Best Seafood Restaurants in Caldwell

Price: Moderate (43)Price: Expensive (33)Price: Very Expensive (8)

33 restaurants available nearby

1. P.F. Market

4.5

Awesome(1075)

Price: Moderate

• Seafood • Caldwell

Booked 7 times today

P.F. Market is renowned for its superior seafood cuisine. Customers rave about the freshness of the seafood, from the Chilean Sea Bass to the Seafood Fra Diavolo, with many stating that the dishes are "cooked to perfection," "always fresh," and "expertly prepared." The restaurant is recognized not only for its delicious food but also for its excellent service, with the wait staff often described as "friendly," "attentive," and "respectful." P.F. Market is regarded as a local favourite for many, with one customer even placing it in their "top 5 of the dining out rotation." Be it a special occasion or a simple dinner out, visitors consistently find their meals at P.F. Market to be an enjoyable experience.

A photo of Laboratorio Kitchen restaurant

2. Laboratorio Kitchen

4.8

Exceptional(2289)

Price: Moderate

• Seafood • Montclair

Booked 29 times today

Laboratorio Kitchen has been heralded as one of the finest Italian establishments in Montclair, consistently praised for its unique and elevated take on Italian cuisine. According to customer reviews, not only is the menu diverse and creative, showcasing fresh, high-quality ingredients in dishes like Mushroom Risotto or hand-rolled Ricotta Cavatelli, but the service is unwaveringly excellent. Patrons rave about the restaurant's superb ambience, and it is clear that the staff at Laboratorio Kitchen are experts in their craft. Dishes are constantly lauded as "superb," "delicious," and "outstanding," with the venue often being deemed a "winner" in the local culinary landscape. With its innovative menu and impressive service, Laboratorio Kitchen has cemented its status as a must-visit for lovers of Italian cuisine.

A photo of Crabbae - West Orange restaurant

3. Crabbae - West Orange

4.1

Excellent(97)

Price: Expensive

• Seafood • West Orange

Booked 8 times today

Nestled within Bond’s Tavern, this modern day “speakeasy” brings flavorful large portions of delicious caribbean fusion specialties, music & ambiance.

A photo of Rare, the Steak House restaurant

4. Rare, the Steak House

4.7

Exceptional(1882)

Price: Very Expensive

• Seafood • Little Falls

Booked 16 times today

Rare, the Steak House, is a top-notch steakhouse praised by many for its excellent quality and services. Quoting from multiple reviews, the eatery constantly gets raving feedback for its great service, unique ambiance, and outstanding food, particularly its steaks. Whether it's a cowboy steak or a bone-in tomahawk ribeye, the steaks are said to be “cooked to perfection”. The menu also offers a wide variety of other options including an exquisite seafood selection and indulging desserts. Though some customers find it a bit pricey, the overall dining experience at Rare, the Steak House is highly recommended and described by many as worth the cost.

5. Halcyon Brasserie

4.6

Exceptional(1948)

Price: Moderate

• Seafood • Montclair

Booked 34 times today

Halcyon Brasserie definitely stands out as an exceptional contemporary American cuisine restaurant. The glowing reviews emphasize the attention to quality and creativity in the food, with items like coconut shrimp sushi roll, truffle parmesan fries, seafood paella, and watermelon burrata salad being hailed as exquisite. The restaurant ensures a memorable experience by providing not only superior cuisine but also an enchanting ambiance, including cozy booths and live music. However, some patrons found the noise level and lighting to be less than ideal. Patrons also highlighted the commendable service staff who were attentive, helpful, and friendly. Not only the food selection, but its espresso martini and other potent drinks have also gathered praise. The restaurant is mentioned as a preferred choice for special occasions, thanks to its upscale and lovely atmosphere.

