Best Southwest American Restaurants in Bayville

Price

$$
$$$
$$$$

Regions

FairfieldNassauSuffolkWestchester

Neighborhoods

BayvilleCold Spring HarborEast NorwichGlen CoveGlen HeadGreenwich

Top Rated

CharmingFancyGood for business mealsGood for groupsGood for special occasionsGreat for brunch

Dining Options

All dining options

Delivery only

Takeout only

Seating Options

BarCounterStandardHigh TopOutdoor

Award-winning

MICHELIN

Accessibility

Wheelchair access

69 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

A photo of Ocean @ The Crescent Beach Club restaurant

1. Ocean @ The Crescent Beach Club

4.5

Awesome(2295)

$$$$Price: Expensive

• Mexican • Bayville

Booked 92 times today

Ocean @ The Crescent Beach Club offers an unparalleled seafood dining experience in Bayville, with its breathtaking ocean views serving as the perfect backdrop. The seafood here is nothing short of extraordinary, with diners praising the "deliciously fresh catch of the day" and the "amazing sushi" that consistently impresses. The ambiance and service only enhance the dining experience, making every visit memorable. Reviews highlight the "wonderful food" and describe the seafood dishes as "delicious and fresh," reaffirming the restaurant's commitment to quality and authenticity. For those seeking a seafood feast with a view, Ocean promises a truly exceptional experience.

A photo of Schultzy's Restaurant restaurant

2. Schultzy's Restaurant

4.8

Exceptional(58)

$$$$Price: Expensive

• Mexican • Bayville

Booked 7 times today

Whether a holiday party with family and friends, backyard celebration, birthday bash, anniversary, or corporate networking event, Schultzy's seafood catering provides a vast assortment of the highest-quality lobsters, steaks, shrimp, clams, oysters, and more for any Long Island off-premise catering occasion.

3. Mill Creek Tavern

4.9

Exceptional(897)

$$$$Price: Expensive

• Mexican • Bayville

Booked 6 times today

Nestled in the heart of Bayville, Mill Creek Tavern offers an exceptional dining experience that truly captures the essence of Contemporary American cuisine. Guests rave about the "outstanding food" and "cozy atmosphere," making it a beloved neighborhood gem. The menu showcases a delightful array of dishes, from the tender Sauerbraten Short Ribs to the perfectly Seared Sea Scallops, each prepared with exquisite attention to detail. The restaurant’s warm and inviting ambiance complements its remarkably diverse menu, ensuring a memorable experience. With accolades such as "always excellent food" and "extremely enjoyable evening," Mill Creek Tavern stands out as a must-visit destination for Contemporary American dining.

4. 2 Spring

4.5

Awesome(1251)

$$$$Price: Very Expensive

• Mexican • Oyster Bay

Booked 16 times today

Nestled in the charming neighborhood of Oyster Bay, 2 Spring offers a cocktail bar experience that is as sophisticated as its multi-course American-European dining. Praised as "hands down the absolute BEST spot on Long Island," this restaurant's cocktail bar stands out with its "awesome cocktails" that complement an equally impressive menu. Guests rave about the creative concoctions that elevate their dining experience, making it a must-visit destination for cocktail enthusiasts. The attentive service and skillful mixology ensure that every drink is crafted to perfection, making each visit a memorable one. Discover the art of cocktails at 2 Spring, where every sip is a celebration.

5. Barney's

4.7

Exceptional(246)

$$$$Price: Expensive

• Mexican • Locust Valley

Booked 2 times today

Barney's is a restaurant serving elevated American cuisine in a "country style" Inn. Everything about the experience at Barney's is designed to reflect refined dining, from the beautiful plating to the attentive and helpful staff.Barney's menu is a fusion of new American cuisine and classic French cuisine. All of the produce used in the kitchen is procured from local vendors, The filet mignon has been voted the best on Long Island by local publications. The signature"Famous" Long Island Duck has also become a local favorite. The large selection of seafood along with our fresh seasonal salads and weekly specials will not disappoint.Our dining areas consist of the Hearth Room (dining room w/fireplace), Bar and Parlour which can also be reserved for private parties. We also offer outdoor dining and a have special areas for private dining. Anything from small intimate weddings to baby showers and any other special occasions. Barn holds up to 45 and the outdoor patio up to 60.

6. The Audrey

4.6

Exceptional(42)

$$$$Price: Moderate

• Mexican • East Norwich

The Audrey, nestled in the heart of Oyster Bay, is a gem of Contemporary Italian cuisine that effortlessly combines sophistication with warmth. Diners rave about the "fantastic food" that feels like "being served in your comfortable living room." This charming spot has earned its place as a local favorite for its "excellent small plates" and "delicious cocktails." The menu elevates comfort foods with an Italian twist, and the ambiance is vibrant and inviting. With a curated wine list and live music, The Audrey offers an unforgettable dining experience. It's the perfect destination for a cozy date night or a lively gathering with friends.

