Best Sicilian Restaurants in Lincoln Square

Price: Moderate (29)Price: Expensive (25)Price: Very Expensive (8)

48 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Piccola Cucina Uptown restaurant

1. Piccola Cucina Uptown

4.8

Exceptional(1999)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • Upper East Side

Booked 70 times today

Piccola Cucina Uptown is renowned for its authentic Italian cuisine, consistently garnering high praises from patrons who laud it as one of the best Italian restaurants in town. The diners particularly appreciate the warm hospitality, efficient and friendly service, and the casual, yet cozy ambience. The menu features a wide range of delectable offerings, including fresh, handmade pasta, high-quality seafood dishes, and creative salads. Past patrons rave about the restaurant's Italian wines, with numerous reviews complimenting their excellent selection. Moreover, the seafood crudo and delectable tiramisu have also been highlighted for their outstanding taste. From the reviews provided, it's evident that Piccola Cucina Uptown proudly delivers an immersive and enjoyable Italian dining experience, making it a must-visit destination for all food lovers.

A photo of Carmine's - 44th Street - NYC restaurant

2. Carmine's - 44th Street - NYC

4.6

Exceptional(28999)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • Theater District

Booked 373 times today

Carmine's on 44th Street in NYC is renowned for its outstanding Italian cuisine. Customers frequently rave about the 'real Italian food' and its 'surprisingly delicious' flavours, describing it as 'simply the best'. Reviewers laud Carmine's for the traditional family-style Italian dining experience, with 'big and tasty dishes' that are 'perfect to share'. The Penne alla Vodka is specifically highlighted as 'delicious and flavourful'. The wine list is no less impressive with a vast selection of Italian wines like Sangiovese, Chianti Classico, and Amarone della Valpolicella. The bustling atmosphere, friendly service, and huge portion sizes add to the quintessential New York dining experience. According to many of the satisfied visitors, no visit to NYC would be complete without a meal at Carmine's.

3. Il Melograno

4.7

Exceptional(1248)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • Hell's Kitchen

Booked 9 times today

Il Melograno, a hidden Sicilian gem located in Hell’s Kitchen, is garnering rave reviews as one of the most authentic Italian restaurants in New York City. Patrons, including Italians themselves, herald it as the best Sicilian cuisine they've ever experienced, with comforts like eggplant parmigiana and maccu drawing comparisons to cherished family recipes. Alongside homemade pasta and divine desserts, the restaurant's great service, warm "osterial" atmosphere, and reasonable prices are frequently praised. As one reviewer impressively states, having lived in Florence and Rome, the food is one of the best Italian meals they've ever had. Il Melograno is undoubtedly serving up a truly authentic slice of Italy within the Big Apple.

4. Sempre Oggi

4.6

Exceptional(208)

Price: Very Expensive

• Sicilian • Upper West Side

Booked 37 times today

At Sempre Oggi, we believe there is no greater joy in life than taking time to enjoy food and wine with the ones we love. Our focus is on market-driven, authentic Italian cuisine, reinterpreted for New York City diners. From Sempre A Casa, our at-home experience, to our daily Aperitivi Hour, our menus make the most of what's in season and whatever is most delicious that day.

A photo of Piccola Cucina Estiatorio restaurant

5. Piccola Cucina Estiatorio

4.7

Exceptional(1555)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • SoHo

Booked 74 times today

Piccola Cucina Estiatorio is a highly acclaimed restaurant, known for delivering an authentic Italian culinary experience in the heart of New York City. As the reviews reveal, it is one of the best Italian restaurants in town, especially celebrated for its seafood. It stands out for its great service, and food quality, with a special mention of the delicious branzino and unique pasta dishes like wild boar and truffle ragu, and lobster ragu. The restaurant also boasts an impressive Italian wine list. Guests constantly highlight the friendly service, cozy ambience and value for money. They praise it for maintaining and respecting traditional Italian cooking, offering a taste of Italy with each visit. Moreover, the positive reviews consistently underpin the fresh, excellent, and authentic Italian cuisine, and many anticipate returning for another delightful dining experience.

