Steaks are very good but small for $50@. Old Fashioneds are not good enough to bring $13@, very average. This is an authentic supper club to try.

The atmosphere was great as well as the food and having the valet parking added to the professionalism of this fine place I will definitely be back for the steaks and shrimp.

The steaks were just ok (they weren't cooked evenly and lacked seasoning) the au jus was amazing. Basically just a high priced basic meal! (Wine was great tho and reasonably priced)

It was just ok

I've been there many times and I have never had a better steak anywhere

Very nice unexpected experience. Would go there for business dinner again.

Thanks Stelio.
Great food.
Great service.
As usual.

We celebrated our anniversary here Saturday and loved the food, service, and the old supper club feel. I mentioned it was our 13 year anniversary and our server brought us a mini key lime pie with a candle.

We finally went here after hearing how good it was for years. I'm not sure if it's relying on it's old reputation or if we missed something but it was TERRIBLE. Food was cold and bland. Service was slow and inattentive. There's is absolutely nothing that would get me to go back. There were four of us and we were all disappointed. We eat together frequently at a number of high end restaurants and have never had that happen. You can do better at literally any other steakhouse in Milwaukee.

Always wonderful food and great service!

Best Steaks in Milwaukee! Enjoy the ambiance and the service is always great!

Great prime rib! Get there early because they run out shortly after opening!

Typical Wisconsin supper club. Great bar good service , the filet was to die for but the strip was poor. Sides are generous. Live music was very good. Worth the visit for sure

Authentic supper club, Food was great! I love the relish tray, salad and bread to start with. The steak was cooked to perfection. Our waitress was exceptionally good. Great smile, very polite and knowledgeable, very attentive without being intrusive. I believe her name was Crystal.

I've been to Five O'Clock Steakhouse on a number of different occasions (date night, special even celebrations) and it never ceases to amaze me. The ambiance is from another era as you feel like you've stepped back into time into historic cocktail lounge and steakhouse.

The food is always amazing. Generally, I don't order steaks from restaurants because I typically don't think the cut of meat is worth the menu price. However, at Five O'Clock I've had almost all of the steak menu over the years and the quality of steak and precision cooking always make it an awesome dining experience.

Overall, I'd recommend this to anyone that is looking for quality drinks and a memorable steak and/or seafood dinner in a unique atmosphere. You won't be disappointed.

A get away for dinner with my husband. Very enjoyable, amazing food, great service. It is a busy place but we didn’t feel like we were in a busy restaurant. Would definitely go back.

Great night out with friends to celebrate my birthday

Excellent experience, outstanding service and very good food. Will be back again.

A must go to supper club/corner bar
worth the drive! 50's decor. Steaks as good as downtown chicago at half the price. I'm a foodie and like everything but if I want a good steak its on my grill or at Five O'clock! Unique place!

Everyone was wonderful, the bartender listened to what I kind of wine I like and recommended an amazing bottle. My wife and I will be going back many times!!!

Everything was great, very friendly and prompt staff.

Best steak I've ever had. Old fashions were also great. Eric provided great service.

Reservations were for 7pm. Were seated at 7:45pm. Shrimp appetizer was ridiculously priced--$5.00 per shrimp for very SMALL shrimp (the 15-20 per pound size) but listed as if prawn sized. Dinner set down around 8:30. I ordered the fillet Oscar medium rare--what was delivered were 2 very small fillets medium well...so I sent the dinner back. New meal delivered around 8:45pm--again 2 very small fillets. I do not understand why, for $38.00, i was being served 2 small fillets??? This restaurant was excellent when run as Coerpers 5 O'Clock club...now as the Five O'Clock, not so much...we will not be returning!!!

Had an awesome meal and our service was fantastic. I highly recommend this place for dinner!!!

Food was amazing and our waiter Greg was, fun and attentive.

We were first timers. The food and service staff were excellent. The steak was perfectly cooked and generous portion. Family style salad was a treat along with the ample relish tray and warm bread.

I have hearing impairment and mentioned ahead of time. They placed us in perfect quiet table.

We met the owner who clearly knows how to treat customers. We will be back many times in future.

Bone in filet was outstanding. Service was great. Can't wait to visit again

Everything was excellent! The only critique we have is to provide more time between salad/bread and entrees. We felt a little rushed.

Outstanding as always!!

I WENT FOR MY FIANCE BIRTHDAY I WANTED TO SUPRISE HIM WITH A GIFT THAT THE WAITRESS COULD BRING OUT FOR ME WHILE WE WAIT ON THE MEAL BUT SHE WAS TO BUSY TO GIVE ME IN SPECIAL TIME TO SPEAK WITH HER ALONE OR TO GET A MANAGER FOR ME

There is nothing better than Old School restaurants.
This has it all. Drinks at the bar while they take your order and set your table with your salad and relish tray.

The food was incredible a long with very attentive staff. Perfect evening.

Only time I order steak is here! It’s outstanding!

Always have a great time at 5 O clock. I enjoy my steak everytime, I always tell people it's the best steakhouse EVER

Fantastic experience. Highly recommended for your dining experience

Reservations for wedding anniversary for 7:30pm on a Saturday night. Waited at the bar where they took our order. Seated at our table at 8:07pm. Entrees didn't arrive until 9pm. Ready to leave at 9:30pm, couldn't settle our bill until 10pm. 2.5 hours and we had a terrible server - numerous other tables were seated and turned over while we were waiting to get our meals and leave.

If the service had been better (even fair) we would definitely be back. But because of this experience, NEVER again.

Best Steak (Filet) in the country! I will only eat steak there. No where else holds a candle!

We moved here from Pa! And we heard about the steakhouse through Harley friends. We love it!
From the valet, bartenders, hostess, waitresses and cooks! Awesome experience! We bring all our friends down when they come to visit!

Our anniversary was celebrated in the cozy but spacious 5-O'Clock steakhouse. The efficiency of our server Erik coupled with the ever-helpful assistance of the owner, Mr. Stelio Kalkounos successfully created a wonderful night celebrating our anniversary; Thank you! On our visits we have experienced high quality antipasto salad with bread, steak, hand muddled Brandy Old fashion, craft beer, delicious deserts, after dinner drinks, and paradigm customer service! We drive from Cedarburg, WI and would drive twice that distance to acquire the great food and safe service at the affordable price. This is our go to "date night" place!

Loved the atmosphere of an old time steakhouse. My date ordered the bone on fillet and I the porterhouse. My steak was exceptionally good and cooked just the way I like it. My date unfortunately wanted the bone on fillet as we had never heard of it before and was eager to try it. What she got was a normal fillet. When she asked the waiter where was the bone he said he thought she had changed her mind. To be honest we discussed this bone on fillet with the waiter for over five minutes discussing the unique flavoring the bone gives the meat. To say my date was disappointed is putting it mildly. The confusion could be that this was the waiters first night.

We absolutely loved it here.