Best Italian Restaurants in Sicklerville

Price: Moderate (19)Price: Expensive (8)

10 restaurants available nearby

1. Limoncello

4.8

Exceptional(312)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Sewell

Booked 9 times today

Limoncello's reputation for great Italian cuisine is highly vouched for in customer reviews. The restaurant has been praised for its fine dining experience, delicious food, and exceptionally professional service. Diners frequently highlight the restaurant's warm bread, Pappardelle a Modo Mio, Vitello alla Parmigiana, and the homemade limoncello as some of their favorite dishes. The quality and taste of the dishes have patrons returning often, some of them even dubbing Limoncello as their new favorite Italian restaurant. The noise level might be high when crowded, but the outstanding food and service make it worth the visit. The fantastic feed back Limoncello gets from its customers is a testament to their commitment to quality and authenticity of Italian cuisine.

A photo of Villari's Lakeside restaurant

2. Villari's Lakeside

4.3

Awesome(559)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Sicklerville

Booked 2 times today

Villari's Lakeside is a must-visit for lovers of authentic Italian cuisine. The rave reviews consistently reference the exceptional service, breathtaking lake views, and delicious menu offerings. A wide variety of seafood, meat, and pasta dishes are highlighted, with particular praise given to the seafood risotto, veal sinatra, and twin lobster tails. Customers remark that the dining experience at this restaurant is one of the best they've ever had and the establishment is recommended to anyone wanting to enjoy great food in a beautiful setting. As one patron summed it up, "If you want authentic Italian food that doesn’t break your wallet, Villari’s is the place to go."

A photo of LaScala's Fire - Glassboro restaurant

3. LaScala's Fire - Glassboro

4.6

Exceptional(394)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Glassboro

Booked 14 times today

Located in Glassboro, LaScala's Fire has consistently received fantastic reviews for its authentic Italian cuisine. Patrons rave about the diverse menu, highlighting dishes like calamari, wood-fired pizza, and pasta as delicious. Notably, their tiramisu is praised as "excellent", even by those who typically don't like the dessert. The restaurant has cultivated a loyal following with many recommending it as their "go-to" place for family dinners. The speedy service, inviting ambiance, and standout dishes like the burrata board and Sunday Gravy make LaScala's Fire a beacon of Italian gastronomic delight. Even Italian-American customers who have a deep understanding of their native cuisine sing praises for the dining experience here.

A photo of Italian Affair Restaurant restaurant

4. Italian Affair Restaurant

4.6

Exceptional(1222)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Sewell

Booked 5 times today

Italian Affair Restaurant, situated in the heart of Glassboro, consistently delivers an outstanding dining experience with its exceptional Italian cuisine. The food is described as 'authentic', 'fabulous', and 'tremendous' by satisfied customers, leaving no room for doubts about the quality of the dishes. The restaurant pays homage to Italian cuisine with a wide array of menu items from traditional pasta and risotto dishes to unique creations like Chicken Oscar or Pistachio Pork. The house wine, imported directly from Italy, adds to the authentic feel. The portions are generous and the homemade desserts are raved about in many reviews. With excellent service noted as well, Italian Affair Restaurant has become a beloved local dining spot, perfect for everyday meals and special occasions.

A photo of Randall's Restaurant restaurant

5. Randall's Restaurant

4.3

Awesome(138)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Voorhees

Booked 9 times today

Randall's Restaurant is lauded as an excellent choice for Steakhouse cuisine. From the reviews, it's clear that this restaurant excels in preparing top-quality steaks which are praised for being great cuts and deliciously cooked. They offer a varied menu where dishes like crab ravioli, veal dishes, and prime rib are also highly appreciated by customers. The recurring praises for excellent food, along with a well-thought-out wine list, comfortable atmosphere, and professional service, indicate a high standard of dining, making it a must-visit for steak lovers. Its convenient location in Cherry Hill and views of a golf course add to the memorable dining experience at Randall's.

