This place was a hoot! Our meals were delicious. Of note - everyone was very happy. Lots of hugging going on. There was a Frank Sinatra singer dude, very entertaining. Very loud music, I'm not sure if it is always like this, but on our Monday night, the party was on. Make a reservation, pretty tight quarters.
Always wanted to try this place and it didn’t disappoint!! Definitely going to be returning!!
Service was friendly and efficient. Great atmosphere. Love the 38th Avenue cocktail
When my breakfast skillet came out with no potatoes I asked our server if it was supposed to have potatoes in it (most skillets do). She said yes and said she would grab me some. Comes back with a bowl of potatoes and says “May I?”, grabs my fork and starts digging through my food looking for the potatoes that weren’t there remarking “the chef swore he put them in here but you’re right there aren’t any!”. I was shocked she had the audacity to dig through my food as if I were lying about the potatoes. The food was horrible anyways.
Food with The Family in an eccentricly authentic piece of local history? Absolutely! Comforting cuisine, superb service, and a panorama of jokes straight from The Godfather over tiramisu and a great cappuccino? You got it! Worried about getting whacked? The door's bullet proof, friend. Leave the gun, take the cannoli, and bring a friend. Live a little.
It was very nice. The food was so delicious. Just a little crowded. Felt like I was eating with the the person sitting right next to me
The food was outstanding and I can't wait to go back. Wish it wasn't as loud as it was or crowded.
We went on “Frank Sinatra” night and had a good time along with great food
Great food and service, we will be back agin soon. I had the lobster ravioli my wife had the lasagne both were delicious. Had the tiramisu for dessert that was perfect. Highly recommend this place to anyone!
Fantastic Italian gem with wonderful food and great service. The wine and atmosphere is nice and can be perfect for a date or a business meeting.
This place was recommended by a trusted friend. This place did not disappoint, as the food was great tasting at a decent price, not bad for a date. Good location with original taste that stuck to tradition. Most of all, the girlfriend loved it and that's what matters most at the end of the day.
Time and time again Gaetano's delivers! The service has always been great and the food reminds me of my east coast childhood. Best Italian in the state hands down!!
Absolutely delicious Italian. We started with the complimentary water and bread. Then we got the fried raviolis with marinara sauce that were delicious. Then we got lasagna and chicken parmesan. The lasagna was the best lasagna I've ever had. We did not have room for dessert unfortunately but I would definitely go back.
Great food at a good value, really cool atmosphere for a night out with friends or a significant other. We’re glad we made a reservation. Highly recommended!
Love this place one of my favorite resturants Love the atmosphere, the history
the wine list , and the food is great.
The history behind Gaetano’s is almost as great as the food. Try the Pesto Pollo but asked for breaded chicken. Sooooo delicious. Birthday celebration? Enjoy your free Tiramasu. Wonderful ambiance, great wait staff and awesome drink menu too!!
The entire experience was awesome. The hostess was a sweetheart and juggled my reservation when my Dad was quite late. Our server was terrific and friendly. The bartender was super cool and the food was delightful!
Great food, great service, great ambiance, great neighborhood spot.
I have not been here in years, but really enjoyed my visit this time. I really like the ambiance, and my Chicken Parm was fantastic.
Food took too much long to arrive, was mediocre and served barely warm. The server was very pleasant, but forgot the salad, served it with the meal after being reminded, said she would take it off the bill and then did not. There is more, but I choose not to elaborate.
Brunch .. too loud ... Can't believe Bloody Mary Bar got a Westword "best" rating. Been to way better. Food OK .. nothing special !
Favorite Brunch Spot!!! Bloody Bar is Insane!!! Great Menu with Standard Brunch Fare & a Few Surprises!!
Very good dining experience, Will most certainly return.
We had Lasagne and Chicken Caprese and both were excellent. They are so busy that the service can sometimes be a bit slow and you will definitely want to make reservations if you want to get a table on the weekends.
Excellent as always. The lasagna portion was big enough to feed a family, but I managed to eat most of it. One of our favorites. I recommend the elevated tables in the bar.
Excellent staff and food!!!
Took the lovely lady there the other night based on her suggestion and as a first timer was blown away. I see now why she continues to return time and time again, as will I now!
Great space with a good amount of parking across the street in surface lot. Dinner and drinks were amazing!
Everything was good, except that there was a hair in the bread basket we ordered while we were waiting on our food. Our meal was delicious. Service was great. Ambience was fantastic too.
Great food, great service. The Veal Parmesan was the best we have ever had. Our server, Mary was excellent! Even though it is a long drive for us, we will be going back.