Due to the popularity of the restaurant it was almost completely booked. The hostess called after I made the reservation to inform me that due to private parties I stairs would I mind being downstairs. No problem just no ambience.
Nice menu choices , very accommodating and a friendly staff.
Great food and vegetarian-friendly menu.
great service, we had two fish meals cooked great and tasted great ,greek salad tasted great but a little small, overall we would go back
The restaurant was not very busy. We waiting at the bar for 10min before being seated. But could not get a drink. After being seated we waited another 10min before our waitress came to ask for our drink order. We ordered an appetizer and took 30min to come out.
Drinks were also lame. Fish was decent but the short rib was drenched in sauce. For the price point this was mediocre at best.
Superb dinner as usual! We sat outside on a beautiful porch and had great service. The salmon was impeccable... cooked to perfection with the accompanists of fresh in season vegetables and a yummy coconut rice! The creative drinks were delicious as well. Would always recommend this wonderful restaurant to family and friends, but we always bring them there anyway!!!
Sunday brunch with family, it was great experience here every time. Kids love the pancake and server were friendly. In addition, great location and nice view while dining.
Upon entering the restaurant we were greeted by friendly staff. We were first showed to a table on the first floor, but the room was crowded, un-inviting and cold. I asked to be seated upstairs in the main part of the restaurant and the hostess quickly showed us upstairs to a great table where we could still see a glimpse of the harbor. Good was delicious! My steak cooked perfectly and our seafood incredible. We opted for the braised calamari- excellent and the raw tuna appetizer which was a special. My husband enjoyed his scallops immensely and dessert was to die for - the flourless chocolate cake with gelato on top. Well done once again, 5th Season!!
The Kobe burger is a must here ! So flavorsome !
My wife had the gnocchi which she loves -
The Macari rose a great evening summer wine .
Great service - love coming here
The food was delicious. The staff was warm and friendly. Great experience.
Great wait staff, good food. In a good location with easy parking.
Fifth Season has always been one of our favorite dinner and drinks spot. Love it here.
Went there Labor day weekend and enjoyed it a lot. Nice menu, good drinks.
Wonderful food and service, as always. We sat downstairs, where the ambiance is not quite so good, but it is a pleasant room. I love everything about this restaurant. Great location, but difficult to find parking.
Excellent food and service! Never disappointed.
The outside of the building could use some upgrade, not very inviting...the carpet on the outside staircase is old, the gutters are growing weeds, the porch needs some renovations.
Inside, however is nice and crisp as you would expect in this class of a restaurant.
Overall, service was great and food was on time and as expected slightly surprising.
Will come back!
The Barramundi was outstanding!!
As always great service - great welcome and great food!
Love this place !
Dinner on the porch was fantastic!
The food was delicious - one of the best meals I have ever eaten! Our server was very friendly, but I do wish he had checked in a bit more frequently. At one point, I was brought the wrong drink, but after I tasted it and realized it was wrong, I had to wait a while before I saw him again to get the correct drink. Overall though, everything was wonderful, and I am looking forward to eating there again soon!
As a person with celiac disease. Eating out is always stressful. I had a delicious meal. Best of all I did not get sick! Thank you for a great tasting and safe meal. I’ll definitly be back!!
Excellent food; early bird prix fixe menu is excellent value
My husband & I have eaten here before & we were satisfied with everything,this visit we were celebrating our 49th wedding anniversary and everyone was wishing us good cheers & we received a beautiful plate with happy anniversary written on it with a delicious dessert , thank you fifth season.
We had a great time great food great service! We only have one complaint it was freezing the air conditioning was to high! Next time we will ask to sit away from the air conditioner! It was so cold it wasn’t fun! There really has to be a middle of the road! Other than that it was a wonderful evening!
Our 35th wedding anniversary. Dinner w friends. I always try for restaurants that are “fit for foodies” and Fifth Season meets my standards. I had their vegetarian special and oh my it was scrumptious. The scallops were awesome too.
The service was spectacular, food was delicious. Would highly recommend.
Came here for a date night with my wife and we loved it. We were seated outdoors since there was availability which was nice on the beautiful day. Our appetizers and food were excellent as well. Definitely a nice find and a nice location for a good meal.
Always an outstanding experience both food and service
Another grand slam hit by the fifth season. Mealwas perfect from start to finish! Ordered the fish special and the soup special both were outstanding. Service always perfect to every detail and the best view in Port Jefferson!made special accommodations for a friend and party with allergies and did so with a smile.
Always nice to be greeted by the owner as well...just to check in.
We've been coming here for years and have always had a terrific time. The food is outstanding; delicious. The acoustics are great, not loud and noisy at all. The staff is VERY attentive. The waiter we just had, Jason, was super nice; so much so that we are going to request if we can be seated in his station next time we go. You leave 100% satisfied.
Service was excellent! The waiter and staff went above and beyond to make sure my gluten free friend had substitutions when the bread and chef’s tasting came out! The food was excellent as well! Will definitely recommend and will definitely come back again!
Excellent food and sevice
The waitress was completely overwhelmed she forget to bring the muffin basket. Our food took over an hour to get and it was ok. Even the check was an issue!
Food was good. Service was very pleasant. Overall value is fair given the relatively high price. Still one of the better restaurants in Port Jefferson.
The location was great! The food was awesome and the service was wonderful! Would definitely go back!!
Wonderful menu and fantastic atmosphere. We always enjoy our meals at Fifth Season and the service is always delightful.
Main course (Sea Scallops) was excellent. Service quite good, if a bit slow. The kitchen was able to adapt my wife's main course to be non-dairy; a plus. Traffic and parking in that part of Port Jefferson is quite off putting when thinking about a return visit. Dessert was good, not excellent. Espresso was sub par.
The Fifth never disappoints. Even my hard to please teenage daughter said “best meal ever!” Kitchen very accommodating with some requested changes to sides and veggie choices. Perfect service from hostess to server. Nice extras to help celebrate an anniversary...rose pedals waiting upon arrival...complimentary dessert to finish the night. We will be back...soon!
I loved everything about my visit to the fifth season. The wait staff could not have been nicer! I just would never order duck again, anywhere. It's just not for me! For some reason I expected it to be on a bone with wing and leg instead of slices. What was I thinking. My husband said the salmon was the best he has ever had, and he's had many! My coconut martini was delicious! I will definitely go again--to try the salmon!
Great food great service very tasty
Great place great tasting food would go again a little on the pricey side but well worth it for the best tasting food they have to offer
Service was impeccable. Our waiter and assistant were efficient, charming and accommodating.
They made the dining experience perfect in all respects.