Best Italian Restaurants in West Milford

Price: Moderate (5)Price: Expensive (4)

3 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Artemio’s Prime & Proper restaurant

1. Artemio’s Prime & Proper

4.8

Exceptional(682)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Ringwood

Booked 3 times today

Artemio’s Prime & Proper in Ringwood, New Jersey, is a beacon for seafood lovers, offering a menu that celebrates the freshest catches. Esteemed for its culinary excellence, the restaurant features dishes that highlight organic and high-quality ingredients. One diner praised the "perfectly cooked sea bass" and urged others to "definitely try the gelato or the almond cake" for dessert. The chef's daily specials promise a delightful surprise with each visit, ensuring an ever-evolving dining experience. With its "beautiful upscale decor" and "lovely caring service," Artemio’s not only serves exceptional seafood but also creates memorable moments for every guest. Whether you're a local or traveling from afar, Artemio’s Prime & Proper promises an outstanding seafood dining adventure, making it a must-visit destination in northern New Jersey.

A photo of Prime 36 Italian Steakhouse restaurant

2. Prime 36 Italian Steakhouse

4.4

Awesome(47)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Warwick

Booked 10 times today

At Prime 36 Italian Steakhouse in Warwick, the seafood offerings are a true celebration of the ocean's bounty, captivating diners with their freshness and quality. The seafood tower, a standout dish, is frequently praised by guests for its "freshest oysters around," showcasing the restaurant's commitment to quality. A diner's review highlights the "exceptional experience" with the seafood tower, emphasizing the overall excellence of the meal. The restaurant's atmosphere complements its dishes, creating the perfect setting for seafood lovers to indulge in well-crafted, authentic flavors. Prime 36's commitment to an unparalleled dining experience is evident, making it a must-visit destination for seafood aficionados in Warwick.

3. Cypress Tavern

4.1

Excellent(169)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Riverdale

Discover the heart of Italian dining at Cypress Tavern in Riverdale, Kinnelon, where Mediterranean magic meets garden-fresh ingredients and treasured family recipes. This premier destination is not just a feast for the taste buds but a spectacle for the senses, boasting a rich, warm interior and enchanting garden seating. Guests rave about the "delicious food" and "exceptional service", making every dining experience memorable. Whether it's savoring the acclaimed short ribs or enjoying live music on the patio, Cypress Tavern promises an authentic Italian flair with every dish. Join us for a meal where "the food was spot on" and every visit is perfect, as enthusiastically expressed by a satisfied diner: "Thank you, Cypress Tavern for making my daughter's day 'perfect'!”

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Explore OpenTable

West Milford

Italian