff is not only professional and knowledgeable, but exudes charm of the past. Their meat is outstanding and is always prepared to perfection. We are already looking forward to our next visit at Gallagher’s.

By far the best steakhouse in the city. Love the atmosphere and the waiters were cery attentive. The food was delicious, we got the surf and turf and both steak and lobster were amazingggg! Highly recommend, thank you for a wonderful meal and a good time!

What a great find! Definitely book as this place was rocking from the moment we stepped in. Obviously a local haunt for New Yorkers also and service was great. The Meat locker amased my boys, obviously not vegetarians (apologies for those of you who are - maybe not your place to be). The choice of meat was outstanding and the service was as I had expected, typical American old-school, loved it! They even brought my son a birthday cake and sang in the restaurant. Really would recommend this place.

Always the best service and amazing steaks I would recommend this restaurant to anyone

It was great! Got the Porterhouse for two, with creamed spinach, and mashed potatoes, and a very tasty bottle of wine. The waiters were always attentive and very professional. We were in a rush because we were going to go and see a show at the theatre close by, but they brought out the food so fast, we ended up relaxing and having a great time. They brought out a nice chocolate cake for my girlfriends Birthday and also complimentary Sherry. The waiters were hilarious and made the dining experience great! I Would definitely go back there again!

Just great. Service is the best I’ve had in nyc. I will be back. Omg. Yes I will.

Exceptional food and ambiance, oustandinf service.

Steak was undercooked, the vegetables cold and the salad limp.

We were rushed to finish with plates being removed before we finished.

Good for the bar, go somewhere else for a steak.

Incredible as usual! We can't wait to come back again and again.

FOOD AND SERVICE WERE EXCELLENT WELL RAN OPERATION THATS WHY THEY HAVE BEEN AROUND SO LONG. LOT OF HISTORY THERE

We had a very good steak mix. Good service and value for what we paid. Ambience too cold for us, but it is quite a rule in NYC!

Fantastic steaks and customer service!

Food was good but overpriced. The service was very fast and efficient. The exaggerated price decreased the overall quality of the dinner.

A bit off the grid for midtown, on the way to Hell’s Kitchen. Not much space for dinning as the bar takes a big chunk of the floor. Having a table near to bar made the area very noisy - not especially good for a relaxed chat over dinner.
The service is courteous but not not outstanding.
I had the Rib steak which tasted somewhat plain. It was served with some gravy-like sauce - which tasted rich - but made me think that without it the steak itself would be probably unremarkable.

“EXCELLENT” sums it up. Food, service,etc. Nothing else to say.

Probably the best steak house in NYC. Not too salty, no extra butter like other steak places. They have all the classics. Great creamed spinach without too much nutmeg, baked potatoes etc.

The best steak house in NYC!!!
The food was amazing, the service was fantastic & the atmosphere was great. It's very NYC xx

Gallaghers does a good job at lunch time. Service is very good and they are attentive. I tried the pastrami for the first time. While the portion was large, I found the pastrami was more like corn beef except it was prepared pastrami style and the salt was too heavy.

My wife and I and our 2 sons were visiting NYC from Georgetown, Ontario and had a fabulous experience at Gallaghers.

The wait staff was very attentive and the food was impecable.

We will definitely return.

In vacanza a New York la scelta per una bistecca seria è ricaduta su questo ristorante. Servizio impeccabile, il nostro cameriere è stato molto gentile nello spiegarci i vari tipi di carne e consigliarci nella scelta di vino e contorno, ambiente elegante, ma non ingessato, e il cibo delizioso. La bistecca più buona che abbia mai mangiato e, non esagero, la cheesecake più buona di New York (sono un’appassionata, la faccio anch’io e ne ho praticamente provata una al giorno! Hihihi)

We visited for three 21st birthdays and the experience was fantastic
The food was amazing and our waiter was very knowledgable explaining the cuts of meats
We will visit again

My wife’s 45 birthday.

I was dining alone between segments of Angels in America. I had a terrific martini an excellent rib steak and friendly, unobtrusive service. The only disappointment was the Caesar salad; it bland and not up to the rest of the experience.

The service was very bad!

Excellent selection of steak, all small dishes are amazing especially the arugula beet salad. The wait staff is top notch catering to your every need. If you are lucky you may just see an infmaous local!

We found Gallagher's this year and continue to come back from Connecticut The atmosphere is quintessential New York, and the food is outstanding. An outstanding place for fine food and fine conversation.

Service was too rushed. Waiter did not check in on food when initially served. Place seemed too busy for number of waiters.

Steak price for one steak was too high charging $51 per person for one small steak over price.The steak taste was good but not great .The staff were polite and friendly But the table was to close to each other hearing the loud couple next to us loud voice conversation was not enjoyable special day..Our Anniversary dinner was not special day as plan.

All was better than good - great bartenders - happy and fun waitstaff -