Cull and Pistol

Lovely experience. Delicious, fresh fish. Nice wine selection

Oysters, lobster roll and New England clam chowder are the best in the city!

Not good food more than the oyster.
Not well made.

The food was fabulous and the service was on point.

Delicious food, great service

service, food, restaurant is great . I had an amazing time thank you.

The food was delicious. The Catalán seafood stew was superb and plentiful, the red snapper special also very tasty but portion was small. The wait staff was very attentive but not intrusive. We will return.

Super fresh seafood in a small venue. Great, friendly service. We try to go every time we are in NYC. Oysters and lobster, what’s not to like!

Friendly service, good food and nice environment - what more can you ask for? We really enjoyed our visit!

Food was great, service was an utter disappointment.

Nice food but not tasty ad we would have expected
The place is ideal

Excellent seafood and best wé had furing our stay. Nice service and Chelsea Market gives à spécial touch.

When we travel to NYC this is one place we love to visit and dine at. From the minute you walk through the door you are welcomed and treated so well, everyone is super nice. The energy and the vibe is amazing at this place.. Can't wait to come back soon! Thank you....

Loved it!!

Food was grat

Do you like oysters? Any raw sea food? This is the place just to get everything done and get the most fresh sea food in the city,every time we enjoy this place with the family,lobster roll Connecticut style is the best....thanks for everything can’t wait to be back!!!!!

We went on a recommendation while on a business/ pleasure trip. The restaurant is crammed and you sit on top of your neighbors. The noise level was high. The food was good. My whole lobster was tasty but my boyfriend’s lobster roll was small and fair. The shrimp and lobster dumplings app was tasteless, and a waste of money. Our server disappeared and left us begging to pay the bill.

I believe there are better choices in the Chelsea Market for a meal well over $150 for 2.

We liked it...a little noisy and the food was pretty good. Very limited menu. My husband had a hard time finding something he could eat. eclectic vibe....would probably go back for happy hour but not dinner.

Oysters were amazing ! Best I’ve had ! Lobster Roll was outstanding also

Great food!

Staff was super friendly. Very accommodating.
Awesome food.

Always have a great experience! Food and service is exceptional. Thank you Gabby for a wonderful dinner.

Really great, fresh seafood, creatively prepared. Good vibe. Good value.

Terrible service

Very good food in busy but nice ambience. Very good service!

The worlds best oysters!!!!

Service, food, environment all excellent. Glad we came. Very fresh fish/shrimp...

Brought family in from out of town. Scallops were delicious. Reasonably priced for the location and the food.

Food is excellent and the waitress was lovely and attentive

Raw bar was ok but pricey. Surprisingly, They did not offer a lot of sauces for the seafood tower. The fish and chips were a little greasy with thick layer of batter but fries were thin and crunchy.
Lobster roll was a little on skimpy side but tasty. However, its hard to make a bad lobster roll. Noise level makes it hard to hold a conversation and the loud music playing doesn't help!

The staff was extremely courteous. The food was amazing. Great atmosphere. Jeremy delighted me. I will tell everyone about this lovely place.

Service was awesome. Oysters were so cold and fresh. Squid .... very tasty but cold. Lobster roll skimpy. All food was tasty and well presented. But having a skimpy lobster roll ... cmon. We are New Yorkers. We go to the Montauk, lobster shacks, The Hamptons, Long Island diners... Everyone knows a lobster roll must be overflowing.

Over priced and over hyped....food OK....seating not good....place virtually empty on a Saturday evening...was seated next to kitchen and tablebusing station

Overpriced, minuscule portions. Connecticut Lobster roll was great, the rest of the meal, appetizer to dessert, was so-so, overpriced food. Wish we ate at the hotel.

Best raw bar in Manhattan. Always have a great time going with friends. It is not cheap and don't expect to get in and out quickly. This place is meant to sit and enjoy and order more!!

Amazing food, place and service.
I would gladly come back next time in NYC

very delicious lobster hotpot.
great selection of wine.
very friendly staff.
will come back!

Hoped to have a good time but it wasn't. I live in Chelsea near the restaurant and it was full of tourists. We ordered an appetizer with the waitress and then somehow the manager took the rest of the order, and when our lobsters came, hadn't got the appetizer. She offered to either take it off the bill or bring it after the main course. Neither acceptable. She should have left the waitress to take care of us , so we waited what seemed a long time for the appetizer. Also, after the meal, they only had espresso, no other choices, not even regular coffee. And a single choice for desert.
In retrospect, didn't like how ordering wine went either. They had several wines I'm not familiar with and Sancerre. They insisted on bringing three wines to taste, and I liked the Sancerre the most and ordered it, and she said something snotty about ordering something new Vs. a familiar choice. I liked it the best and don't need someone in a restaurant saying their taste is better than mine. It's run by Lobster Place, the wholesale fish store next door, and they are a lot better at running a store which I got to all the time than a restaurant. I think the absence of customers other than tourists says a lot, locals are not coming back.

Amazing fresh seafood! Great service and atmosphere.

What a lovely little restaurant. Food was amazing. Loved the scallops and tile fish. Our server could not have been kinder or more attentive. Ambiance is a little lacking but fine.