Popular dishes
Chicken
3 reviews
Pasta Emilio
Sausage, shrimp, ham, scallions, diced tomato, light pink cream sauce, spaghetti
1 reviews
Soup of the Day
1 reviews
Menu
Food was great. Totally social distanced. Waiter was FANTASTIC
Valentines Day and it was busy, service was little slow
Food always excellent. Service very good and staff pleasant
Service was excellent, food also very good. We will be back there again
It was given to us on a gift card and we have been here many times before. Everything was great and due to COVID not crowded and quiet for a Sunday night. Only complaint was that open table directs you to a very old menu which by the restaurant should be changed to the correct one,
The first visit to Emilios was slightly rushed as we had arrived at 9pm while they were winding down but the staff was still relatively accommodating & graciously seated us.
I decided this wouldn’t have been the best time to judge this place so we went back the following day for brunch and boy was I happy I had made that executive decision!!
The staff was much more welcoming and the food was absolutely scrumptious!! As much as I wanted to hate this place I couldn’t... it’s truly found it’s way into our hearts.
UPDATE: I’ve been back 3 separate times since my initial visit and it Emilios just keeps getting better & better!!
Food was very bland not much flavor, service was no more than mediocre. For me personally I would never go back they are again
Quality of food has definitely declined. Brocolli rabe was tasteless and Sardinia not as flavorful as in the past. Maybe it has changed owners. Will not be going back anytime soon
Set at the bar due to busyness of restaurant- Stacey is amazing love her! Looking forward to a return visit
Friday night the service was so slow , and they forget my brothers soup. Each persons meal came out about 15 mins after the other that one was done before another got a meal .
Not that busy on a Saturday night- plenty of open tables so there should not be an excuse. Plenty of staff working. The food was just ok. The service was terrible. It took 20 minutes for the waiter to take our order and 35 minutes to get our entrees. No free refills on soda (who does that anymore?) On the flip side, the bartender is great. Personable and knowledgeable. Excellent service at the bar only.
Food was excellent. I really have no complaints. Only had a slight issue with dessert. I ordered cheesecake with berries. When I got it, there were no berries. I questioned it and the waitress said they didn't have any. I should Of been told before she served it. I would of picked a different dessert.
Love Emilios. I go all the time. But I was super disappointed because I finally convinced my brother and his gf to go to Emilios and eat outside. We got there and stood inside for 10 minutes waiting for our reservation (we wanted outside dining so we wouldn’t be indoors), and then we waited for our food for over an hr. Waitress barely came over. We had to ask for more bread and water since we waited so long we had none left. I don’t know what happened that our food took so long but we received no explanation. I will continue to go back bc I love their food but unfortunately my brother and his gf said they won’t be returning 😕
Ate dinner outside. Ceasar salad and fettuccini and both were delicious!
Everything is always amazing! Whenever I bring someone new they fall in love with this place and want to go back. Food is amazing and so is the staff!
Both Sergio & Kelly are the Best!!!!
Was able to have dinner outside. Area was just ok. Tables were on a slant due to uneven pavement with napkins under table legs to keep tables from moving. Tent should of had more outdoor plants and decorations to enhance outdoor dining experience. Outdoor dining was not an enjoyable experience to have a meal. Would not go back to outdoor dining. Service and food was good.
The food was delicious but the service was slow. It took awhile to get a menu and then to get someone to take our order. The waiter was very pleasant but I think he was overburdened with too many customers. It also took awhile for the food to come out.
Our waiter was fantastic. Recommended excellent entree and wine! Food was fantastic!!
Really enjoyed the food and the service was pretty good. Our first try at this establishment. The outdoor chairs and tables left something to be desired, very uncomfortable and unstable. Will definitely go back.
As always, Emilio’s never disappoints us. Due to Covid19 the restaurant closed earlier than we anticipated but it was my birthday and they still seated us. In the end we ended up the only people in the restaurant. Had our own Tony Soprano moment. Made me feel really special for my bday during this pandemic and during Hurricane Isaias. Thank you Emilio’s!
Food was good, service was excellent. During the pandemic one must give some latitude to restaurants.
Great tomato sauces.Gelato is excellent.Arrive early.Not many tables now.Good out door seating if its not too hot.
We enjoyed our lunch at Emillio's outside dining .The service was excellent and the tables were set up very nicely. It is shady and cool under the tent. I recommend dining at Emillio's
The service at this restaurant is great. The food is fresh and tasty. They use quality products.
Our first night out since the quarantine and we were not disappointed! Our waiter was excellent and the food was delish.
The food and service was great
The food was amazing, it was cold as hell in the restaurant every time the door opens. My only other issue was I made a 7:30 reservation and was not seated until 8:05.
Food came out cold and had to be sent back. Server inattentive and did nothing to make us feel respected as customers.
I love going for good food in a clean and friendly restaurant. Emilios is the best! Dining room gives the upscale feel and quieter than rustic booth area. Food and service are excellent!!!
Food was served quickly and Hot. Food Was very good, I had the chicken Parm.
As always, delicious and fresh. Perfect wine, food, dessert and company. We had pizza, penne vodka, Mac & cheese (kids) calamari Arabiatta, bakes clams, grilled shrimp, Bronx tale veal, pasta Emilio, and for dessert, gelato & creme brûlée cheesecake. Everything was cooked perfectly, and our waiter was very attentive... even with our 4 kids!
Great food. Any dish can be changed to zucchini noodles to swap out pasta for a small charge! So worth it if your eating low carb and want some interesting options like me {and my hubby}.
Had 7 pm reservation had to wait 20 min.was told they are running a little late/
Our server, jose, was excellent! Food and atmosphere were great as well! We really enjoyed the gluten free options.
The best pizza around! The food is excellent, but the pizza by far is superior. It can get noisey, but the food is worth it!
Went with a friend for a casual birthday dinner. Food
is always outstanding!
We are a long time Emilio's customer. They up-charged us $10 for a side of pasta because it was home made and didn't tell us that. When questioned the waitress said she didn't know either and the manager didn't reverse the charge. They put a young waitress in an awkward place too. Poor way to do business. Kinda Greedy if you ask me.. Especially since we have been customers for over 30 years. The food is always great but this incident left a bad taste in my mouth. Disappointed in their customer services or lack of training which ever it is .. it wasn't my mistake and I shouldn't have had to pay for that. By the way we had a nice size bill too with a bottle of wine and extra drinks so we were not the ones who were cheap!
Everything was great
You can never go wrong w Emilios. Worst kept secret in Commack!! ,)
Best pizzeria around. The best!!
FAQs
Emilio's does offer delivery in partnership with Uber Eats. Emilio's also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (631) 462-6267.
Emilio's is rated 4.5 stars by 585 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.
