Best Seafood Restaurants in Sheepshead Bay

Price: Moderate (54)Price: Expensive (51)Price: Very Expensive (28)

37 restaurants available nearby

1. Nick's Lobster

4.4

Awesome(528)

Price: Moderate

• Seafood • Mill Basin

Booked 20 times today

Nick's Lobster is a beloved seafood restaurant known for its fantastic menu and hospitality. Reviewers consistently praise the well-prepared dishes, such as the seafood risotto, twin baked lobster tails, and seafood boil. Many gourmands commend the quality and freshness of the seafood, with notes on the lobster being particularly impressive. Diners also applauded the ambiance of the restaurant, highlighting the relaxing, waterfront view. The service at Nick's Lobster is highly rated, with customers mentioning the professional and attentive staff. Numerous views depict the restaurant as an excellent place for special occasions. The restaurant's love for seafood is clear, and it is a top choice for many looking for a memorable seafood experience.

A photo of Level Restaurant & Bar restaurant

2. Level Restaurant & Bar

4.3

Awesome(135)

Price: Very Expensive

• Seafood • Sheepshead Bay

Booked 8 times today

Level Restaurant & Bar has earned high praise for its exceptional European cuisine. Reviewers applaud the dining experience, from the appetizers like sushi and octopus, to the main course options including rib eye steak and sea bass, to the desserts, with crème brulee singled out for recognition. The eatery's ambiance is highly appreciated, adding to the fine dining experience. The staff is noted for their top-notch service and hospitality, enhancing the overall experience. According to one review, the venue exudes an "amazing ambiance", making Level Restaurant & Bar an ideal spot for special occasions like birthdays, anniversaries, or even date nights. The restaurant's modern and elegant interior design is also frequently noted, adding to its charm. From the food to the service to the atmosphere, Level Restaurant & Bar provides an unforgettable dining experience that keeps its visitors coming back.

A photo of Michael's of Brooklyn restaurant

3. Michael's of Brooklyn

4.9

Exceptional(892)

Price: Expensive

• Seafood • Midwood

Booked 14 times today

Michael's of Brooklyn offers an exquisite Italian dining experience that has been praised by many as the best in New York City. A gem tucked away in Brooklyn, it brings together a combination of classic Italian food, exceptional service, and a warm, inviting atmosphere. Diners highlight a wide range of dishes from Veal Parmesan to Chilean sea bass, each prepared to perfection. The restaurant has also been commended for its amazing dessert selection and its "best red sauce in the city". The attentive and friendly staff add to the overall dining experience, making it a place many look forward to revisiting. One review perfectly encapsulates its charm stating, "Michael's is the go to restaurant for a wonderful Italian home style dining experience. Impeccable decor, truly first-class service and a warm friendly atmosphere. The cuisine is to die for." A dining locale with rave reviews for over 28 years, Michael's of Brooklyn stays true to its Italian heritage with its phenomenal Italian food.

4. Ponte Vecchio

4.7

Exceptional(151)

Price: Expensive

• Seafood • Bay Ridge

Booked 9 times today

Ponte Vecchio is an esteemed restaurant lauded for its authentic and delectable Italian cuisine. Situated in Brooklyn, it offers a high-quality dining experience, combining traditional dishes with creative spins on the classics. Its merits are effortlessly echoed by numerous patrons through reviews, with one stating, "Best Italian food since being in Italy!" while another applauds the variety of regional dishes. The ambiance is noted to be perfect for a date night while still catering to large groups. The robust dishes like the Stuffed Veal Chop and Shrimp Fra Diavolo are reported to be immensely popular. The glowing reviews culminate to declare Ponte Vecchio "one of the best Italian restaurants in NY," exemplifying its excellence.

5. Chateau Yaffa

4.5

Awesome(0)

Price: Moderate

• Seafood • Mill Basin

Booked 1 time today

Chateau Yaffa is a breathtaking new restaurant that provides a unique and unforgettable dining experience. Located at 6214 Avenue U, Brooklyn NY 11234, the restaurant features elegant and sophisticated décor with high ceilings, ornate details, and a warm, inviting atmosphere. The menu offers an array of delectable, seasonally inspired dishes, crafted with the freshest and finest ingredients.