7. The Marker

4.6

Exceptional(122)

$$$$Price: Moderate

• Mexican • Glen Cove

Booked 35 times today

Newly renovated restaurant in Glen Cove with views of The Long Island Sound!

A photo of Coach Meeting House restaurant

8. Coach Meeting House

4.9

Exceptional(617)

$$$$Price: Expensive

• Mexican • Oyster Bay

Nestled in the heart of Oyster Bay, Coach Meeting House is a seafood lover's paradise. Renowned for its exceptional seafood offerings, the restaurant ensures every dish is a "delicious" and "amazing" experience. Guests rave about the freshness and quality of the seafood, often describing it as "better than expected." The ambiance is equally praised, with options for cozy igloo dining, making it a unique and memorable setting for enjoying the sea's bounty. The dedicated staff and swift service further elevate the experience, ensuring that every visit is "a great night out." Dive into the authentic flavors at Coach Meeting House!

A photo of The Valley Piano Bar @ The Plaza restaurant

9. The Valley Piano Bar @ The Plaza

4.6

Exceptional(33)

$$$$Price: Moderate

• Mexican • Locust Valley

The Valley Piano Bar @ The Plaza offers an exceptional Mediterranean experience in the heart of Locust Valley. Renowned for its authentic flavors, the restaurant "elevates small plates to an art form," with dishes like swordfish skewers that capture the essence of the Mediterranean. The ambiance, described as "very chic and upscale," complements the European flair, creating a refined yet vibrant dining atmosphere. Guests rave about the "handcrafted cocktails" and the delightful tapas dinner, all set to the backdrop of live piano music. With top-notch hospitality, this local gem ensures an unforgettable evening, making it a must-visit for Mediterranean cuisine enthusiasts.

10. Provisions Market

new

5.0

Exceptional(1)

$$$$Price: Moderate

• Mexican • Oyster Bay

Provisions Market is a cozy neighborhood grocery store featuring a thoughtfully curated selection of specialty and gourmet foods. From fresh produce and quality meats to artisanal cheeses and other culinary treasures, we offer ingredients that inspire. You'll also find a handpicked assortment of distinctive, high-quality housewares and kitchen smallwares.After hours, we welcome you to gather around our table for a hearty meal. We offer a curated multi-course dinner as our sole offering, thoughtfully designed without substitutions or additions served Thursday through Saturday from 5 PM to 9 PM. Our menu is built around local goods, just-picked produce, fresh-caught fish, and warm, homemade bread straight from our bakery.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

R
RobinVIP
New York City •1 review
5.0
Dined 5 days ago
From apps to main course to dessert - food was excellent, service was amazing .
More info
Besito Mexican - RoslynPrice: Expensive• Mexican / Southwestern• Roslyn
•
4.7
D
Diane
New York City •3 reviews
5.0
Dined 6 days ago
It was our first time here and we absolutely loved it!
More info
Besito Mexican - Huntington NYPrice: Expensive• Mexican / Southwestern• Huntington
•
4.7
S
Sharon
New York City •11 reviews
5.0
Dined on Jun 23, 2025
The ambiance is modern and the food delicious. A lot of interesting options to choose from.
More info
Caracara Mexican Grill - East NorthportPrice: Moderate• Mexican / Southwestern• Northport
•
4.5
K
KristinVIP
New York City •111 reviews
4.0
Dined on Jun 10, 2025
Manager/owner is very nice, our server (I think his name was James) was super busy but very attentive and nice. Food is always solid.
More info
Caracara Mexican Grill - FarmingdalePrice: Moderate• Mexican / Southwestern• Farmingdale
•
4.5
M
MARCOVIP
New York City •65 reviews
5.0
Dined on May 5, 2025
First time at this restaurant despite a busy day everything was good friendly service and food.Will going back in the future.
More info
5 De MayoPrice: Moderate• Mexican• Westbury
•
4.1

Explore OpenTable

Neighborhood
Cuisine Nearby
Mexican Cuisine

Bayville

Mexican

Center Moriches
Somers
Islip
Oakdale
Westhampton Beach
Garden City
Tuckahoe
Woodbury
Tarrytown
East Quogue
Manhasset
Bridgehampton
West Sayville
Patchogue
Gilgo
Great Neck
Glen Head
East Meadow
South Salem
Sag Harbor