Peppers | Onions | Mushrooms | Cheddar Cheese
This was our first time there. We got apps, a steak, seafood dish, appetizer and drinks. Everything eas very good and a great value for what we got. Will be going back.
Food was excellent, service was good. Second time there and both times we left very happy. We will definitely be back.
Birthday for my husband
Very enjoyable meal, room a little tight but overall very good experience, will definitely return
I have to start by saying our server was good. My sister and I went to dinner and each ordered apps. They came out quickly, before our drinks and bread. I got sesame chicken skewers and she had shrimp cocktail. Mine lacked salt and flavor. Then our steaks came out, we each ordered the 8oz filet cooked medium. Mine came out medium well and hers was more than medium well, almost no pink at all. We don't like to complain about food but we told the server. There's a difference between a steak being tender at medium and chewy at well done. Our server says he's going to grab his boss. His boss comes over and tells my sister, "Well, we do things differently, that's medium for us." You're telling me your version of medium is no pink? He looks at mine, which has very little pink left because it's cooking further as we sit here arguing (Yes! the boss was arguing with us about steak temps) and tells us the steaks look "comparable." He says if we want a dark pink center we should've ordered medium rare because that's how things work here. Reluctantly we sent her steak back for a "medium rare" which should actually be medium. And guess what, the steak comes out medium rare. I've never been to a place that understands what a temperature is for a steak but just doesn't cook it that way and tries to make my sister and I look dumb. Call it what it is, your chefs can't cook a steak. Medium is medium. This cuntasaurus argued with his customers telling us we should've known the steaks would come like this. It's NOT mentioned on your menu, your server didn't notify us, you just suck and can't cook a steak. And you ARGUED with your paying customers! On top of that, everything lacked salt. Never going back.
Found Delmonico’s after a previous failed reservation elsewhere. Got lucky.
Wine list was good and well priced. A nice surprise.
Note to Delmonico’s please reprint wine list.
Food was well cooked and nicely prepared
Swordfish cake was outrageous. Sautéed chicken
Was great. Portions were generous, and the staff was friendly. Will put on list as a place to go.
We’ll be back !!!
Highly recommended. Great service and even better food. Everyone seemed to care if a good experience was had.
Overall everything was good , kirchen works pretty slow
Very disappointing in every regard. Pathetic steak (worse than grocery store quality) and lobster that was as dry as a sock. Inattentive waiter. We won’t be back.
Great way to celebrate our anniversary. Brandon & the team can be counted on to make for a wonderful experience every time.
Everything was delicious! Staff is always friendly and efficient!
Fantastic appetizer, okay main dish, service was only okay
Had a small 50th birthday party. Everything was perfect. Memorable evening for us all. Food was great and our table and food/drinks were wonderful. Thank you for a great evening.
Never had a bad meal here and staff is excellent
Gustavo was terrific and the patio was the way to go even on a humid night. Love doing our own tapas-style experience: chicken lettuce wraps, pepper sirloin tips, pork tips, tuna ceviche, caprese salad. Throw in a nice apertivo and you’ve got one great summer night.
Keep it going Brandon!
Another place doing more with less staff. Waiter was outgoing and attentive. Food did not disappoint
Great place to grab some drinks and good food. Service is a little slow but it’s worth it.
Great food and drinks. Friendly and accommodating staff. Always a good time!
Service was great. Nice outdoor space. We had high expectations for the food after reading the reviews and were unfortunately left disappointed. Requested steak medium rare and came out medium well.
The steaks (porterhouse and delmonico) were very delicious and we loved them a lot, which is good as that was the main reason why we went there. The bread alongside the different dipping oil options was also very tasty. The garlic fries were unique and different, and I enjoyed them though the sauce was pretty strong and felt a bit too much like gravy. The coconut shrimp and scallops appetizer was delicious but I do think too expensive for the amount of food it comes with.
Delicious & varied appetizers give you the option of doing a tapas-style dinner when you don’t want one main plate. Great summer cocktails and nothing better than dining al fresco.
Great fresh food, great service, and terrific balance of selections on their menu. I never got a bad meal at this place. Highly recommend.
The service was responsive, courteous, and helpful. The food was delicious. Coconut shrimp and scallops and fried calamari were our appetizers. I had the Filet Mignon wrapped in bacon with a side of Gorgonzola sauce which was excellent. We were outside so the ambiance was not wonderful, but that was our choice. We will certainly be eating here again.
Staff was friendly and attentive. Delmonico steak was phenomenal. We will be back for more.
lovely interior and solid service. The food was good but I expected the Delmonico signature steak to be thicker - it was a thin cut not worth the money. I would try it again though.
First time there ... we will definitely be back!
The food was delicious, the apps were great even thee bread ( didn't like the crab cakes) but other then that everything was amazing even the staff. I will be back :)
Upscale restaurant with lovely decor and a very good wine list. Not cheap, but you get very good steak and side dishes. The short ribs were luscious, melting un your mouth. I admire any place which lets the diner decide whether or not to put garlic into mashed potatoes. (NO.) Our waiter was prompt, cheerful, and attentive.
It was a very enjoyable time. My steak was perfectly cooked. Our server was a great help with the menu. I will be going back.
Me and my girlfriend celebrated our 1st anniversary together the ambiance was great food was good and I definitely recommend it for anyone needing a quiet date night with fast food service and good appetizers
Food was all delicious. Service was fantastic
Always great steaks, seafood and drink! A great local value.
The food/Service, and experience was amazing.. We were well cared for throughout the whole time. I mentioned a birthday and asked for a candle in the dessert in my reservation and they did it!
Service was bad never check on table after food came out. Server was told it was our first time and should that he could care less and was a special occasion. I have been in the restaurant business for over 25 years and that was one of the WORST Experiences I have ever had!!!
My short ribs literally fell of the bone!! No knife needed. My friends had penne vodka w/shrimp and steak!!! Everything was delicious!
Superior food, excellent service, beautiful space. What’s not to love. 10/10 will definitely return.
Always enjoyable and the food is always delicious! Solid wine list, cocktails and diverse menu. Something for every taste!
You can order delivery directly from DelMonico using the Order Online button. DelMonico also offers delivery in partnership with Uber Eats. DelMonico also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (973) 433-0333.
DelMonico is rated 4.5 stars by 407 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.