Freds Madison at Barneys New York
Book your next event with us
Instantly increase your points with dining rewards
See availability for bonus point tables
Sun 5:00PM - 6:00PM
Mon - Fri 5:00PM - 6:00PM 8:00PM - 9:00PM
The worst restaurant on the upper east side. Prices are ridiculously high. Even the bread is stale. I cook a far superior breast of chicken. Question... the place was virtually empty, but we were caught in a rain storm. Why would anyone elect to go there?
Trendy! The Belgian pommes frites are AMAZING!
Very disappointing. We have dined at Fred’s for many years and this is the first time the food wasn’t good. I wanted to order a lobster club and they said they didn’t have lobster. I ordered a turkey club instead and the turkey did not taste fresh. I left it on my plate and did not complain and neither the waiter nor the busboy chose to comment. My husband ordered the chicken livers and they were over cooked. The buffalo cheese on the caprese salad was tasteless. The fettuccine pasta with red sauce and the hamburger were very good.
I always love their chewy sourdough bread and vegan daily soups; vegetable ravioli were amazing today as well!
The Sunday Brunch Special Straussie’s Bagel Basket is one of many reasons to go. The bagels are among the best that can be found in the city. The bagels have a excellent crust, good texture and consistency and above all are the perfect size. Bagels are served with vegetable, scallion and plain smears, they were delectable bites to savour. During our visit we also selected the Mushroom risotto special and Eggs Benedict. Food as always, was well prepared and seasoned. Service was attentive but not intrusive, allowing us to enjoy our dining experience. Freds has been consistent in their food quality and service delivery, that once again satisfied and delighted us.
Quality has dropped a lot. The chopped salad was wilty and old. It looked like it was sitting around for awhile. Service was bad, we had to hail down service many times.
There are no words, only stars, and as always this was a 5 ⭐️ experience!
Place is old and shabby - glassware and silverware were old and dirty. Service was fair to lousy. And food was not good. No need to ever return.
Fred’s was always a favorite. Recently, however, I’ve noticed that they don’t seem to value Open Table reservations, seating customers in the worst area, with diffident service. I no longer wish to pay these prices, only to leave feeling dissatisfied and feeling taken advantage of. I was so displeased this last visit that I left without returning to the shoe department to purchase a four-figure pair of boots I’d planned to pick up. Take notice, Barneys!
Great food -great table-never disappoints!
Good is consistently wonderful!
Been to Fred’s many times — always amazing
Very nice place to eat a good meal. Sophisticated enjoyable
Our server, Aggie, was exceptional!!!
Food had no flavor. Definitely over rated. Service was good. Would not give another try.
Food was bad. Did not receive what we ordered.
After shopping at Barney’s or just craving great comfort food, Fred’s is the best! Spaghetti and meatballs with perfectly cooked spaghetti or lasagna are as good as you can get anywhere.
Fred's is kind of unique because it's inside Barney's Department Store on the 9th floor. When we were there for an early dinner, it was quiet, and had a nice atmosphere - spacious with lots of windows. The food is very fresh and good. The service is also good. The only downside is it's on the pricey side.
Service was very good but too prompt. I would have preferred to have been given more time between dishes. All too quick & no real time to relax. Even after my wife & I requested a longer break in between dishes the food came out far too quick. Also my salmon ,although delicious,was over cooked.
Branzino was amazing!
Unfamiliar with New York and looking for a quiet dinner with my daughters that would not cost a mortgage, I found Freds. My first impression was the place had been there a while and was favored among the locals. We were there on a Thursday evening, about 7pm, and the restaurant was nearly full. The 3 of us were seated promptly and while not ignored, service was a bit slow in coming. The place was cozy, bright and quiet. We started with cocktails and grilled calamari appetizer which was fresh and very tasty. Next, we had the steak Frites and chicken parm. The portions could have been shared among us but having a sumptuous take-home did not disappoint either. We opted for the dessert sampler, which included tiramisu per our request. Our server was skilled and I honestly feel that we could have asked for anything and he would have done his best accommodate. Freds is not inexpensive, but also not over the top. It is on my list of places to return to.
Always a treat 😎
Senior Reporter Trip Advisor HOTEL & RESTURANT Expert
If the friend was from out of town and wanted to see a certain privileged thy[eo of diner gathered in one spot who didn't rea;;y care how much it cost and didn't mind noise at one in the afternoon...bring em on.
The veal was dry and burnt- our server agreed. It was later in the day on a Sunday afternoon so things were slow.
It literally had burnt edges. We should have returned both plates but were too hungry and running late for our movie.
Not good at all.
Excellent brunch. Love the scrambled eggs and toast. Favorite place always
The food was disappointing and the service was poor. We had to continually ask to have our water replenished.
Consistent, fresh, on the expensive side, but most enjoyable for lunch.
The waiter at the adjacent table dropped food on me (staining my clothing) and wasn’t very apologetic. Did me a favour to call the manager. Manager also didn’t address this adequately and wasn’t apologetic.
Our own waiter never bothered to offer us bread, forgot to bring our drinks and disappeared for a long time. Overall, this was an extremely disappointing experience. Will not be rushing back there.
Food was not good this time.
our favorite. Always excellent food, attentive service an comfortable sound level. We are always welcomed like family.
Better place for lunch
For dinner, service and food preparation were poor.
When we complained, manager didn’t care.
We felt it was way overpriced but quality was good.
Fred's has always been my go to, I have been going to this place for YEARS, the staff is the so kind and always accommodating, food is amazing. Unlike most I do not go to people watch although there are and have been plenty of celebs there, they obviously go for a reason. One main reason I go as well, bartender Hassan is so lovely, dear friend of ten years, and always takes care of me. I never sit at a table. And if you see him interact with others you will see he is as lovely with other customers as well. From Senegal he is a kind soul and makes your experience so much more enjoyable. Go to Fred's, order ANYTHING, sit at the bar if you can, or anywhere, you are sure to be delighted!! From a loyal customer since I have been in manhattan!!! Always Five stars!!!
Food is always good, service is slow.
Excellent food and service. Great desserts. Love the brisket and potatoes
This is one of my favorite restaurants. We often meet friends here to catch up because we can hear one another. The service is steady, the food really well prepared and the location perfect.
Love this place
Food was terrible; my sandwich was dry and my wife’s salad had too much dressing. The table and seats were cramped.