Apple Cider Braised Niman Ranch Short Ribs
sweet potato strudel, green and red cabbage & carrot slaw
Pan Seared Scottish Salmon
roasted cauliflower, sauteed spinach, caper & cured lemon gremolata
Mother's Day Menus & Specials
Join us For a Very Special Four Course Dinner Menu to Celebrate Mom. We Will be Offering Indoor Dining From 12pm to 7pm on Sunday, May 9th For Mother's Day. Make Your Reservations Today!
I always get a great meal in a great setting. Tough to find one of those places where you can get a meal that you can count on.
Great night. Food was amazing. A little pricy Drinks were good but expensive. The girls at the desk were friendly and beautiful.
Food was exceptional, service was quick and amazing. Our server, Parker, was great! Not a single complaint, what a fantastic meal.
fifth season is just the best. They are extremely careful about the Covid situation and they provide a meal as wonderful as they always have
Every time I go here I feel special. The food is fantastic and the service is impeccable. They even do extra things if you let them know that you are there for a special occasion. I love going here. This is what going out to eat should be.
As always, great food, great service. We sent the chicken back as it was rubbery. It’s not typical, as the food is always first class!
Had an amazing dinner at Fifth Season with my daughter . My duck breast was amazing and my daughters steak was perfect ! Friendly professional staff as always !
Food was outstanding!
I found the music choice to be out of step with the atmosphere.
The Easter prix fixe dinner was outstanding with regard to options and the quality.
We have had the pleasure of dining at 5th Season over five times in the last two months. Although we have frequented 5th Season many times in the past. We routinely go there for birthday celebrations, special occasions and simply for good food. The service is outstanding with a high attention to detail to your dining experience. The staff is highly attuned to gluten Free requests as well as any other special needs.
The food gets better every time we dine here. Upscale dining experience without be pretentious.
Always fresh food and great local choices.
Wonderful service - and excellent Kobe beef steak!!
The food is exceptionally tasty. From the moment you’re greeted till the time you exit the building everyone is pleasant and treat you with respect. I like that this restaurant uses locally sourced ingredients.I would definitely be going back to this all around great restaurant.
Meal was delicious. The staff was super friendly and accommodating. Everyone had a great time with the great drink selection and always great entree menu. Will be going back more frequently after a great outing with friendly staff.
Fifth season is a very nice restaurant with beautiful views. The upstairs bar is very nice. It was busy but private at the same time. There are partitions between between patrons for covid safety. The happy hour was decent with reasonably priced apps.
Dinner was also in a pleasant room with a nice view. Prices are comparable to most restaurants since covid (which Have increased).
I would recommend this restaurant.
As soon as you walk in you are welcomed by a great smile. The hospitality there is excellent. Our server Veronica is a SUPERSTAR. She was knowledgeable about the menu and was very attentive. If you have never been there, you are missing out. From date night, girls night, family night or just grabbing a drink by yourself, it is a great place to go!
5th season in Port Jefferson is exceptional. Food and Service are way above the norm
Every dish is freshly prepared and the service is outstanding.
One of our favorites for sure! Great food and friendly staff all around. Definitely recommend!
Another wonderful birthday dinner with my granddaughter
As always, The Fifth doesn't disappoint! Let's start with Rocky our bartender- AMAZING! She makes a mean Meyer Lemon martini! Our party of four enjoyed short ribs, salmon, rib eye steak & ravioli- all flavorful and cooked to perfection. We had such a wonderful night we managed to lose track of time and missed our return ferry back to Connecticut! Since The Fifth curates wonderful seasonal menus, we have already started planning for a return trip to beautiful Port Jeff to indulge in the upcoming spring menu! A big thank you to Chef John, Deb, Rocky and the entire Fifth staff! See you soon!
This was our first time eating inside a restaurant since the pandemic .
We felt it was safe to go out since we both had our 2 vaccine shots !
We were very satisfied with the food!
Our server was a very sweet ,accommodating and pleasant young lady ‘
Not quite ready for us foodies yet
We arrived a bit early for ourreservation and decided to have a drink upstairs at the bar. The waitresses were friendly and the drinks were perfectly made. Once we were seated, we looked over the menu and decided to go with the prefix dinner. We started with the Caesar salad and the empanadas which we shared. Both were very very good. For our main course we went with the Kobe burger and the pan seared sea bass.
The burger was juicy and had so much flavor. Also, I might point out that there was a generous portion of bacon on our burger... thick and crispy... not thin and wilty as you’d find in many places. The sea bass was tender and prepared nicely. The braised fennel added a nice flavor to the dish.
Sorry no pictures.... I’m typically not one to take food pix at a restaurant....
We each had the warm flourless chocolate cake for dessert, which was really creamy and chocolatey... a nice way to end a great dinner.
We had early reservations so the restaurant was not overly crowded. We sat downstairs in a small room which gave our experience there a nice intimate feel...
We will definitely go back this summer to see it in full swing.
Everything was awesome except the food. The food was delicious but everything was cold-warm. Nothing was above like warm.
Always a delicious meal and a great evening at Fifth Season. The food is consistently amazing. Highly recommend.
Service was good, food was bland. I’ve eaten here before and it was good.
A beautiful, fancy setting
Staff is so friendly
Food was delicious, cocktails were great.
Music in restaurant was on point.
My 2nd time here, will continue coming for special occasions.
The service and food are phenomenal but portions can be on the smaller side. Not terribly small but definitely not a huge plate.
The staff was extremely friendly and very attentive. The food was outstanding!
One of our favorite local places to dine. Everyone is very nice and friendly.
The food was amazing! We can’t wait to go there again!
Server was fantastic and the food was perfect
Always top notch food and fast friendly service!
Very good menu selection. The food and it's preparation are exceptional. Our waitress, Veronica, was witty, knowledgeable, understanding and above all professional.
Valentine’s Day menu was delicious!!!
Wife and I went for the first time on Saturday night, Feb. 13, with a reservation.
Welcomed upon walking in, seated immediately, and received attention from our server within just a minute or two. Overall service was excellent.
Food was superb. Portions are a bit small for my liking, but the food was really very good.
We will go back again.
5 stars across the board except for 'Value' due to the portion sizes. It's a bit pricey in that regard.
Will always be my favorite! We take the ferry over from CT. Wonderful bar with a very creative seasonal drink menu. Food menu is fresh and seasonal as well! Waitstaff goes above and beyond to make you feel welcome. We don't go out to restaurants often so when we do this is our go to place. You know you're going to have an amazing experience and leave full! Supporting small businesses right now is very important and they will have my support over and over! Can't wait to be back 😊🍸
Love the fireplace and service but the food was a disappointment. Will not return.
This is only the 2nd time I have been to the Fifth Season and again, I was not disappointed. The food was excellent. The service was excellent. As we are still in the pandemic and seating is limited, it was very quite which was nice. The courses were not rushed where you never stop eating. It was great to relax a little between them. The Fifth Season is on my "favorite places to eat" list from now on.
Fifth Season offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (631) 477-8500 ext. 2.
Fifth Season is rated 4.8 stars by 2493 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.