Best Historic Restaurants in Fire Island

I love the three course special menu. The atmosphere is beautiful and upscale. Our server Chris was excellent and very attentive. The food was delicious. Insignia is our "go to" restaurant for special occasions.

We celebrated a friend's birthday here on Friday, and it was a blast. The atmosphere was bright, lively, and perfect for the occasion. Our server was friendly and attentive, making us feel right at home. We all tried different entrees: Enchiladas Verdes, Steak Quesadilla, and Pechuga en Mole. Each dish was flavorful and worth coming back for. Plus, a live mariachi band played throughout the restaurant, even serenading our table with a special song. It was a fantastic first impression, and we’ll definitely be back!

The food was excellent, one of the best lobster rolls I have ever had. The restaurant was loud, we ate inside so it seems the noise echos. The service was good but I would have liked the server to check on us more often. We had to wait to order more drinks, and to get our check at the end.

Lorena was our server she was very good, attentive and friendly. We were seated right away food selection was good for brunch. Only concern was that food was barely warm had food been hot or at least a little warmer rating would have been a 5.