6. Strange Delight

4.7

Exceptional(72)

Price: Expensive

• Seafood • Fort Greene

Booked 34 times today

A contemporary take on the classic oyster bar, located in Fort Greene, Brooklyn, near BAM, Barclay's, the Paramount, and Atlantic Terminal. Strange Delight finds its influence in New Orleans and is also inspired by the rich history of oysters in New York. Our menu consists of regional seafood prepared in a variety of styles: Charbroiled Oysters and Shrimp Remoulade share the stage with classic seafood towers and Oysters Rockefeller. A rotating selection of larger plates features items such as Black Cod Almondine and Blackened Swordfish Belly.To drink, Strange Delight updates old classics, serving both a Hurricane and Ramos Gin Fizz service for 2, alongside Martinis and Sazeracs. Our wine and beer lists feature our favorite American producers. Please note: We offer 3 distinct types of reservations:Regular: a table in our back dining roomBar: seats at our back dining room barHigh-top: a higher table with bar stools in our front room with an open kitchen and oyster counter.

A photo of Fulton Fish Co. at Tin Building by Jean-Georges restaurant

7. Fulton Fish Co. at Tin Building by Jean-Georges

4.6

Exceptional(31)

Price: Expensive

• Seafood • Financial District

Booked 14 times today

A sophisticated seafood eatery that boasts a comprehensive raw bar alongside locally-sourced, sustainably-caught fish, paying homage to the historical roots of the Tin Building.

A photo of Mezze on the River restaurant

8. Mezze on the River

4.4

Awesome(586)

Price: Moderate

• Seafood • Battery Park City

Booked 33 times today

Mezze on the River distinguishes itself as an excellent provider of Mediterranean cuisine, with a beautiful location by the Hudson river and glowing reviews from satisfied customers. Renowned for its vibrant decorations, mesmerizing views, and of course, the flavorful and diverse food, Mezze's reputation is further bolstered by the caring and professional staff who demonstrate exceptional service, accommodating the needs of every guest. Dishes such as salmon, lamb meatballs, bronzino, and a variety of dips like spicy feta and hummus are frequently highlighted and praised by diners. Excellent customer service rounds out the superior dining experience, with many customers eager to return for another meal at this splendid establishment.

9. Blue Pearl

4.8

Exceptional(42)

Price: Very Expensive

• Seafood • Stapleton

Booked 8 times today

Blue Pearl offers a vibrant and well rounded menu focusing on fresh seafood with Asian flare and selections that will delight guests with all varieties of dietary restrictions and preferences. Our Cocktail Program highlights innovative mixology and a curated wine and sake list. The impeccable service and attention to detail is only surpassed by the extraordinary ambience and seductive vibe.

10. Thalassa

4.1

Excellent(1490)

Price: Expensive

• Seafood • TriBeCa

Booked 1 time today

Thalassa is celebrated for its authentic Mediterranean cuisine, specializing in a variety of fresh fish dishes. The establishment receives high praise for its healthy offerings and attentive service, as suggested in reviews which appreciate the "beautiful ambiance", "delicious food", and "conscientious and dedicated" staff. Highlights from the menu include the grilled octopus appetizer, seafood trio, and the Mediterranean sea bass. The restaurant consistently impresses diners with its high-quality cuisine, which one reviewer compared to that of any high-end restaurant in NYC. Thalassa's setting, characterized by a Mediterranean sailboat theme, adds to the delightful dining experience, creating a tranquil atmosphere.

How is content generated

Discover best Seafood restaurants in Sheepshead Bay

Discover the allure of seafood dining in Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn, where a variety of restaurants offer a delightful array of oceanic delights. Nestled in this vibrant New York City locale, each eatery showcases its unique interpretation of seafood, from traditional dishes to innovative culinary creations. The dining scene in Sheepshead Bay is renowned for its eclectic mix of flavors and atmospheres, catering to seafood lovers and culinary adventurers alike. Patrons can expect menus brimming with fresh, high-quality ingredients, ensuring each meal is both satisfying and memorable. These establishments take pride in their service, with staff who are knowledgeable about both their menu and the origins of their offerings. Whether you're in the mood for a casual seafood shack or a sophisticated dining experience, Sheepshead Bay's seafood restaurants promise an exceptional gastronomic journey. Enjoy the splendid views of the waterfront while indulging in some of the finest seafood available in New York City.

Explore OpenTable

Sheepshead Bay

Seafood