We had a 1Pm reservation and they where out of everthing. Waitress had an attitude like she didn't want to be there. It was my Mothers Birthday and Terrible Expierence

I had a great experience dining here at Earl’s New American. The atmosphere was pleasantly aesthetic, clean, and spacious. Our waiter, Erin, and our bartenders were also kind, involved, and funny. Lastly, the food was delish! I highly recommend this restaurant.

We had a great time at Earls!
Great service and great food! We appreciate how hard the chefs and staff are working during this crazy time!! We had a great night!

Slowest service ever. Pretty sure they forgot to put in our appetizer. Should have made up for it somehow but didn’t, and it was my grandmother’s 86th birthday.

If you like over priced, salty food. This is the place for you.
Very expensive! Decorated to the nines. Should look into better tasting food.
OUR WAITRESS WAS WONDERFUL, SHE MADE OUR DINING ENJOYABLE.

Excellent service. Choice of craft beers on tap. Food was excellent: seafood dish & filet for wife & I. Busy Thurs night in October after 6:00PM.
Busy bar too with some couples having meals at bar. I would say best place in Village for nice meal and setting.

Awesome meal and service as usual. The friendly and professional team at Earl's always make you feel at home.

Rachel was fantastic, very attentive to us. Appreciated Jim adjusting our reservation due to increase in guests.

Food was warm, took over an hour to receive. Disappointed that they ran out of certain food.

Figure this was an off night for a normally awesome restaurant.

While the number of menu selections was not large, the food was delicious. Outside seating was picturesque and comfortable. Nice place to have lunch when visiting Pedler's Village.

Had another nice meal at Earl’s. Was disappointed that they were out of short ribs, which is my favorite meal there. Service was excellent. Place is very pretty, nice decor. Did not like the creme brûlée. Had it before and it was great. This time it was ice cold and did not seem fresh. Server did give it to us complimentary for our anniversary, which was very nice. We will definitely dine here again. Food is very good, and it’s a great location, right across from the main village.

It was a lunch menu. Soups, salads, sandwiches, etc. It was very good. We have had meals there in the past and will continue to eat there in the future.

Excellent service by Chris!!!!

Wonderful experience! Have always been happy at Earl’s

We went as part of our 35th wedding anniversary celebration. I asked the restaurant for their help in setting up a nice table with some pictures of us to help set the mood. When we arrived everything was set nicely, the food was very good as usual and the service was outstanding. We were even comped for one of our desserts which was a very nice touch. We will go back.

The food was really good!

It was great. Food and wervice was wonderful. We sat outside on a beautiful day

Wonderful food. Great atmosphere. Really knowledgeable and friendly server! Overall loved the experience. Will return here often.

Pumpkin Martini was delicious. Waiter was very personable but a little slow with the service.

Been there, done that… have wanted to go for years, guess the years caught up with them. Reservations were for 4… start of dinner menu… items on specials menu were not available. Front desk hostess tried placing us in hallway, away from the so called ambience… was told dinning area with booths was not available… long story short… we’re seated in booth, along with mumbling under the hostess’s breath. Steak was tough, asparagus stringy and thick. Chicken was nothing special. Cobbler was microwaved; crust was mush, lost its crispness. Been there, done that… not again

Food was very good. My husband had the wedge salad and I had the chopped salad to start. Both were delicious. We then ordered the short ribs - they were very good. Our waitress was attentive and nice. She brought us a a free dessert because it was our anniversary. Overall, a very enjoyable experience.

We were excited to go to Earls, as we were there 6 months ago and enjoyed the food and service. However, our experience this time was much different. Though our waiter was very nice, we waited an hour for our meal. We understand things may happen in the kitchen, but we were just told repeatedly the food would be out, or that porkchops take a bit longer to cook. We even waited a while for our appetizers and dessert. The whole thing was very odd, and would have been made much better if we were informed of whatever issue was occurring that had us in this restaurant for over two hours.

We’ve been to Earls many times and it never disappoints.

Great setting. Waitress very attentive. Food ws excellent except for my scallops which has an unusual amount of salt. Actually almost uneatable due to the salty coating.

The food was very unappetizing -- not enough sauces, condiments, flavorings, etc. Also the sides were puny. It was all just plain and unappealing.

We miss the old Earl's where you could always count on excellent food and fantastic service.

Chris, our waitress, was a fantastic server and made my fiancé’s and mine night enjoying and easygoing. The oysters and bisque were delicious. The lobster dumplings, we both thought were just okay and could use more lobster meat or even crab as a filler as they tasted to us like normal pot stickers. The arugula with the glaze dressing was a nice touch though. We topped off by splitting a 14oz ny strip steak that was just a little undercooked for our taste which is why we’re giving all categories a 5 except for the food.

We had lunch outside and the bees and flies were overwhelming. I strongly recommend that you eat inside.

We had dinner here on Labor Day 2021 and though the food and service were both very good, we probably won't return since this was a vacation trip and we ended up ordering higher priced entrees than we would have otherwise. Lots of people were here because it was a holiday and the restaurant server claimed they were out of certain items. Understandable but they should have been better prepared for that scenario and were only letting patrons with reservations dine. Perhaps gambling that the reservations were solid and would not be cancelled? Hmm.

Great as usual!

The host welcoming us was friendly and professional. We were seated and was quickly approached by our server. He was very personable and knowledgeable of the menu. He took our drink order come back within minutes with our drinks and then took our food order. He made some suggestions. Our food came out reasonably fast and it was presented beautifully. I ordered short ribs and my wife ordered a fillet. It was perfect and tasty. Our server came back several times to check on us. It was a very pleasant experience and we were there to celebrate our anniversary. I highly recommend this restaurant. The chef needs to be recognized for the plate presentation very well done.

The food was delicious but after taking a long time to get out food the orders were mixed up. We were told we would be compensated and though they took off one of the entrees they double charged us for another. The drinks were very good wish we could rate them excellent.

Wonderful! The restaurant is beautiful!
The staff wonderful! Dinner delish and beautifully displayed.

We looked forward to dining here on Monday evening. There was a group of 4 men near us at a table and they were LOUD!!!!!!!!!!!!!! We kept waiting for them to leave, or else my wife was going to ask them to try to respect the other diners and lower their 'bar lounge' voices! I saw Verizon on one of their shirts: hey Verizon guys, Earls is NOT a Sports Bar. Inside voices please.

A friendly local spot and get destination. Nice decor, good food, and always great service.

Amazing dinner!

Wonderful waitress. Food was very good

The staff was wonderful, very friendly and attentive. They left us to chat and did not hover, knowing just when to check in on us. We had an early reservation and were disappointed that they were already out of the entree special for the night. Ordered a specialty drink and it was ok. The short rib entree was on the small side & shrimp and grits were good. Both fish entrees were very good. Overall a very enjoyable evening.

Overall it was pretty good. Not what you would

Excellent! We ate here several times years ago and we were happy to see the quality has not changed. Food was delicious, our waiter was attentive and helpful.

Our experience at Earl’s New American was exquisite. Our service was fast, drinks were good, and the food was phenomenal. The peach cobbler was to die for. It was our first time there and we will absolutely be back. If you’re considering Earl’s, don’t hesitate!

We frequented Earl’s when it originally opened but wrote it off when there was a steady decline in its quality, consistency and service. We decided to try it again after it reopened and transformed itself and we were pleasantly surprised. Great, fresh and inspirational food creations. Delicious oysters and clams. Very creative interpretation of sea bass. Brook our server was remarkable. Will definitely go back!