Don't Tell Mama NYC

Price fixe is a great deal glazed chicken was scrumptious as was the lemon meringue pie. Great easy location to the theatres.

Good food. Friendly service. Not too noisy. Fun neighborhood.

The food was excellent. Though it didn’t bother us it was a pity we were the only customers as the atmosphere was quite and strange

Intimate small tables well trained waiters

The food was great and for nyc it was a particularly great value. I had the 35 prefix dinner of salmon and it was very good. Our waiter Ryan was particularly delightful and such a pleasant server. We loved it and would go back in a second!! Thank you!!!

Our waitress was very attentive and friendly. The girls loved their drinks and the food was hot and fresh. We'll go again.

Excellent food and service. Will definitely be back!

I cannot remember the name of young man who helped us but he was very attentive. Kept checking to make sure we were doing well. The Krispy salmon was great could have been better with more vegetables. It was perfectly cooked. The drinks were good but two expensive. Nice small cozy place. Clean bathroom which is a big thing with me. The name was unusual but it was explained to us just what it means. carabet. Overall a very enjoyable evening. Will try the happy hour bar on the other side

awesome night. staff and piano guy were fantastic. highlight of my time in new york x

The food was so yummy and our server made the experience very enjoyable. I had the Seafood Trio with the white wine sauce. It was so fresh and delicious. I also had Creme Brûlée for dessert.

Before the theater, we got to Don't Tell Mama early. They held our reservation for us while we sat next door and enjoyed the piano bar. Our table was squished next to the door for the restroom, which was a little obnoxious. Ryan, our waiter, was awesome - friendly and helpful. The food was great.

From the start the service was outstanding. Our waiter Ryan set the tone and his fun personality and willingness to make our experience amazing stood out and made our daughters 28th birthday so memorable. Food was great, I had Mamas Martini which I loved and it was a pre theatre dinner we will not soon forget. Thanks !!!

You can’t beat the location for pre-theater dining! The staff was very attentive and accommodating. The restaurant was unremarkable for decor. It was very quiet, but it was also very early. I might go back basically because of the location. My entree was good but not outstanding. The biggest disappointment was the size of my dining companion’s entree salad relative to the price. That’s why I gave the food 3 stars and not 4.

The food and service were excellent! We did think the good value we got for the entree was undone by the price of drinks and desserts.

After the show it is very quiet and I crowded in the restaurant. If you dine and want to go next door you go to the front of the line if there is one. Definitely not gourmet but ok after a show.

Very good all around, service and food I would highly recommend.

Excellent meal with great service. In and out in plenty of time for a theatre show. Provided a special menu with appetizer and dessert.

Delicious meal and great pre-fixe menu choices

This is one of my favorite places in the city!! Food is delicious and service is impeccable.
After dinner, I always have a cocktail at the piano bar while listening to Broadway tunes - the singers are AMAZING!!!

The A/C was broken on the hottest day of the summer and food was average.

Had an incredible night . Short ribs were perfect .service excellent.can not say enough good things about the manager Manuel.Professional and friendly.Truly knows his business and makes you feel very special .It was a great night

Came here with a few friends for a midweek get together. Wonderful, and friendly service, impressive wine selection and the food was delicious. Most of the table ordered fish, which was cooked perfectly, and accompanied with the most delicious mashed potatoes and steamed vegetables. We skipped dessert, but ordered up another round of cocktails. The moderate dining room is quite inviting and charming, a nice place to hang out with friends. And the best part is that it was not too loud so we could hear each other. I will definitely return here, and recommend to friends and family.

I had a wonderful dinner at Don’t tell Mama what an amazing cozy restaurant. The food and service was excellent. I do recommend this restaurant 5*

Love this spot - always a fun time. Recommend grabbing dinner and then fun in the piano bar. Pre-fix menu has a good selection and did not disappoint! Ryan was our server and made sure we had such a good time celebrating my cousin's 50th bday with cousins and aunts!

Amazing. Highly recommend for brunch before a Broadway show!

My wife ordered a chicken dish and I ordered tilapia. The chicken was very chewy (tough). My tilapia was cooked too long and was tasteless. The accompanying vegetables and mashed potatoes were very good.

There are so many great restaurants near the Theatre District, that we will most likely not return here.

Not a bad little restaurant but there was a musty mold smell that would prevent me from ever going back. Too many other great restaurants in the area.

We went for an early dinner before the theatre and before the piano bar opened. The restaurant wasn't too busy and had a good vibe which I am guessing would have turned into a great vibe once the piano bar opened. The food was nothing special. Nothing was bad, but it wasn't a meal I'd go back for. I'd be willing to go later in the evening and check out the piano bar, but it's not a place I'd reccomend for an early pre-show dinner.

Had dinner here for the first time before Theater. Very pleasantly surprised. Food was excellent and server very attentive. We sat outside. Just a few tables so I can't comment on the rest of the questions. We would return to this restaurant.

Great lunch before going to a show! My friend and I both ordered the ore- fix lunch and it was all delicious food. Bar drinks were creative and tasty too!

Quaint little place with an adjacent piano bar. Prix fix menu with salad or soup, main dish and dessert, had good choices. Service was good. Went after broadway show matinee.

Great NYC vibe here and nostalgic too. Bygone era sorta nightclub and great food! It’s the total package.

Great service, unfortunately the food was borderline inedible. The chicken Marsala wasn’t good. Chicken was hard to cut. Marsala sauce was more like a gravy. Short ribs were supposed to have red wine reduction but was covered in some type of tomato sauce.

I love being there at the restaurant and the piano bar before and after dinner!

The food was lower than diner grade. It’s small so it was noisy! Very disappointing for a Manhattan Restaurant even being on Restaurant Row. I would never consider going back. Simple plate - tomato and mozzarella was processed and my sauce for ravioli was probably canned. PS they had a B rating.

Overall experience - Great!

Restaurant
+ Good food
+ Nice Ambiance
+ Kid Friendly (at least the waitstaff tried their damndest!)

Music Lounge
- Music was a bit loud, which was fine for the energy but the mic was off
- Hit/Miss on the drinks

We had a great time. Loved the show. Great location and tons of fun.

The food was good but dishes were small and pricey. The kitchen was really slow. Staff was kind.

Went here after a Sunday matinee. Good selection of appetizers and mains. They also have a nice price fixe dinner.

Went after a show. Our server was super sweet and attentive but not pushy. The food was very good. We sat outside and enjoyed people watching while dining.