We love eating at the Forebay whenever we are in Hershey. The food is always good and the servers very polite. I love the Pretzel with mustard just wish they would give you more.
We are upset that they don’t take reservations year round because of the near by Hershey Park.
Very slow kitchen. The waitress told me there was a "mishap" in the kitchen, but didn't bother to explain.
I ate on the patio, and it became obvious that this was a bit of a hike for the waitress. LONG wait for food, drink refills, and finally, the bill.
Or maybe I became invisible? Hate it when that happens.
Forebay remains one of our favorite restaurants in the greater Hershey area. Food is consistent and good. Nice variety of seafood offered. Wine selection complimentary to the food served. Service is always good and ambience enjoyable. We recommend this place to locals and visitors alike. Give it a shot!
I came here for business in the area with my wife. I have been to many hotel restaurants in my day and I am telling you that this was by far the best experience I have ever had. I was thoroughly impressed with the maitre d. I believe his name was Ryan. He was a great first impression and even offered to help me out for the rest of my stay if I needed anything. I actually gave him my card because that is someone I would want working for me. I had Jim as a waiter. He was more than exceptional. He was able to give me suggestions and recommended a few items to me.
This restaurant is decorated like a barn and has the most perfect atmosphere. It is semi-dark, but gives off a cozy ambiance. I had a Ribeye and my wife had a 5 oz filet. Both were done perfectly. We had a chocolate molten cake to share and you could tell it was made in house and was delicious. We were thoroughly impressed and will absolutely be back when I have business in the area again.
Took my wife there for her birthday. The appetizers - lamb ribs and shrimp - were a delicious start. The short ribs and the halibut with risotto were worth a return visit, hopefully very soon.
Our server was efficient and friendly.
Had a great meal! The Short Rib & Chips app was fantastic. Excellent wine selection, though predictably expensive. Great service....very professional and attentive.
A very nice restaurant conveniently located in the Hershey Lodge. Friendly and attentive service and good food.
My husband Ordered the 16oz cowboy ribeye, was properly cooked to medium but that’s about it. Had zero flavor. I had the filet it was cooked correctly but was very fatty and had no taste I order the chocolate sauce on the side and it was good that I did to give it flavor. Service was not completely terrible but was unable to obtain a second beverage. Would not go back.
We really enjoyed the barbecued ribs! They were plentiful and delicious! Service was great!
Outstanding food and the service was great. The waiter was so patient with my two kids who were under two!
Our experience was wonderful, the food choices great, the waiter and other staff very friendly. I love the pretzel rolls with mustard dip.
Filet Mignon was cooked to the correct temp but the piece of steak itself was not a quality piece for the price. Never got the side sauce option. Waitress was short, not too friendly. There was a birthday party with children and they had horns and were blowing them. Took a while to get our wine.
Great food, friendly staff, relaxing atmosphere. Our waiter was great with working with my food allergies.
The server who waited on us was top-notch. Incredibly helpful, professional, and kind. The ambiance of the restaurant is great and you can't go wrong with any of the chocolate-themed cocktail offerings. The meals are a little pricey, but it's a great option for a special night out.
a good for a nice night out. The chairs were unconfortabel but not enough to miss eating there
The waitress was absolutely wonderful, however the food was nothing to write home about. I ordered the Cesar salad, it was just LONG lettuce with a few croutons and cheese. It actually looked like they just took lettuce and placed it on a plate without even cutting it at all. I ordered the chicken- I took one bite and that was about it. It was very dry and I didn't care for the potatoes either. No flavor whatsoever. My husband ordered the salmon and he didn't care for it at all. I would choose a different restaurant if you're staying at the Hershey Lodge. I won't be dining here again.
The menu is creative, the food was excellent and the service great!
Excellent restaurant. Delicious food. Perfect service! Highly recommend!
Our dinner was amazing. The atmosphere was very nice Our service was impeccable. The waiter was very attentive to our table even though he had numerous other tables. He suggested a appetizer that was fabulous and went out of his way to make our dinner special. He was very knowledgeable on the menu and the items that was available to us. He also went out of his way to get my son a chocolate milkshake from another area of the hotel.
There was a convention so the noise level was higher than usual but we’ve been here many times and the service and food never disappoint.
I would have given this a 5 Star Rating if it was not for the way the our Waiter greeted us, his attitude and the delay time between our seating and our waiter arriving and the fact that I felt the special was a bit pricey. We used Open Table to reserve a table for 4 at 6:30. We arrived at 6:25 to make sure that we were there early. We were seated right away by the hostess who told us that Jim would be with us shortly. We waited for several minutes before Jim showed up; when he arrived he promptly stated "Sorry for the delay I was talking Real estate in Harrisburg- that's kind of my thing and was tied up with my customer." My husband and I were immediately annoyed and put off by this clear lack of interest in our table. Mind you, I had a 6 year old and 3 year old with me who were coloring and being little gentlemen at the moment. Jim immediately rushed through the specials and seemed highly annoyed that I asked him to repeat the Sea Bass Special a second time. Now, once we were ready to order, he was particularly helpful in deciding what I would like to drink and our orders were done correctly. Therefore, if he has been more concerned with us an less with his real estate chatter, I would have given this a higher review.
First time here, the food and cocktails were wonderful, the chef makes his own pretzel rolls and outstanding mustard to dip the rolls into as the table bread, in a word incredible!! With this being February and Hershey, we had our arms “twisted” and I had the Chocolate Manhattan and my wife the Chocolate Martini both were amazing, worth stopping by just for the cocktails! We had the local cheese and meats appetizer which was a fine representation from local farms. For our main course, I had the fish of the day, a seared halibut that was prepared to perfection and my wife had the Chicken Schnitzel which was incredible! For dessert we had the chocolate mousse and the pound cake, both were outstanding!! The service from Andrea and her assistant made for a very enjoyable evening!! We look forward to returning in the very near future!!!
Great meal. Portions are large. Hostess and waiter seemed to have a bit of an argument about table sizes when we checked in. Service was great until time to pay - took a long time for the waitress to come back - would have just left the payment but we wanted a bag for our three containers of leftovers (finally another waiter came by and saw right away we needed a bag without us asking). Have one of their many chocolate martinis - yummy!
We had a wonderful time. Our waitress Kim was exceptional. Her honesty and friendliness made our dinner and time enjoyable.
Dinner was great and the drinks at the bar prior to dinner were amazing.
Nice quiet atmosphere, the service was a little slow. The food was excellent. Great place for a nice date night.
Wonderful steak dinner & the service was top shelf!
Fantastic! Always a great place for Dinner
Delicious food and friendly service make for a great date night!
Our experience was mediocre. Slow service because i believe they were understaffed that day, steak had no flavor and was tough even though it was medium rare... really loved the ambiance though
Great meal for my wife and I. Had king salmon and Chilean sea bass, was delicious. Finished wish dark chocolate creme brulee and dark chocolate martini, WOW SO GOOD!
Always such a pleasure. You eat in a very nice barn!
Everything was outstanding. Our server was very professional. The food was very good. I would recommend this restaurant to anyone. Thank you for an outstanding experience.
I love a restaurant that offers healthy meals not only for myself but for my children as well. Not all kids want to eat chicken fingers or mac and cheese, my children loved the steak and salmon options!
this place is highly recommended and I would defiantly return at a later date
Excellent food and service.
Great evening with friends, wonderful good, great service.
Will highly recommend to friends.
Consistently good. Menu, service, preperation.
I made a special request to have sweet potato fries when we arrived because my girlfriend just loves them. And they actually made them even though they didn’t have them on their menu. Great service!
Food was good but portions were small. Sam was my server and she was great.