A photo of Adelphia Restaurant restaurant

6. Adelphia Restaurant

4.6

Exceptional(1321)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Deptford

Booked 13 times today

Adelphia Restaurant, a delightful blend of charm and taste, is perfect for those seeking a high-quality American dining experience. The steaks and chicken wings, mentioned as 'so good' and 'crispy and delicious' by many reviews, are particularly praised. The restaurant's welcoming atmosphere, combined with the exceptional service, only enhances the whole dining experience. Reviews also laud the full-sized appetizers, like the crab dip, clams & mussels, and fried calamari, as well as main dishes such as lump crab cakes and steak. The unanimous opinion of reviewers is that Adelphia offers a satisfying and enjoyable dining experience, with 'generous portions' and 'bang for your buck.' The restaurant's commitment to customer satisfaction is evident in their attentive servers, who are mentioned by name in several reviews for providing outstanding service. Whether it's a casual meetup or a special occasion like a birthday, Adelphia is guaranteed to deliver a memorable dining experience.

A photo of Mannino's Cucina Italiana restaurant

7. Mannino's Cucina Italiana

4.7

Exceptional(779)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Pitman

Booked 5 times today

Mannino's Cucina Italiana impressively presents authentic Italian cuisine that is consistently lauded for being delicious and fresh. Customers notably compliment the generous portion sizes and the warm, cozy atmosphere of the restaurant. Despite being a bit on the expensive side, many agree that the quality of the food and exceptional service makes it well worth the price. Special mention goes out to the phenomenal entrees and the divine cappuccino. With its inviting staff and unforgettable dishes, Mannino's Cucina Italiana is known to be a beloved favorite among Italian restaurants. The commitment to tradition and quality promises a dining experience that leaves you craving a return visit.

A photo of Siena Italian Creative Cusine restaurant

8. Siena Italian Creative Cusine

4.8

Exceptional(425)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Voorhees

Booked 2 times today

Siena Italian Creative Cuisine consistently impresses with its quality food and excellent service. Numerous reviews praise its diverse, authentic Italian dishes, with patrons often exclaiming the freshness of the ingredients, and the seasoning expertise applied. Customer favourites include delectable antipasti, seafood specials, and the signature chicken and veal Siena. The restaurant further differentiates itself by offering new and exciting dishes daily, consistently refreshing patrons' palates. Servers, specifically mentioned Yazmin, are lauded for their friendly and attentive demeanor. Many also appreciate the value-for-money aspect of the restaurant's offerings, making Siena a reliable selection for any occasion, whether for a birthday celebration, business lunch, or simple date night.

A photo of Pizzeria Mannino's restaurant

9. Pizzeria Mannino's

4.7

Exceptional(164)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Pitman

Booked 4 times today

Pizzeria Mannino's has quickly established itself as a beacon of excellent Pizzeria cuisine. Customers have consistently praised its range of delicious pizzas, with some noting its 'excellent' service and 'fresh' ingredients. The restaurant's commitment to quality is best evidenced by its use of a wood-fired oven, which greatly enhances the flavor of its pizza. Furthermore, customers also have the opportunity to bring their own beverages, making for a more personalized dining experience. Whether you're catching a show at the nearby Pitman Theater or simply enjoying a night out, Pizzeria Mannino's guarantees an outstanding meal every time.

10. Lucia's Bistro

4.4

Awesome(47)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Pitman

Booked 1 time today

Lucia's Bistro, conveniently located near Rowan University, serves delicious Bistro cuisine, earning praise for its freshly prepared food and generous portions. Reviewers call particular attention to the authentic Italian dishes like Stromboli and Paninis, stating the food is "phenomenal" and "absolutely wonderful". The eatery's ricotta board and desserts, including croissants, donuts, and gelato, are also highly recommended. It's not just the food that makes Lucia's Bistro superior; the restaurant also provides excellent service, with visitors complimenting the friendly staff. The bistro's decor, boasting live-edge wood tables, contributes to the pleasant dining experience, making this restaurant a must-visit for those who appreciate good Bistro cuisine.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Explore OpenTable

Sicklerville

Italian