Frankie & Johnnie's Steakhouse - Rye
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sealed or wrapped utensils used
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
- Staff temperature check required
Rib Eye Steak
Prime Beef Sliders
Best steak in westchester
If you're planning to order a steak and do the classic American steakhouse dinner, then Frankie and Johnny's is a worthy spot. This is your white table cloth, martini + ribeye + potatoes-au-gratin kind of place. They do that food very well. Be weary of drifting to other choices on the menu (farm raised salmon?? cacio e pepe swimming in thick sauce?? beef tartare served with plantain chips??), as we were unpleasantly surprised by the lack of craft and preparation of these dishes. Stick to the basics and you'll have a lovely meal!
Excellent food, wonderful service
Outstanding, as always!
We so enjoy the food, the ambiance, and the friendly people! Food is always delicious!
This is a local Westchester steakhouse. If you keep that as your lens you will be fine with the steak. My issue was I was expecting, e.g., Keens or Wolfgangs. With that as the expectation I wish I tried Flames in Elmsford instead.
So we went here for my wife's 70th birthday. Appetizers were great, wine too, but when it came to the mail course which was filet mignons things went south. We have been here before so we were shocked that the quality of the beef was so bad. We didn't complain (we should have) and took what we didn't eat (about 1/2 of each portion) in doggie bags. We tossed the take-home in the trash container in the parking lot. So disappointed. This will be our last trip here. Benjamin's Steakhouse here we come!
Oh, and the dinner for two cost me $360!
Just no words but amazing
Vass makes everything perfect
The Octopus was outstanding as well as our Porterhouse for two. Our friend had the Veal Chop Tomahawk a special that night. Cooked perfectly and delicious! Great side dishes. Excellent wine list.
Service was attentive . A special place for sure.
Fran the manager was amazing and so was Ron our server.
We had an excellent experience! The food was amazing & service was as well. We also appreciated the screens up for extra covid protection.
Second to none !
Fantastic! Porterhouse for 2 medium rare was prepared perfectly! The beef was of the highest quality and was seasoned to perfection. Tuna Tartare was outstanding, and the French Onion Soup was the best I ever had (yes, you read that correctly!). Very safe and socially distanced restaurant. Can’t wait to go back!
Greatest ribeye anywhere. Go and enjoy. Nice size alcohol drinks.
excellent service and food was a work of art will definitely return
Excellent food, fantastic steak.
I've been to 30+ steakhouses in the NYC metro area and I am impressed by the quality of food and service here.
There's so many good steakhouses in/around NYC it's tough to stand out but I'd rate this a cut above most.
Perfect atmosphere and better food
They couldn’t find my open table reservation , the service was mediocre and the prices were outrageous.
I always like a big, rare, dry-aged Prime porterhouse for my birthday, and there are three steakhouses at the absolute top of my list: Peter Luger, Frankie and Johnnie and (if it's still there) Da Ivo in Venice, Italy. F&J never disappoints. The Rye outlet is totally different than the NYC original - instead of a raucous (pre Covid), checkerboard tablecloth joint, it's an elegant, spacious and airy white tablecloth restaurant.
Ourserice was excellent. I brought an "88 Chateau Latour and the waiter/sommelier properly used a CO2 opener to assure the cork came out clean and whole. I don't mind the corkage - these days, I want to do anything I can to keep my favorite places going. We ordered twice as much food as we needed so we'd have leftovers and a big bill - we have been out so seldom, why not splurge? I had a half-dozen Littleneck clams. Wow! They were the perfect size - medium to small - icy, briny, sparkling and the best clams I've had in several years. My wife had the East coast oysters, and they were big, smooth, and likewise, as good as they get.
On to the main event! The beef was absolutely perfect. I had asked for it "rare- red and basically raw in the middle, black on the outside, and barely warm on the inside. A notch past black and blue. And, man, he nailed it!! The home fries with onions were just exactly right, and the creamed spinach completed the holy trinity.
I don't believe there is a better steakhouse between Brooklyn and the North Pole. Some are close but it's hard to say any are better. Everything I have ever seen come out of the F&J kitchen looks like a feast, but all I ever eat is clams, potatoes and steak. And I feel blessed to have it just 15 minutes away when we aren't in the City. Quarantine in Westchester is made a lot more tolerable by a careful trip to Rye. Don't deny yourself... GO!!
Outstanding Filet with bone. Nice wine selection. Service was great. Fun atmosphere
Literally the best steak i have had in NY. Very courteous, great drinks, ambiance was perfect
Food was delicious, wait staff amazingly attentive, great atmosphere! All around WONDERFUL and PERFECT place for an occasion or anytime!!
It was a good dinner. Nice time spacing between courses.
The food is always excellent and the service top notch. Our server, Dean, is always very attentive. The burgers and filet mignon are prepared as requested, medium rare and delicious.
We had a great experience here. Very clean staff were very professional and
Attentive. The food was amazing. We're definitely returning to this beautiful restaurant.
Dinner was wonderful as always. A great time was had by all.
Very good overall
Wonderful food, great service. Expensive, but well worth it for a special occasion, and a great night out
Excellent steaks cooked exactly as we wanted. Professional and experienced staff from being greeted to being served.
We had a great time and enjoyed a birthday surprise for Kayla. Service and food were awesome. Wine as well!
Everything was just what we needed. The food was delicious and the staff was terrific.
we went on Sunday early evening, had a great time for my fiancées birthday. It was absolutely perfect. There were eight of us and everyone enjoyed their dinner and experience.
After going several times a year since they opened, it is amazing how they get it right every single time.
It was good
Food was good
Definitely will be back
Food was good. Staff was unfriendly and made experience unpleasant.
You can order delivery directly from Frankie & Johnnie's Steakhouse - Rye using the Order Online button. Frankie & Johnnie's Steakhouse - Rye also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (914) 925-3900.
Frankie & Johnnie's Steakhouse - Rye is rated 4.8 stars by 879 OpenTable diners.
Frankie & Johnnie's Steakhouse - Rye does offer gift cards which you can purchase here http://s.thegiftcardcafe.com/zBWrLm.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.