Earl's New American
Book your next event with us
Maine lobster, shaved carrot slaw, sweet soy
quinoa & mushroom ragout, corn porridge, candied bacon
Great atmosphere. Great food. Recommend the wedge salad, bisque, striped bass and scallops.
Excellent people and food
Nice Place. Good Food, Good Service. Great Experience!!
Nice atmosphere, clean, modern, big bar in front room, parking.
Food and service are always outstanding! She-crab bisque is wonderful and they always have delicious, inventive seasonal specials. Beautiful, relaxing space. Our must visit spot whenever we are in the area!
Food was delic as always, service was just right (attentive but not overbearing). Second time here and loved it just as much as the first! Will be returning again once we can sit outside for summer dinning!!! :)
Could use some pots of flowers outside to improve ambiance.
Great food and service!
Well I think the food use to be better and they needed more waiters because Earl’s was very busy because of Easter.
Everything about the dinner was average at above average prices. I am ok never eating here again, not worth the money.
Love this restaurant! The food is amazing, the servers always polite, helpful, friendly and professional. We dine here almost every time we come to Peddlers Village and have never ben disappointed!
The server was wonderful, ambiance is nice. The food however was just average. Some of it was very tasty and others were bland, undercooked and not good.
Drinks were very good!!
Excellent service and dinner was fabulous! Top quality and delicious!
Service good, food a little underwhelming
Hostess was very nice, seated us early. Waiter was ok, didnt have mask over nose. Service was slow. Noise from street was way too loud due to trucks (not the fault of the restaurant of course), but felt like we were sitting on the street. Waitstaff had to bring our (uncovered) food from the restaurant through the busy walkway and over to our outdoor table. All our orders were overcooked/dry...Crab Cake sandwich dry and looked as if it was left under the heat lamp for a while, Pulled Pork sandwich dry, barely any sauce, bun was burnt, Smoked Duck on the salad was overcooked. Crab soup was awesome and very hot.
Outstanding meal! Went to Peddler's Village for a short get away from Manhattan. Had an amazing meal at Earl's. I eat out regularly in Manhattan and the meal at Earl's rivalled quite a few of my favorite spots. Service was friendly and attentive. Would HIGHLY recommend this restaurant.
Went there for our 1st time,for wedding anniversary dinner. Shrimp and grits were hot creamy and delicious . Hubs had filet and cleaned his plate . We also highly recommend the lobster dumplings . Bread was ugh.. incredible- like a beer bread . Let’s just say I was ready to roll my stuffed self out of there feeling happy and full
The food was tasty. The portions were a little small .
Delicious lunch on a beautiful Spring day. Food and service never disappoints. We had oysters, crab cake and short rib sandwich. Try the Grapefruitt-tini, light and refreshing. Great spot for lunch or dinner. Our go to place in Peddlers Village.
The food and drinks are always the best at Earl's. This is my go-to place whenever I'm in Peddler's Village.
Excellent dinner. Very nice service. Beautiful environs.
We visited for my daughter’s birthday. Food and service were excellent.
Food quality was very good and pricing similiar to other restaurants in Peddlers Village
We went to Earl’s last minute after a race on Sunday. Our waiter Johnny D was absolutely fabulous. The food was delicious. Will definitely be back.
Food was delicious and drinks were excellent. Would recommend to anyone in the area.
Earl’s had great food and atmosphere as usual! Always our go to at Peddlers Village!!
Brook is an excellent waitress and bartender.
Was a beautiful day to dine outdoors. The only thing that would make it even better, an Umbrella. Very sunny and an umbrella would give you coverage and make it a little bit more private and may even soften the noise from all the traffic Whizzing by on the street. Just a suggestion. But, it was very nice to celebrate our Anniversary where we got married at Peddlers Village.
Great food and our waiter Jack was outstanding!
Took our 27 year old Pharmacist granddaughter to lunch; wanted it to be special, someplace she had not been to and quiet enough for easy conversation. We selected Earl's based on past good experiences and we were not disappointed. Earl's projects as an upscale establishment without being overly expensive. Excellent cocktails - especially the Templeton Rye Manhattan. Nice place for a quiet business lunch. We'll go back!
First outside dining out since the lockdown, and what a treat! The service was wonderful - our waiter, Jeremy, made sure our glasses stayed full and our food was hot. We felt very safe with the outside tables being at least 6' apart. The food.... the food... always top notch, as what I expect with Earl's. They didn't disappoint!
A great confortable resturant, great service and food. The staff makes you feel very welcome. Can't wait to go back
Great experience by the fireplace. Food was delicious and authentic!
Everything was quite delicious. We had a 3 course meal, everything cooked to perfection. Server was very pleasant. I’m going back soon!!!
Early dinner on a Saturday - oysters were fresh, cheese board delicious, shrimp and grits good, but nothing special and the beef short ribs were excellent. Service was nice, but not overly friendly. Can't really place my finger on why I would give it four starts vs. five, but I've had better.
Short ribs and 7oz filet were dead on. Service was great. Cocktails were perfect. Our waiter Brittany was around the perfect amount of times and not interruptive.
The food was delicious. The service was great. The atmosphere nice.
Fabulous time! We booked a table month in advanced.
Table was a small high top. Did not know the table size. Needless to say it was to small. The hostess changed our table no problem/-to what we feel was the best table in the restaurant. Everything we ordered was perfect. We had oysters for appetizers and they were the BEST WE EVER HAD! We made sure to tell our waiter that whomever shucked the oysters really knows what their doing! Fresh cold and clean.
Blue cheese olive martini-Yum! Lobster dumplings! So good. We’ll be back for sure. A little noisy- a couple of jubilant birthday tables, but so fun. Great time!
My husband and I stayed at the Golden Plough Inn and made reservations for Earls and glad we did! The lobster dumpling are great and the burrata! The fried tomato melts in your mouth. Good wine selection too! Our server was very attentive and our experience that much better.
Fantastic meal and service. Very nice place to dine. Would most definitely go back!
Earl's New American offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (215) 794-4020.
Earl's New American is rated 4.7 stars by 1068 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.