Apple Cider Braised Niman Ranch Short Ribs
sweet potato strudel, green and red cabbage & carrot slaw
Pan Seared Scottish Salmon
roasted cauliflower, sauteed spinach, caper & cured lemon gremolata
All Natural Chicken, Butternut Squash & Queso Fresco Wontons
salsa verde & cumin-lime crema
Absolutely wonderful experience! From the moment we entered, to the time we departed, the service, the food, everybody/thing was phenomenal! Their attention to detail places them above many other dining establishments! If you have not dined with them yet, make this your next stop! I'm sure you won't be disappointed!
The food was absolutely too notch!
Awesome as usual.
Overall experience was Exceptional... food was amazing...service was Exceptional...beautiful place to have a nice dinner
Food was very good but best of all was service, our waitress was just fantastic- I would repeat even if food was just fine
Great food and service. We wanted to eat outside but it looked like rain. We sat outside on the porch and it was perfect. I can’t wait to return.
We came here after getting legally married down port before our big wedding in PA this weekend! Bartender was very friendly, food was amazing. Would love to come back and have a sit down dinner! We enjoyed food from the happy hour, Kobe beef sliders & clam strips were out of this world!
Consistently great food & service! This is our go-to restaurant in the area. Best filet mignon I've ever had!!
I had been here 4 years ago and liked that they vegan and Gluten free options. I was disappointed with a few things. First of all, I booked it on open table for 7 pm on a Sunday evening. We were staying across the the street at Danfords. It was 6:58 pm telling me that and if I am not there in 2 minutes they aren’t holding my table. We got there about 7:01 pm I asked her what was the issue since I made the reservation on Open table. She told me they don’t take reservations past 6:45 pm on Sunday. Well why wac it an option on open table??? When I mentioned to waiter he said they don’t take walk ins past 6:45pm on Sunday or 7 pm if you have a reservation. It was not a good start to the evening. Then they bring out a bread basket which was stale little slices of Italian bread and a weird hummus spread. Since I am gluten free they told Hey that they had gluten free bread. They come out with a piece of white bread I could tell was frozen previously like I buy in supermarket. Dinner entree was ok I had the salmon and husband had filet. The desserts were also a disappointment. My husband ordered toasted almond cake and I ordered flourless chocolate cake. They were like cupcakes/ muffins and not great. I will not go back
We were very satisfied with the food and service. Our waiter was exceptionally helpful in advising us about the food on the menu and the specials of the day. It was an enjoyable birthday celebration. Well done. Will return in the future.
Excellent seasonal dishes prepared with the freshest ingredients. Highly recommend this local gem!
We had an awesome double date night at The Fifth Season last weekend. The food and drinks were delicious and the presentation was beautiful. The staff was attentive and friendly. The overall vibe was so great that we didn’t want the night to end. We’ll definitely be back soon and are already looking forward to it!
Food is ridiculously good! Service is outstanding
If you’re not sitting outside on the porch, the atmosphere really needs an updating, especially upstairs. The food is mostly pretty good, especially the main courses. Tho they aren’t as large a portion as you’d expect for the price. But the appetizers could be better. They’re not bad per say, just “fine”. The cocktails are large & the bartender doesn’t skimp on the alcohol, which is good. The waiters could be a little more attentive after food is served…never asked if we wanted cracked pepper (had to flag someone down for salt & pepper since post-COVID it’s not on the table). Never asked if we wanted another drink. Have been coming here for many years & felt this most recent visit was a bit lacking.
We had an excellent meal here. The fish of the day was delicious, the spring roll starter and the burrito starter were excellent. the atmosphere was great and the service was perfect. We finished with great deserts. Strongly recommend Fifth Season.
Wonderful date night out! The food was great and the service was outstanding. It is worth mentioning that I have a celiac disease and cannot have gluten. The waiter was very knowledgeable about the menu and I had an incredible meal without worry. They modified an appetizer to accommodate us and mentioned all of the specials they could modify as well. A great experience all around.
One of the best restaurants I have ever eaten at! The drinks were amazing, the food was impeccable, and the staff was fantastic! I ordered the Filet Mignon and it was one of the best I’ve ever had. The Butterfinger Martini was so sweet and delicious. I can’t wait to go back!
Great food and service. Sat inside this time. More fun on porch but still great as always
Service was friendly but not on par with a restaurant of that caliber. Waiter was not knowledgeable about wine.
The food has stayed consistently great for many years and is an excellent value for the quality of the food. The staff is friendly and attentive. Chef owned and run which is good and Nice atmosphere and views of the marina from across the street.
The overall look of the place us nothing spectacular but the relaxed atmosphere, good background music, great service and excellent food more than makes up for it
This is a fabulous restaurant all around. The food, drinks, service, atmosphere, all first-class. Been going there for years and highly recommend it.
Always great great food. The service was excellent too!
The farm to table recipe works here and I have never left disappointed. The best restaurant in Port Jefferson.
Nice place, go there often, food and service always on point.
Vinnie was a wonderfully warm and attentive server. He gave great advice based on his clear knowledge of the menu and wine list. Thrilled to see the amazing gnocchi on the summer menu (had it years ago) and enjoyed it as an appetizer. Scallops were delicious and generous. Thank you 5th Season!
The food here is so delicious! This is a regular spot for us so it only made sense to take our out of town friends here. The Mac and cheese is beyond tasty. I had the filet and it was melt in your mouth perfection.
Our waiter was a little slow, but all restaurants are struggling for staff right now and are still working hard. He was such a nice gentleman though.
Since we were a big party right next to 2 other big parties, it was a bit noisy. But that is to be expected.
I 100% recommend this restaurant to everyone.
I had the potato gnocchi and it was out of this world. The vegetarian quinoa dish was off the hook as well. The service was impeccable and I even got some sorbet and ice cream with a candle for my birthday. This place is one of my favorite places to go of all places.
We had a wonderful experience and will definitely be back! Service was professional, prompt and friendly. Hosts, waitstaff and bus people were well trained and attentive. Food was delicious.
Fantastic!! We’ll be back!!!!
Great restaurant with choices for everyone.
Salmon and gnocchi were our favorite dishes
Had a great lunch time meal for special occasion - outside on the deck with beautiful view of harbor in front. Food was excellent as always - this is our favorite Poet Jeff restaurant and it remains that. Lobster roll was great, drinks well made and other sandwiches chicken and kobe burger perfectly done and seasoned.
Fantastic food, great service, good menu selection.
Best plate of gnocchi I have had in quite some time. The burrata appetizer was outstanding- served with fried eggplant, ratatouille-type veg and marinated onions. Server was personable and attentive. Although we did not order, the price fixed menu included several favorites from the main menu and included an appetizer and dessert.
We enjoyed the dinner at the restaurant, except the sun bothered our guests. The shades need to be adjusted upwards. Otherwise, the light went right into guests eyes. also the restaurant is very crowded, with no masks on anyone. It is bothersome, with Delta variant is still around. We prefer outdoors dining in the future.
Nicely prepared entrees, good daily specials, and excellent eggplant hummus! Great friendly service.
I called ahead to request a special night for my mother and I! The entire staff went above and beyond to help make our special night memorable! We are both grateful for the care and special attention! Thank you!
All seven people in our party enjoyed their meal. The resturant is very nice.
Very good place. Excellent service and very good environment.
Fifth Season offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (631) 477-8500 ext. 2.
Fifth Season is rated 4.7 stars by 2599 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.