Nearby points of interest
Restaurants you may also like
Nearby points of interest
About Permanently Closed - Elizabeth's Neighborhood Table
This restaurant is permanently closed.
Enjoy the taste of traditional American southern cuisine at Elizabeth's Neighborhood Table. Its white picket fence, along with its hardwood floors and wooden furniture as its inner decor, create an atmosphere that recreates a feeling of being in an actual old southern home as guests enjoy dishes that have been a part of American culture for generations.
Elizabeth's Neighborhood Table utilizes nothing but local and organic foods. Elizabeth's Neighborhood Table menu features appetizers, such as jumbo lump crab cakes with apple fennel slaw and homemade herb gribiche, as well as macaroni and cheese. Some of its main entrées range between crispy fried chicken, as well as pan-seared Irish organic salmon.
New York, NY 10025
American, Comfort Food
Hours of Operation:
Dinner: Sunday - Thursday: 3:30pm - 11:00pm, Friday & Saturday: 3:30pm - 12:00am; Brunch: Saturday & Sunday: 11:30am - 3:30pm
$30 and under
AMEX, Diners Club, Discover, MasterCard, Visa
Delivery and setup. Many packages and options included.
B,C,1,2,3 @ 96th Street
Beer, Delivery, Farm to Table, Full Bar, Outdoor dining, Takeout, Weekend Brunch, Wheelchair Access, Wine
Elizabeth's Neighborhood Table - Permanently Closed Ratings and Reviews
Have had a nice brunch of omellettes, pancakes, biscuits here before. Noted the cold coffee then also. Decided to meet a friend here today and since it was after 1pm, we both had the veggie hash w/ 2 eggs. What a terrible dish! It was a huge mound of cold kale (including a substantial amount of old, wilted, yellowed and pock-marked kale), warm red cabbage (tasted fine), and what looked like might be home fries big pieces of cold potato and onion mixed in with the kale and cabbage. The eggs were cooked well and served on top. No sauce - nothing tying this weird combo together and all for $14. Coffee was lukewarm --both servings again this time. All the servers were nice and tried very hard, coming back to see if we needed anything. Ambiance is pleasant. Prices for things seem too high. $15 for 1 Belgian waffle and then bacon on the side is additional $6.
Won't be back--such a shame.
Everything my friend and I ordered was delicious. I had a housemade Veggie Burger that was the best I've ever eaten: thick, juicy and flavorful. My friend had a Cobb Salad, which she described as "better than the usual version." Again, all ingredients were fresh and colorful. I would definitely return to sample other items on the menu.
I wish I'd known about Elizabeth's a long time ago! It is fantastic! The charming porch instead of the usual Columbus Avenue Sidewalk cafe makes you feel immediately welcome, like you've stepped into a little country inn. There's even a porch swing, where I waited happily for my lunch date, who was running a little late. The service was impeccable - friendly like the place but not hovering. Indoor ambience charming and cozy - we chose a comfy banquet. And the food! So delicious we found ourselves passing our plates back and forth! Rare to find a place with both grassfed beef and superb vegetarian choices. So glad we saved room for dessert - peach bread pudding was heavenly. Love.
It was my wife's birthday and I could not be happier with the choice I made. Elizabeth's is a gem in the city. The food is amazing and Thomas is the wizard of all chefs. The drinks were marvelous. The bartender (I wish I could remember his name) is a mad scientist of mixology. You have to try the Brooklyn Gin mixed with Uncouth Vermouth. It'll make your night. Liz you are amazing and genuine, and you have a wonderful staff working with you. It is such a great atmosphere at Elizabeth's. My family and I could not have been more pleased. We will definitely dine, laugh and drink at Elizabeth's again. We highly recommend that you do to!
My girlfriend suggested that we go to this neighborhood spot. It looked nice and quaint so I agreed to give a try. She ordered the lambchop special and I ordered the ribs. Both were not good. We left most of our food on the plate. The ribs tasted as if they were old and the flavoring was off and her lambchop had a sweet minty taste rather than the typical salt you expect on a lambchop. Needless to say we did not stay for dessert.
During a girls' weekend in NYC we booked Elizabeth's for brunch on Saturday morning and it was amazing! Away from the hustle and bustle of the city you really feel like you are somewhere else entirely. The chef was very accommodating as we had some diners with allergies and particular diets. Our server was lovely and the food and drinks were fabulous!
Will go again. Love that music was not loud nor were other diners do I got to catch-up with out of town friend. . Happy went got the ribs & fried chicken. Service was good too all good feedback and I'd go back there too. Love the country ambiance in the middle of NYC very clever. Portions were big do next time I'll make sure to save room for desert list.
Whether I come early or leave late, with a large group or by myself, I have been greeted warmly and treated well - I love every single staff person's hospitable grace and accommodation. Then add great food, comfortable décor and a friendly ambience? One in a million, a true gem!
I love this neighborhood restaurant , good quality foods , attentive staff , decent priced and although located on the opposite side of my downtown neighborhood I never mind making my way up to this cute place to meet up with my friends.....specially if one prefers the less crowded north side of central park, it's an easy walk over there to enjoy a good meal...I hope it stays there for ever!!!
Things started out well (good draft beer, reasonably nice decor) but went downhill as we waited 45 minutes for our (overcooked) food to arrive. Our waitress had an air of indifference and sort of disappeared. Not good, especially with a restless 12 year old at the table.
Elizabeth's is quickly becoming my go-to place after Popover's closed. The food is good and brunch is nice. It feels spacious enough and very kid-friendly, from the reasonable kids' menu to the staff's pleasant attitude. Once you go through the white picket fence you feel as though you're going into a country inn.
My husband and I stopped in for a weekday lunch. It was great. I had the Cobb Salad-the server told me it's not tomato season so she suggested alternatives-but I was welcome to the tomatoes if I wished. I chose apples and it was fantastic. My husband had the BLT with cheddar and applewood smoked bacon-delicious.
The service was great and the ambience was nice, but unfortunately, the food was not so good. The turkey meatloaf was overlooked and bland. The pork chop was also overlooked and needed seasoning. Mashed potatoes were good. Appetizer of dips was also good, but they skimped on the veggies.
We went there Wednesday night with my wife. She ordered the turkey burger (it was OK but a little too much dry), and I ordered the meatloaf with mashed potatoes (which was OK). Portion sizes are nice.
Probably for brunch is better, but I wouldn't recommend it for dinner.
Needed a place on the upper west side to get together with some friends for a birthday brunch....I went to Open Table and scanned through the list of restaurants and liked what I saw for menu choices at Elizabeth's (also --- I kinda really liked the name too)...so I booked a ressie.....Well.... I'm so glad I did!!! What a great place! The food was yummy and I loved the fact that they had a round table to seat 5 of us. I will definitely go back in the spring to sit in the "fenced in" outdoor seating area!
We all found our meals delicious. The service was good (other than the busboy asking if I wanted to take my food home while everyone was still eating. This is a pet peeve of mine - all plates should remain on the table until all parties are finished with their meals!).
Was disappointed this time. Was New Year's Eve. The waitress never served us bread. It as not crowded -- so, no excuse. Ordered onion rings that were pretty bad and not very crispy (as the menu suggests) at all. The turkey burger was not as good as I have had in the past. Overall, not happy. Hope it was a fluke.
Please sign in to record your input. Thanks!
Report this review as inappropriate?
If you believe this review should be removed from OpenTable, please let us know and someone will investigate.