Fleming's Steakhouse - Indianapolis
Welcome to Your Indianapolis Fleming’s.
Book your next event with us
We expected higher quality food for the price. Very disappointing.
It's not as engaging as it was a couple years ago when we discovered it.
Our server (Tom) did a fine job delivering our food and refills. Never asked once. But he wasn't engaged. Gave us someone else's take home bag. Gave our bag to someone else. Not bad - just not what we've been used to.
The manager passed our table 4 times and did not engage us even once at any level.
My complaint, that I wanted to share with the manager was that 3 bites into my salad, I reached for the salt shaker, which was empty. No foul there - it happens. Our server's assistant (who brought us water and bread) was close. I caught her eye and told her the shaker was empty. She politely apologized and took the shaker - and then never came back. As in NEVER came back. For anything, the entire night. I finally got up and walked about 6 tables over to retrieve a salt shaker so I could finish my salad - but that was 12 minutes later (yes, I noted the time after a while).
The food is always good. Last night just didn't turn my head enough to be glad I dropped $155 for a meal. I can get ignored at Outback...
Fantastic night at Fleming’s
First time to try Fleming’s.........completely exceeded my expectations!
I'm a wimp when it comes to hot or spicy food, so I have learned that there are just some side dishes I NEVER order. The Au Gratin potatoes, creamed spinach, and macaroni & cheese are things to stay away from if you don't want jalapeno flavor in them. It's quite a shame, though, because I have tried each of these and would love them if not for the spice. The onion rings ARE to die for, though!
Everything was wonderful! Music was a little too loud - hard to hear conversation sometimes but that is simply a minor comment!! Thank you for a wonderful experience!
Fleming’s is our favorite place to go for wonderful food and service. Highly recommend.
We had a beautiful dinner, it was our 36th anniversary, Mark the manager and the staff made it special, we will be back very soon.. thank you..
Everything was outstanding— excellent food and service— thank you.
The second time we have been to Fleming's. Once in Nashville and now in Indy. Service and the food are great. Steak, chicken ,and the salmon were all good with their own unique flavors. I will go back again.
Waiter was very very friendly but overall service was not as timely and coordinated as should be expected for an upper end steak restaurant.
The steak was amazing. The crab cake were not the same as last time..., had more salt. Smashed potatoes were excellent!!!
Service was excellent. Food was very good except for the salads. Both the Caesar and the Chopped salads appear to have been prepared in advance and refrigerated. The greens were dried out and chilled. The Caesar was mostly stalks from the Romaine -- little in the way of leaves. I asked for a replacement of the Caesar -- the 2nd one was only slightly better. For the prices of this restaurant, salads should be freshly made and above average in quality. I've had much better Caesar salads elsewhere at a lower cost.
Our server, Akbar, made the entire experience really special. He was attentive and responsive to our requests with a personal touch.
Great food & service.
$57 strip was not very good, very tough. Ordered it medium so that should not have been a problem
As always the food at Fleming’s was excellent. The service not so much. We ordered an appetizer and nice bottle of Silver Oak Cab. The server never offered to decant the wine which at a restaurant in Fleming’s class should be SOP. After finishing the appetizer we place our dinner order - salad, entree, and side. The server didn’t bring the bread offering until serving the entree. Would have liked that with the salad.
Unfortunately although we have not been to Fleming’s in several years we had the same opinion of the service as we had previously - mediocre. The service level detracted from what should have been a great experience.
Just a couple of small issues but that was probably due to how busy they were. Overall it was a great experience
great venue with great food and great service. everyone was very professional and polite. a great night to enjoy. thanks!!!
Best on the N Side of Indy
Wish the Wines by the glass hadn’t been paired down but still plenty to choose
Great service and always excellent atmosphere heads over Ruth’s Chris, Morton’s, Sullivan’s, Ocean Prime
Extremely disappointed after hearing great things about this restaurant. Grateful that we had a gift card and this wasn't money spent out of our own pocket. The restaurant was not crowded, yet service was very slow. Our app was decent, but when the main course arrived my husband's steak was raw. They took it back and re-fired it, basically burning it and it tasted like charcoal. Needless to say he had one bite and did not eat it. They asked if we wanted another one, but considering how long it was taking to receive service, we said no. They even asked if we wanted to take it home with us, which was odd considering my husband was not about to eat it. My dinner was good (scallops), but our sides were terrible as well. The brussel sprouts were soaked in balsamic and that is basically all you could take. The onion rings collapsed as soon as you picked them up and were soaked in oil. They did not charge us for the steak, which was commendable, but they didn't really apologize for anything else or offer us anything other than a new steak to make up for all the issues. We will not be returning as we have been to many other steakhouses that do a far better job.
Everything was great !
Very disappointed with the food quality, didnt put up a fuss cause it was a holiday. Would have thought more attention to food quality on this special day. I didn't want to embarrass my date with complaining about the food quality.
The crab legs & lobster were amazing!!!
From the moment we arrived until completion of the evening, everything was superb.
Everything was perfect. Expensive dinner - 2 people, a couple drinks and tip = $300, but it was done very well. Shout out to Frankie the bartender, Curtis the server and Curtis the Manager. All made it a very enjoyable night.
Great food. Steaks were perfect. Service was also great.
We were immediately greeted by the manager and given a wonderful seat. The wine selection is wonderful as is the selection of food. The tomahawk ribeye is amazing and no other steakhouse seems to get the steaks cooked like Flemings...a medium rare center with a seared crispy exterior. We will definitely return
Very overpriced for no reason, average steak quality.
Jacob Carlisle was our server and the night was perfect. We were celebrating an 80th birthday, and the entire evening was lovely.
Was there on Wednesday evening to celebrate birthdays. Restaurant was sparsely populated which made it quiet. Waiter was great, food was very good. Waiter gave us a great wine choice and the host took our picture and put it in a frame. Great evening... we really like this restaurant. Most of our special occasions are celebrated here, especially when we order steak.
We reserved a table to celebrate a birthday and received top notch service. They took a picture of us as we sat down and provided it to us in a frame before we even ordered. The food was delicious and the servers were friendly and attentive. Great experience!
We sat near kitchen and it was awfully noisy. I had to ask if they were doing Devour Indy and the waiter begrudgingly brought us the menu. It is too pricey and cannot compete with the other Steak Houses in the corridor. It is not the Flemings it used to be. We will not return.
We’ve always had great experiences at Fleming’s and this was no exception. The service has always been great with very knowledgeable staff and we have never found ourselves waiting on service. My filet was cooked a perfect medium rare and my wife’s salmon was flaky and flavorful, and we always have to get the lava cake with the house chantilly cream. Fleming’s is one of our favorite restaurants and is always our top choice for special occasions.
Fantastic service, food was hot, loved the Chef’s menu selections!
I do not routinely go to steak places as I have limited d red meat and actually make a great steak at home. However, we have always had an excellent experience at Flemings!! Service, food and cocktails are first rate!!
The crabs were an incredible disappointment for the $80 price charged. The amount of crab combined with limited sweetness and dryness of the crab meat was again, disappointing.
amazing food, service, and location. Very nice staff.
They were overwhelmed. You could tell as soon as we were seated. We had our menus 15 minutes before order was taken. Then the water brought us a full glass of drinks to leave at our table because he didn’t have time to wait on on because he had to many tables. Wasn’t the waiters fault. To pay this much for a meal and to have service like this is very frustrating. I could go on. Just not worth it. Maybe it will be better next time around.