Please join us for our awarded Best Bloody Mary Bar Westword 2016. Also A great Italian style brunch with 6 different kinds of Bottomless Mimosas.
Nice menu well presented.
Always amazing! Erin was our waitress and she was the best!! Brought 3 people for the first time and they loved every minute. Thank you for always exceeding our expectations
Everything is always delicious and moderately priced. Great atmosphere for couples and small groups. Would not recommend for children.
Fast and friendly service in a truly old-school atmosphere. Food was outstanding and we’ll definitely be making this a regular dining stop.
Orders for 2 people were combined onto one plate. Food only so so. Extremely loud.
Had a decent wait time past our reservation, but hostess kept checking on us and updating us. Amazing food and great atmosphere! Highly recommend!
If you are looking for authentic Italian food, this is the place to be. My wife and I were very impressed with the food. We have had Italian all over the United States and this place ranks in our top 3. Our Server was very friendly but we believe he did not allocate his time efficiently with all of his tables. He was very courteous very friendly and made wonderful recommendations. If you are looking for a romantic dinner and do not feel like dressing to the nines, this is the place to go.
Had a wonderful evening celebrating my Birthday!! Everyone at the restaurant was so nice and accommodating!! Can't wait to go back!
What makes this place great is Derek Evilsizor; what an awesome entertainer. If you lose him you lose your edge as an excellent restaurant.
The food was delicious as always. Never disappoints!
Smaller portions than I was expecting but otherwise excellent!
The two times we have eaten here the temperature in building is way too warm! Need more air flow or air conditioning. We were miserable trying to eat.
Had reservations for 7:15, but weren’t sat until 7:45. The service was pretty slow. Food was pretty good though.
The server was very knowledgeable and helpful when picking items. We went for Mother’s Day and my mom had the best lasagna she’s ever had!
Great food, quick service. Definitely will be going back again and again!!
We had an excellent waitress named Erin, I believe. Our appetizer and main courses were very good, but the beet salad was not okay...beets okay, but very wilted lettuce...yuck! They need to fix their hosting set up...one long line for everyone...reservations or not. The young male host was very nice, but overwhelmed. Open Table contacted us, saying we hadn’t honored our reservation.
Best Italian food there is totally worth it will more than definitely be going back
Great service and good food. Restaurant has a lot of mob history
Wanted to take my godson to an authentic Italian restaurant while he was in Denver. I read the reviews for Gaetano's and hoped for the best. As soon as we arrived, I knew I picked the right place. It was busy for a Monday evening ( must be good ). The atmosphere was definitely Italian. We had reservations and were immediately seated. The hostess apologized for not being able to seat us at a booth - I was impressed that they actually read the comments/requests when I made the reservation on OpenTable. Once seated, we were immediately taken care of by our waitress. We were pleased to find out that Monday was all day happy hour - so we took advantage of the drink and appetizer specials. The main menu was extensive, but I took the advice of our waitress and ordered the home made Gnocchi. My godson was excited to try the peppers and sausage over cavatelli and we both had side ceasar salads. There was very little wait before the salads and the entrees were served. The servings were generous - and WOW on delicious. We finished off the evening with cappuccino and a large serving of terramissu. I took some of my Gnocchi home which my wife had for lunch the next day. Guess where we are going for dinner the next time out. I've been looking for that "go to" place in the Denver area since we moved here three years ago - With a quick drive from Broomfield, the ease of parking and the great food and service, I believe i have finally found it.
Tonight the food and service weren't nearly as good as usual. Hopefully this was an "off" night and next time will be back to the excellent food and service that we are used to at Gaetano's.
Excellent food excellent service! We also really enjoyed hearing about the history of the restaurant.
Spent comfortable and fun two hours dining, drinking, talking and laughing. Great place for special occasions. Too pricy to be a regular customer.
Everything was amazing!! We will definitely be coming back.
The atmosphere has really changed over the years. Al,ost too noisy for me.
Go early as it gets crowded and noise level is loud..A must the risoto and brussel sprouts
Took my friend visiting from the UK and he loved it. He thought the meal and dessert was good, then came the Lemoncello and that just put the meal over the top. I would rate it a 5-star +++. I always have a gr8 experience at Gaetano’s, just wish I lived a little closer. But it is worth the drive. The only downside was we were seated near the door and it was a cold evening.
Such a classic restaurant! Rich ambiance, great food, Highly recommend over anything in the area.
Tried the Chicken Caprese for the first time and it was so good! Food and service is always on point and the Creme Brulee cheesecake was delicious. My only suggestion would be to turn the music down a little-I had to shot across the table just so my Mom could hear me and we were barley 3 feet away from each other. Other guests near us were commenting that is was obnoxiously loud also.
A place with lots of history and good food. Waiter was attentive and friendly.
Like that they have a free parking lot.
Food was super good!
We love the food, grate tasting from the fry Calamari all the way to desserts. We will be back soon.
Great happy hour prices on appetizers and cocktails all night on Monday. Meatball sliders and mussels are a steal and delicious. The rest of the food is just okay, so we usually just come for the amazing happy hour deal.
Cool vibe and great food. I look forward to going back.
We checked in with the hostess for our reservation. We were sat promptly. We weee not acknowledge. No one took our drink order or food order. We waited 25 minutes while several staff walked by us; seated in the center booth next to the bar. One server was sitting with a group at a booth eating and would get up on occasion to check on her tables near us. No one assist us so we left.
Too bad as we were looking forward to a nice Italian dinner. Maggionos took care of us and we enjoyed it very much.
Gaetano’s will not be given another option to have our business. Very disappointed and the restaurant was not busy.
Easter brunch. Food was amazing as always. Service was great.
Great traditional Italian food in a wonderful classic atmosphere.
We've been here a few times. Love the food and wine. Service is wonderful. Location is decent, parking good. There is some traffic noise, oh well. Nice restroom.
Bloody Mary bar was great, the gnocchi was fantastic and the eggs carbonara was perfect.
Good food. Good server. Some loud kids in the dining area made it a bit annoying, but overall a good experience.
Old time family owned Italian restaurant that is becoming harder to find in this era of corporate restaurants