Nearby points of interest
Nearby points of interest
'Emilio's is a real hometown favorite among locals who stop in for a quick slice of pizza to go, or to sit at one of the high-top tables in the dining room and enjoy freshly prepared dishes like fried calamari, eggplant rolatini, and grilled chicken parmigiana. ' -Commack Patch
Commack, NY 11725
Hours of Operation:
Sun-Thurs: 11 am-10 pm
Fri-Sat: 11 am-11 pm
$30 and under
AMEX, Discover, MasterCard, Visa
Emilio's Ratings and Reviews
Second time I had a reservation and they did not Honor it. I waited 45 minutes before . The only reason we had a table 45 minutes after reservation is because we spoke to the manager and hostess was seating all the regulars that had no reservation. Hostess was rude the moment I came in.
I hate to say it but we were disappointed! The food was just not great. I've had the mammas rigatoni before and it was very good, this time it was mushy and bland. The server was not very friendly - just doing her job. We brought another couple with us telling them how good it was and we very not happy at all. Don't know if we'll go back.
The food and prices were decent. My biggest complaint was the 30 minute wait for a table after booking a reservation on open table. Open table showed availability every 15 minutes for a table of 6 people so we booked a 6:45pm reservation. When we arrived at the restaurant we were not seated until 7:15pm.
They do not honor the Open Table reservations. This is the 2nd time within 2 weeks that I had a reservation and had to wait the same amount time as someone who just walked into the restaurant and requested a table. The hostess is not pleasant, I understand it could be overwhelming but I do not need an attitude from her.
The food is outstanding but portions are small
Food was great, however, service needs improvement. My husband and I ordered a flatbread pizza for an appetizer and just as we had gotten that and taken our first bite our entrees were being brought to the table. As a former waitress, that is a big no-no. Knowing they were putting our food to sit under a hot lamp we just asked that they bring it out to us. The waitress then asked if we wanted another round of drinks and we both ordered something but she only returned with one drink forgetting about the other. I also had to grab another waiter to bring parmesan cheese (it is an Italian restaurant and we both ordered pasta...the waitress should have brought cheese over without us asking).
Emilios is always full, because it deserves to be! We took our daughter, who lives in Seattle, here because out of many Italian restaurants in the area, Emilios is our favorite! She agreed that the food was great and she especially enjoyed the meals that had red sauce on them.
This time, I ordered the delicious meatballs, but I usually order the cabonara with chicken which I also really love. The only thing that could have been improved was the bread, but I think on other visits there was more of a choice than on a Saturday.
If you go on a Friday or Saturday, make reservations ahead of time and avoid the line.
I have been to Emilio's before and have loved it. However this visit was very disappointing. Let's start with our waitress who was not friendly. I had to ask for food menus. Not to mention the four slices of bread that came out in a pasta bowl???? I ordered a pasta dish and asked for cheese several times... needless to say I'm still waiting in my cheese. My pasta was also under cooked. I also notice their menu changed and I was not impressed. Overall most likely will not return.
We are only on Long Island a few months of the year and live about an hours drive from Emilios. But we like it so much that we go there at least 4 or 5 times during our short stay. Reservation time always respected, good prompt service, and great food. We meets friends there and they too travel about 45 minutes to get there. They love it as well.
The food at Emilios is always on point. The Sicilian pizza is out of this world!!!
Simply amazing. I have nothing bad to say about Emilios, however the service is not always the best. Typically you have to wait a while for the server to bring over menus to the table. My advice is to have the hostess give the customers their menus when they are seated at the table instead of having the hostess say to the guests that the waiter will bring the menus. So silly & wastes so much valuable time!
This was our all time favorite restaurant but I think they got too busy. Last two times services was terrible. This time waiter forgot appetizers. Then messed up food order Literally had to beg him for a check just to get out of there. Such a shame cuz we live chef Chris but quality and service on decline
I'm thrilled with the Limoncello Alfredo Shrimp Special I had. Wow. Their regular menu is real good anyway, I find lots of healthy choices, (thin veggies made like pasta called Skinny Girl) as well as those that are yummy and I can't help but order. Happy to see added Specials because we eat there so often I love trying new dishes.
The beet salad was tasty, fresh & delicious. More salad than beets but a nice size portion. It was served with a balsamic reduction and mild goat cheese. The eggplant rollatine was filled with fresh ricotta and covered in red sauce & mozzarella. Very hot & delicious. My dining guest had the chicken parmigiana which he said was tender & delicious, also.
I love this restaurant! The bartender Stacey is by far one of the greatest mixologists in New York and super nice and sweet! I thought I was a goner when I found out I had celiac, but Chris and the rest of the staff seem pretty knowledgeable when it comes to non-contamination and great food. One (selfish) suggestion, get some good gluten free bread to lap up all the delicious sauces your kitchen makes!
Please sign in to record your input. Thanks!
Report this review as inappropriate?
If you believe this review should be removed from OpenTable, please let us know and someone will investigate.