Best Oyster Bars in East Harlem

This was my first visit to the Mermaid Inn - Chelsea but it won’t be my last. The food was exceptional. I tried one of the special appetizers; a shrimp gazpacho soup, despite not typically liking cold soups, and I was blown away by the clean yet complex flavors. It was a perfect, refreshing summer soup. My companions shared another special - roasted octopus - and a regular menu appetizer - fish tacos. Both were outstanding, but I especially liked the octopus. It was flavorful and meaty. Not at all rubbery like I expected. Entrees were also wonderful. I had the arctic char, and it was cooked to perfection with a lovely, rich sauce. My companions had the Chatham cod (another winner) and the ahi tuna, which was prepared exactly as it should be. I was fortunate to dine with a group of “sharers”, so I was able to sample everything. Nothing warranted a rating below 10/10. Finally, our server, Sue, was delightful. She was attentive without being cloying, made solid, informed recommendations, and helped make our overall dining experience memorable. Sorry if I sound like I am gushing, but as someone who enjoys dining out as much as I can, my Mermaid Inn experience ranks as one of the best I have enjoyed in some time. I look forward to a return visit soon.

Oyster happy hour is amazing! Loves also the slider

Everything was really good. This is my third time coming to this place, and I'm sure I'll be back many more times. 100% recommended.

Great overall value. Beautiful decor, delicious chilled Main lobster…