Very pleasant dining experience! Ordered the filet mignon and it was a small cut but good (some fat and grizzle!) I’ve had much better elsewhere! Nice views before dark! I’d go back again but won’t be ordering filet mignon unless it’s at a steakhouse! 😉 Good atmosphere and the wait staff is very friendly but not overbearing! Enjoy!
Great night out with my wife, son and his girlfriend. Everyting was super.
I was very disappointed in the drink we ordered prior to sitting at the bar. The mango margeretta was terrible. The bar tender made the drink what seemed very aggressively spilling liquor on the bar and barely shook it in the shaker with ice. Then just topped it off with more ice. For 28 dollars is was a big downer on starting my wife and I’s first date out since our two kids.
Food was fantastic. Service was just as good. Will definitely be back soon.
As always food and service was outstanding! As a celiac I always feel safe eating at The Fifth Season. This meal the chef even sent out a special bite for the table that was gluten free. This was super appreciated by all at our table since the people I dine with know the struggle. Patrick was a great server.
Everything was delicious. The crab cakes were awesome. We sat downstairs in a cozy room. Service was excellent. Well worth the price.
A little pricy, but everything was delicious! Had the burrata and kobe beef burger...all great.
Pretty much the best "mainstream" restaurant in the Port Jefferson area. Good food. Good service. Not overpriced.
The Fifth Season is certainly a restaurant for people with all tastes, the food is consistently good. The Kobi Burger is the best I've had, The menu changes through the year and never fails to impress. I would like to see a little more choice for vegetarians, my wife would like little more choice on that front.
I would always recommend this place, well trained staff, good service, great food.
Food and service were excellent!!
Excellent . Must visit
I have yet to be disappointed at the Fifth Season. Everyone is courteous and they pay close attention to detail. I enjoy it even more because I have celiac disease and they have a few dishes that are gluten free and I have yet to receive a reaction and I am extremely sensitive to gluten.
Christian was our waiter amd was great. Food delicious and prices good too.
Enjoyed our night with friends, thank you.
We’re always pleased with the food and the service.
Very nice restaurant. Parking was okay now but can see it to be a challenge in the summer. Food excellent and waiter was wonderful.
We were married and had our reception at the Fifth Season and return there from time to time. It is nice to go there and be recognized and remembered by the employees who work there. We were also greeted by one of the owners. Food here is always excellent, and we had a nice view of the water. Only real complaint is that there is not a lot of space at the tables. Service staff was very polite, friendly and professional. The waiting time for the food was not insane and it was very busy that night. Highly recommended!
Prompt and friendly service. Great food
Food and service was excellent
Great Valentines Day dinner!
Food was of average quality, however did not warrant the fixed $70 per person price. The fixed price was also not advertised online or over the phone at the time I made my reservation (3 weeks ahead). Wait staff were helpful and friendly, dispite the crowded dining room.
Valentine's Day. Fixed-price dinner. Portions of first 2 courses were very small. Entree good size, as was dessert. Great service and ambiance. Will try again on a non-holiday night.
Great overall experience. Cozy, a little fancy but the price wasn't bad considering their competition of restaurants, which are normally higher priced. I will be back.
This was our first visit. We found both the bar ad dining had excellent service. The menu was very interesting and each member of our party chose different appetizers and entrees. In all cases we found the to be delicious and with careful attention to specific requests. We will be back.
Everything was well done. The food and the service were excellent. We have become to expect the very best from this restaurant and they have not failed in any way. They always meet or exceed our expectations with their food and service. Everything is always well done!!
Just didn’t love it. Third time, but both previous times I got the special, but this time ordered a burger, just ok. No Prosecco,that killed me. Lol
The food was amazing as always.
This is a wonderful restaurant in an area where few culinary options exist. The menu is excellent with a variety of options featuring local purveyors. The service is very good. I love the fire place upstairs and the view of the water.
The food was absolutely amazing.
Amazing dinner! Chef John is on point every time we come here! We have never had a bad experience here. Our server, Patrick, was super sweet & attentive. The chicken was crispy on the outside & moist inside, just awesome. Monkfish was prepared perfectly!! We will be back very soon!!
Been going to Fifth Season for many years - and been many many times , why ?
The quality of the food and variety on the menu is superb, always imaginative, sometimes daring but always works.
They maintain excellent quality of the food and are always dependable and consistent.
The wine list a little limited for my tastes . I’m a world wine guy and it’s a little limited as they promote local or predominantly US wines. Having said that, they have some nice wines.
I wouldn’t hesitate in recommending this restaurant.
Fifth Season is a reliable good restaurant whether for a causal night out or when entertaining guests.
Food and service are consistently outstanding, though noise level can be an occasional distraction. We've eaten here before, but this time we brought along relatives who had never been to this establishment. They spoke in accolades about every course, whether salad, appetizers, and entrees which included vegetarian, seafood, and meat. It's worth the drive.
This restaurant was a perfect choice for our pre-concert dinner.
very nice place. food was great and service was phenomenal
Amazing food, great night out
Service, ambience, food always exceeds expectations.
Food was excellent. The waiter and serving staff was very professional.
I have been here over a dozen times and I am never disappointed. The food is fresh and delicious and just the right amount to not leave stuffed; you leave 100% satisfied. From the appetizers to the desserts, each seasonal menu is delicious. The seasonal cocktails are also delicious. The service is terrific. Never, ever a complaint about any aspect of this restaurant. Top notch all the way.
Service and food excellent as usual. Great Job to everyone.