See availability for bonus point tables
Fri - Sat 8:45PM - 10:00PM
The lobster bisque soup was delicious and the 10oz NY steak for just as delicious.
Top notch as always
It was ok. Nothing great
I’ve been to many steakhouses in Westchester, both more expensive and less expensive. the experience was fine - service was good, everyone helpful and polite - but I found the food mediocre. my steak was undercooked from what I ordered (I wanted medium, not medium rare) and it had a lot of fat on it. I just wasn’t impressed. I’ll go elsewhere in the future.
Received a gift card from my sons as a birthday gift. My husband and I had a great dinner here, comfortable conversation due to acoustics and terrific waiter service. Was served a nice plate of biscotti for my dessert
This was our second visit to Frankie & Johnnie’s and after surviving two storms a flooded basement and being stranded on MetroNorth this was a treat that we were both looking forward to. We were seated upstairs at a spacious table for two on the balcony overlooking the first floor. The ambiance is warm and elegant. The wait staff are attentive and engaging without being intrusive. They are well trained and considerate of each other as they weave back and forth with trays of drinks and, stands for larger trays of food. The Pinot Noir was excellent. We shared the house salad, surf and turf and a baked potato. Each dish was perfectly prepared. We are looking forward to our next visit.
Excellent food, although too much dressing on arugula salad. Steak was delicious, although I expected more than 4 or 5 fries when the description noted steak fries as part of the entree.
Quality of the food is below standard for the price.. Steak is good but the salad is wilted and the hash browns tastes like fish. I don't think they change the oil they cook in! Service was great but disappointing overall.
We love this restaurant
Atmosphere all amazing
Never have we had a bad meal
As always, the food and service was excellent. But, as with any good restaurant, it is not inexpensive. It always is a pleasure to eat in a good steakhouse.
Very disappointed. We had been wanting to try this place for a long time. We can now say we've tried it and will not return. It's extremely over-priced and under-whelming. It's an ordinary old fashioned steak house with a fairly limited menu and nothing special, especially considering the prices. Our waiter was fine -- nothing special. Our food was under-cooked and lacking in flavor. Medium rare should not be blue and cool in the very center. Everything is a la carte, so with our over-priced mediocre meat we also ordered over-priced mediocre vegetables. The portion size for the over-priced vegetables was miniscule. The wine list was very extensive and nice, but also over-priced. We will not be back.
Frankie and Jonnies was everything I had hopped for! The service was great, food was spectacular and we would definitely come again.
I had spent a lot of time researching steak houses in the area- I live in Norwalk. A friend mentioned Frankie and jonnies, and we had to check it out.
Great food, but the noise level was a bit much. We also waited 30 minutes for a table despite having made reservations. We’ll go again, but we might avoid busy nights moving forward.
I brought my son to this restaurant on recommendation from a friend. It was my sons 18th birthday. I thought they would make a whole fanfare, maybe even a well decorated plate with a tiny cupcake. What we got was a scrape of very iced over freezer burned ice cream and someone streaked some chocolate over it and stuck a candle. The presentation was atrocious. Even being ice cream the presentation was poor. The steaks were good; the Mac and cheese was very thin and runny.
Overall steaks were good. Service was mediocre at best. Wouldn’t go back. For the previous reviews and the cost I expected so much more.
Our favorite steakhouse in Westchester. Wait staff couldn't have been nicer. Went for Valentine's Day dinner. Nice, reasonable wine selection.
Great experience all around
My wife and I booked an early dinner on a Saturday night and were the second couple to be seated. We had a salad and oysters to start and shared a steak and lobster with a few sides. The restaurant soon filled up but our service was attentive without being intrusive. The food was truly outstanding and although the bill was more than the tab for our usual Saturday night dinners it was worth every penny. We will be back soon,
We shared a Porterhouse for 3 and it was outstanding. We even were able to have it Medium and Medium Rare! The Tomato & Mozzarella was delicious. Atmosphere is beautiful. Our server was attentive and pleasant. Just a great place. Look forward to returning again soon.
Excellent. Our waiter could not have been better and the food was delicious.
Always a favorite!
