Best Pizzerias in Water Mill

A great place to go for drinks or a family meal. The staff is wonderful attentive and hard working.

Great family celebration in a nice atmosphere with great tasting pizza and apps.

Overall always great but portions seem to be getting smaller… Always a favorite though. :)

Absolutely authentic delicious food every time. Extensive menu with classic and amazing specials you won’t find anywhere else. Emilio’s not only has excellent pizza but their dine-in food is the best Italian you’ll find!

Wonderful dinner for 4! Two ordered spaghetti and meatballs, and both proclaimed them to be the best meatballs ever. Another had the sausage and rigatoni and I order the evening’s special of salmon with artichokes and spinach risotto. I was the only one who left a single bite on my plate unfinished. Everyone else left nothing, it was that good. I usually order the salad and meatballs for my meal here, but this was a nice departure. We will be back, again and again. It’s our favorite restaurant in the area, including Mystic.