Pork chops were great. Service was super
Service was attentive and very friendly. Food was average at best, steak was a fair cut with butter and garlic. Clearly not an aged beef. Calamari was also fair, marinara sauce was obviously out of a jar in a ketchup cup.
Food was delicious, service was great. Everyone was so friendly.
Upscale casual, feels like a “local” but also a bistro.
Dan the Man is a terrific server and know how to make sure the drinks match the menu.
Great food. Owner is a great guy. Our service from our waiter was unacceptable tonight.
Food as always was fantastic
Pricey but worth it. Excellent if you are looking to celebrate a special occasion.
i already told 2 friends, they had already been there, they though the place was great, i thanked them for not telling me about the place, we will definitely be back, we have been looking for a place like that
We went here to celebrate my birthday and what a wonderful evening it turned out to be. The ambiance is amazing, great decor and fun music. The bread is awesome, comes with choice of butter, garlic oil and and a hot pepper oil which is our favorite. We got to meet the owner, Brandon, and it added to a wonderful evening. Cheesecake was amazing. Highly recommend dining here, you won’t be disappointed.
We celebrated a birthday. Staff was very attentive and food was fabulous!
This was our 3rd visit and it did not disappoint. We had family in from out of town and they were amazed at just how good the food was, everything from appetizers, to the meals all the way through to desert. Drinks were great also. Definitely will be coming back. Becoming a neighborhood favorite for us!
Second time eating here and was not disappointed. All food from appetizers through entrees were outstanding. Definitely adding to our regular dining list. Great job!
Reservation for 7:00pm on New Years Eve. We were seated promptly. Nice table. Not too crowded in. Sidney, our server, came right over to take our drink order. When the drinks came over, we ordered. Some apps and we all had steak (when in Rome). Food came out in a timely manner. Steaks were cooked as requested. Sizzling hot. Tasted GREAT. As good as the expensive Steak Houses. Sidney came over a few times to ask is everything was Cooke. To our satisfaction. We said. YES. After dinner we ordered dessert. It took quite a while for the desserts to come out. After a while, Brandon, the manager came to our table and apologized for the delay and comped our dessert. Which was very nice of him. The entire dinner was great. And the entire dinner, with cocktails, appetizers, entrees, desserts and coffee for 4 people for $200 it was a great value too. I Definitely recommend it. Will be back there real soon.
We tried this restaurant for the first time on New Years Eve for a celebration. Amazing experience. All food was outstanding from appetizers, to main course through desert. We will definitely be coming back. This will be a new regular for us!
My steak (Delmonico) was so salty it was not edible.
Drinks were great; lots of fun, creative winter cocktails to choose from. Great service.
We like to use a tapas approach to dining. The menu is terrific if pricy, but 3 unique flavors & a w.ell mixed cocktail are hard to resist.
My favorite restaurant to go go with my wife. The service is excellent and the atmosphere is perfect for any occasion. From start to finish any food put on the table is exquisite. The steaks are always perfectly cooked and delicious. Although the food is superb the best part about del monicos is the price. Highly recommended
Great family dinner. Always delicious!
Overcooked steak. Bad service.
Dinners were great. The server was wonderful, bit the kitchen was a bit slow.
Amazing food excellent staff
We were in town to visit our daughter and wanted a nice steak dinner but not at pretentious prices or atmosphere. DelMonico was a perfect option - great neighborhood restaurant with excellent service and food/drinks. Our reservation was ready on time and the drinks were well made. Wine and beer list is very thorough.
We ordered the special - ribeye with mushrooms, onions and crab which was excellent and the bacon wrapped filet - also excellent. The au gratin potatoes which accompanied the steaks were very good as well.
We shared a small dessert of cheesecake bites and strawberries which finished off our meal well.
The restaurant has a nice outside seating area which of course doesn’t work now that summer is over a d the inside a small and cozy... which can be a bit loud, but it’s the “good friends having a good time” kind of loud.
Great food and service as usual
Always always a great time here. Food is amazing and drinks. Staff always on point
Enjoyable. Typical steakhouse fare.
Excellent service and food as always.
I love this place. I only wish I had more time to enjoy on a regular basis.
Delicious food, especially the spring salad. Service was excellent. Will definitely return.
Excellent service and food. As a Cedar Grove teacher I've eaten there a lot and never disappointed.
The food and service were outstanding but the prices were on the high side. It's not a place that I would frequent on a regular basis but would be good for a special occasion. I did like the wide variety of choices, steaks, Italian and Asian.
Let me start by saying we enjoyed our meal very much. My wife and daughter's meals were excellent, the bolognese and the pene vodka. Mine was very good, chick picata, but it was overly lemony for my taste. Salads were fresh with home made dressing and the desserts were yummy. Great pour on the wine. What brings it down a star is that it doesn't know what it wants to be. Is it a funky Italian restaurant or a sports bar? Half the restaurant is a dining room with a cool vibe but the other side, and it's wide open, is a bar with 6 tv screens and sports on. Fans were screaming throughout the meal and that was a drag. I would recommend DelMonico but would say don't go when one of the local teams is on tv.
Appetizers: Yakitori excellent, Cajun shrimp and scallops excellent. We both had the small porterhouse, my guest’s was “blackened,” mine was “Pittsburgh style” I.e. charred. (I had to explain to the waiter what that was...it’s an old-school expression, I guess.) Both steaks were done close to perfection
Bar service very good, but please keep the water glasses filled.
Dissapointing! Food was not as expected , menu is confusing, its Asian, Italian and other. Out of pork chops at 7:15 at night, in a restaurant that had a few tables. Not good.
They charge a corking fee, but when I called they said no corking fee bring your own, not true .
Always get a solid meal here and the service is wonderful!
Great service and food!
Everything was wonderful! A very unique menu
Food as always was incredible but the service as always was lacking, will constantly go back because the food is AMAZING!
Excellent service. Delicious food.
Our second visit was just as great as the first. The service is great, the food is delicious, and the price is amazing. We are definitely coming back.
DelMonico does offer delivery in partnership with Uber Eats. DelMonico also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (973) 433-0333.
DelMonico is rated 4.6 stars by 302 OpenTable diners.
You can book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size.