Great place. If you want a good steak this is your place when your near Rye NY. The Kale & Mushroom Side was incredible. Steaks amazing. Lamb Chops the same! Well done.
Beautiful restaurant. Terrific food and great service. Just like going to the New York Frankie and Johnnie's without having to go to NY.
Strike three. Went there with my two daughters on Monday at 6pm to give it one more try. Previous two times steak and sides came out lukewarm. So this time I specifically told the waiter actually begged the waiter to please make sure the steak comes out sizzling. Nope.....lukewarm again. The owners/chefs should head to Benjamins Steakhouse in Hartsdale or Lenny’s in Larchmont to take a lesson. Worst part is the place was empty. Not sure how you screw that up. Sent the steak back to have it come back hot and while we waited had the sides which of course were lukewarm but we were starving so we ate them. Re-heated steak is just not that good. And the porterhouse for three is a complete ripoff....way too small. $250 plus tip for the three of us......really disappointed.
My chicken scaparelli was not what I expected. It was too hot and spicy and the chicken was nothing special.
Great Steaks and excellent Bourbon selection
Always a great experience.
Delicious food, great service and awesome dessert!
The steak was phenomenal!
We went to dinner here for Christmas Eve and had an absolutely amazing meal! Would love to return for another special occasion. The steak was excellent!
Have not been to this restaurant in many years. Last time the food and service were off. This time, the food was very good, caesar salad for two of us was excellent, cold, crisp and great parm slice on top, steak cooked perfectly, onion rings great, truffle fries not hot enough..but the service was bad. Get some more servers, our server was obviously over worked. It took many attempts to get her attention to order a bottle of wine, and forgotten , and literally thrown down on the table in front of me, and then tried to get us to finish the bottle much too quickly. Water had to be begged for. I know it's the holiday season, but for these prices, please hire more help.
this was our 10th+ time there and it was great as usual my wife and I couldn't eat all the food so we asked for left overs to take home. wouldn't you know they forgot to pack our hardly touched sauteed spinach. check you take homes next time.
Frankie & Johnnie's continues to be one of the top places in Westchester for my money... great ambiance, a warm and welcoming staff, a teffiiric wine list, outstanding steaks and all around well prepared food... I have had guests order fish and they are just has happy. This is a place that should be on your short list.
Food was wonderful. Only disappointment is that I had notified that it was my husbands birthday. Nothing happened. No singing, no dessert, nothing. When I asked the hostess about that she said it was her fault and would do better the next time. Hardly an apology for a $200+ dinner for two.
We celebrated our 30th wedding anniversary and our daughters and almost son in laws engagement. It was a delicious and elegant dinner with attentive and professional service. Pricey but very worth it.
The food is excellent and the servers are very friendly and attentive.
The new chef provides delicate flavor combinations and creative options in appetizers and daily specials. And their reputation as a Top Rate steak house remains sterling.
We enjoyed catching up with our children home from college. They were craving a perfect steak and that’s what they received. Ambiance was very relaxful and service was exceptional.
Looking forward to our next visit.
It was a engagement dinner for our daughter. We requested a special table and a bottle of chilled champagne with our reservation. It was all perfect! Great food and service.
Hands down the best Ribeye I've ever been served .. coming from a real steak snob it's saying a lot ..
I ordered my typical black and blue ribeye and they totally nailed it. The waiter was a bit frustrating but we just kinda ignored that.
According to the hostess, my reservation was for 2 people, not 4. Therefore, I had to wait
over 1/2 for a table. The table was not a table I would ordinarily accept, but the restaurant was full. I am sure if they had 4 not 2 people the table I was given would have been the same.
Saturday night is not a good night to judge a restaurant. I frequently dine at Frankie & Johnnnie's and know the owner very well. The service was slow, but he made up for it.
Please note above that this reservation WAS for 4, not 2 people.
We went on restaurant week and ordered off of the special menu. I thought the portions were meager, the choices limited and very disappointing. We go often and generally find the food good, so if they can't keep up their high standard during restaurant week, they should not participate!
Impressive to say the least! The steak was to die for! Wish it wasn't so expensive so I could go more often.