$$$$Precio: Caro • Seafood • Bay Shore
Nestled in the heart of Bay Shore Marina, Nicky’s on the Bay offers an unforgettable waterfront dining experience with sweeping views of the Great South Bay. Specializing in fresh seafood, American classics, and seasonal favorites, Nicky’s is a local favorite known for its laid-back atmosphere, exceptional hospitality, and vibrant sunset views. Whether you're arriving by land or boat, you'll find the perfect setting for everything from casual lunches to romantic dinners. With live music, outdoor seating, and a lively dockside bar, Nicky’s captures the spirit of Long Island summer all season long.