6. La Masseria

4.8

Exceptional(6597)

Price: Expensive

• Sicilian • Theater District

Booked 53 times today

La Masseria is a highly recommended restaurant famous for its authentic Italian cuisine. The menu boasts an extensive range of traditional dishes, featuring "Costata di Vitello alla Milanese," "Ravioli di Angelina," "Fusilli alla Bolognese," and a swoon-worthy "Tiramisu al Caffe`" for dessert. Reviewers emphasize the excellent food and service, with one stating it as their "new go-to Italian place in NYC," while another praises it as "terrific old-school Italian with contemporary cocktails and classic food options." Other recurring compliments include the perfectly timed courses, inviting atmosphere, professional waitstaff, and delightful pre/post-theater dining experience. Whether you're a local or tourist, La Masseria stands out as an exceptional Italian dining spot.

A photo of Carmine's - 91st Street - NYC restaurant

7. Carmine's - 91st Street - NYC

4.5

Awesome(8370)

Price: Expensive

• Sicilian • Upper West Side

Booked 111 times today

Carmine's - 91st Street - in NYC is an exceptional example of fine Italian cuisine. This restaurant offers a diverse array of dishes from Steak to Seafood, and Desserts to Drinks, encompassing the very essence of Italian flavor. As per reviews, the restaurant is commended for its "great food, great employees, great atmosphere" and the "authentic Italian food" served in family style. The Lasagna is deemed as the best, with the eggplant parmigiana being so good, it's referred to as food made by angels. Another fan-favorite is the world-class Carbonara. With the consistency in service, taste, and portions, Carmine's has been praised as "outstanding" and "the best Italian in NYC."

8. Sicily

4.4

Awesome(467)

Price: Expensive

• Sicilian • Hell's Kitchen

Booked 55 times today

Sicily, a gem nestled in the theater district, impresses with its authentic Sicilian style Italian cuisine. This newly established eatery consistently offers a variety of high-quality dishes - ranging from its fennel salad appetizer, to classic pastas and pizzas, and ending with decadent desserts like the pistachio lava cake. Its unique take on the eggplant parmesan, replacing the common heavy breading and frying with roasting perfection, is a delight. Exclusive offerings like "Pasta alla Norma" and "branzino" add to the authentic experience. Attendees of Broadway shows laud it as the perfect pre-theatre spot, praising not only the superb food, but also the friendly staff, efficient service, and a warm, rustic ambiance.

A photo of Piccola Cucina Osteria - Spring St. restaurant

9. Piccola Cucina Osteria - Spring St.

4.7

Exceptional(2443)

Price: Expensive

• Sicilian • SoHo

Booked 49 times today

Located in the heart of NYC, Piccola Cucina Osteria on Spring St. showcases the essence of excellent Sicilian-Italian cooking. Its consistency in delivering high-quality, authentic dishes has earned it high praises from satisfied customers, many of whom commend the restaurant for its "delicious food" and "fun ambiance". One diner even declared it as "one of the best Italian restaurants in NY". The restaurant's seafood options such as the lobster linguini and Bronzino have been singled out for their exceptional taste, while the table-side tiramisu preparation adds an exciting touch to the dining experience. The staff, including a noteworthy server, Linda, are applauded for their friendliness and excellent service. Perhaps the most telling of all reviews is this one: "Probably the best Italian food outside of Italy" capturing the restaurant's exceptional culinary offerings.

10. Osteria Nonnino

4.5

Awesome(182)

Price: Expensive

• Sicilian • West Village

Booked 53 times today

Osteria Nonnino, located in the bustling West Village/Meatpacking district, offers a delightful array of traditional Italian cuisine, noted for its authenticity and quality. From the outstanding reviews, it is clear that the restaurant takes pride in providing fantastic food and exceptional service. Descriptors such as "excellent", "delicious", "fresh", and "homemade" are repeatedly mentioned to describe dishes like the Fettuccine di Emma, Paccheri Nonnino, and the table side made Cacio e Pepe. It's a testament to the homemade pastas, Italian classics, and an intriguing selection of wines, that customers are eager to return. Their attentive and friendly staff have also earned rave reviews, adding to the charm of Osteria Nonnino.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Explore OpenTable

Lincoln Square

Sicilian