A photo of THAVMA Mediterranean Grill restaurant

6. THAVMA Mediterranean Grill

4.6

Exceptional(671)

Price: Moderate

• Seafood • Livingston

Booked 20 times today

THAVMA Mediterranean Grill, located in Livingston, New Jersey, has established itself as a beloved spot for its outstanding Mediterranean cuisine. The restaurant earns high praises for its deliciously prepared food, friendly service, and welcoming ambiance, being described as "a hidden gem" in many reviews. Customers favor dishes such as the spinach pie, Greek salad, Thavma spreads, calamari, and the lamb and orzo entree. Leveraging both indoor and outdoor seating, THAVMA offers a comfortable dining experience. Reviewers often highlight the authenticity of the dishes and the restaurant's dedication to quality, making it a favorite Mediterranean locale in the area.

7. Lumis

4.7

Exceptional(345)

Price: Moderate

• Seafood • Fairfield, New Jersey

Booked 6 times today

Lumis ranks highly among Italian restaurants, with customers applauding its authentic and delicious cuisine. The restaurant shines through its variety of dishes, including shrimp and avocado, seafood salad, fried calamari, and chicken oreganata, earning approval for their freshness and great flavor. Notably, the chicken oreganata was hailed as the star of the menu, with one reviewer stating, "Sometimes that dish has just too much oregano. This one was really perfect." The staff's super attentiveness and excellent service also enhance the dining experience. Despite the restaurant becoming pretty busy, Lumis manages to maintain its inviting atmosphere, encouraging customers to return. Reviews suggest that Lumis successfully combines a great atmosphere, excellent service, and delicious food, securing its position on top of the Italian dining scene.

A photo of Greek Taverna - Montclair restaurant

8. Greek Taverna - Montclair

4.6

Exceptional(581)

Price: Expensive

• Seafood • Montclair

Booked 9 times today

Greek Taverna - Montclair, located in the heart of Montclair, is renowned for its authentic Greek cuisine. With stellar reviews highlighting excellent service, a warm, inviting atmosphere, and perfectly cooked traditional Greek dishes, dining here becomes a delightful experience. Greek locals themselves have applauded the place for making them feel at home due to its excellent food and service. Many customers commended the delectable food and the generous portions, allowing some to even share for the next dinner. The restaurant also wins praise for being accommodating towards special needs and surprise birthday treats. The added advantage of parking makes Greek Taverna a perfect choice for Greek food lovers.

A photo of Bahama Breeze - Wayne - Wayne Township restaurant

9. Bahama Breeze - Wayne - Wayne Township

4.6

Exceptional(423)

Price: Moderate

• Seafood • Wayne

Booked 4 times today

Bahama Breeze in Wayne Township has been praised for the authenticity and quality of its Caribbean cuisine, making it a popular choice for those seeking a tropical dining experience. Customers have commended the restaurant for its excellent food and service with a special mention for fan-favorites like grilled salmon, Cuban sandwich, and coconut shrimp. The Mojito also comes highly recommended, adding to the Caribbean vibe. Its outdoor seating offers a nice ambiance, especially during warmer weather. Reviewers also frequently mention the knowledgeable and friendly servers that enhance their dining experience. The restaurant's vibrant atmosphere, along with its outstanding food, makes Bahama Breeze a must-visit spot for anyone craving Caribbean flavors.

A photo of Legal Sea Foods - Short Hills restaurant

10. Legal Sea Foods - Short Hills

4.1

Excellent(2594)

Price: Expensive

• Seafood • Short Hills

Booked 26 times today

Legal Sea Foods in Short Hills is renowned for its excellent seafood cuisine. With a long history in the Boston area, this restaurant receives acclaim for consistently delivering fresh and delicious seafood. Whether dining after a day at the mall or stopping by while in the area, patrons appreciate the balance between classic and innovative dishes. Happy customers note the restaurant's exceptional service, generous portions, quality of ingredients, and pleasant atmosphere. However, the restaurant also welcomes constructive feedback, and some customers have expressed the desire for beloved dishes to return to the menu. Whether it's an anniversary lunch, a special occasion, or just a regular meal, Legal Sea Foods never disappoints, cementing its reputation as a go-to seafood destination.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Explore OpenTable

Caldwell

Seafood