Best Italian Restaurants in Short Hills

Price: Moderate (80)Price: Expensive (60)Price: Very Expensive (7)

44 restaurants available nearby

1. Fiorino

4.8

Exceptional(1809)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Summit

Booked 13 times today

Fiorino is renowned for its impeccable service and authentic Northern Italian cuisine, touted by many as the "Best Northern Italian Restaurant in NJ". With an impressive range of offerings, from classic pasta dishes to Veal chop and Shrimp Fra Diablo, Fiorino has never failed to impress its customers. Reviewers have repeatedly praised their exquisite food, friendly staff, and warm, authentic ambiance. Whether for a family dinner or a casual meet-up with friends, Fiorino promises an excellent dining experience with their perfect blend of traditional favorites and modern Italian dishes. It is undoubtedly a must-visit destination for lovers of Italian cuisine.

A photo of Scalini Fedeli - Chatham restaurant

2. Scalini Fedeli - Chatham

4.7

Exceptional(2456)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Chatham

Booked 19 times today

Scalini Fedeli in Chatham, New Jersey, has consistently received high praise for its outstanding Italian cuisine. Customers continually express satisfaction with its exceptional service, flavorful dishes, and relaxing ambiance. Highlights from the menu include the perfectly cooked risotto, excellent ravioli, and interesting combinations of unusual ingredients. Many note the generous portion sizes and the extra touches such as amuse-bouche and palate cleansers. The restaurant is heralded as one of the best Italian dining experiences, even described as the best Italian restaurant in New Jersey. The overall consensus from all reviews points to the dedication of the staff and the outstanding quality of the food, creating a dining experience that never fails to impress.

3. Gregorio's

4.8

Exceptional(327)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Chatham

Booked 7 times today

Gregorio's is a highly recommended restaurant, offering the finest Italian cuisine in Chatham, Madison, and Florham Park area. Many customers praise the consistently excellent food and service, with standout dishes including the Rigatoni Sausage, lasagna, shrimp risotto, and Chicken Gregorio. Reviewers frequently attest to the high quality of food preparation, from simple salads to complex entrees, and express admiration for the ambiance, describing it as soothing, cozy, and friendly. They also commend the staff, particularly Sebastian, for the superb service provided. Given these glowing reviews, it's no surprise that Gregorio's has become a well-loved go-to restaurant in the community, serving up the "best Italian food in NJ".

4. La Pergola BYOB

4.7

Exceptional(1609)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Millburn

Booked 9 times today

La Pergola is lauded by patrons as a must-visit destination for authentic Italian cuisine. Guests often emphasize the restaurant's homemade pasta, fresh seafood dishes, and delicious desserts, with repeated praises for the lasagna, pasta, and limoncello cake. Interestingly, several reviewers mention experiencing a touch of Italy while dining at La Pergola. The restaurant is praised for its ambiance, with many reviewers admiring the romantic and calming atmosphere, frequently likening it to a secluded Italian garden oasis. Additionally, patrons appreciate the attentive service and express high admiration for the restaurant's outdoor setting. For many, La Pergola is truly the best Italian experience in Millburn.

5. Basilico

4.7

Exceptional(1629)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Millburn

Booked 5 times today

Basilico stands out in the realm of Italian cooking, consistently praised for its high-quality cuisine and exceptional service. The menu, extensive and diverse, is brimming with delightful Italian offerings such as Piatto Vegano, La Parmigiana, and Branzino alle Erbe. From the creamy Carbonara to the tantalizing Ravioli ai Porcini, every dish is crafted with expertise and precision. Reviews echo a similar sentiment, repeatedly highlighting the delicious food, professional service, and inviting atmosphere. As stated by one frequent diner, "the food is always fantastic" and "the atmosphere is inviting and comfortable." Truly, Basilico captures the essence of Italian gastronomy to perfection.

6. Par 440

3.8

Excellent(307)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Short Hills

Booked 4 times today

Par 440 is a celebrated American cuisine restaurant known for its impressively diverse menu and vibrant atmosphere. From pizzas to pastas, burgers to entrees, the menu boasts a wide array of scrumptious dishes. It also features much-appreciated American classics like BBQ ribs and prime rib, while offering a diverse selection of seafood. According to reviews, diners have highly appreciated the food, service, and ambiance at Par 440, with special mention of the "top notch food" and "excellent service." The restaurant is also praised for its live music, fostering a lively atmosphere that guests find enjoyable. The good pricing and comfortable environment further enhance Par 440's reputation as a prime location for great American cuisine.

7. L'Allegria

4.6

Exceptional(745)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Madison

Booked 2 times today

L'Allegria consistently proves its worth as a superior Italian restaurant through its exceptional service, authentic cooking, and welcoming ambiance. The restaurant has received rave reviews from many customers who emphasize the quality and authenticity of its Italian cuisine. Highlights include a black pasta with lobster special, a loved Bolognese dish, and a wide selection of pastas. Many patrons also hailed the seafood offerings as perfectly cooked. They often praise the restaurant's ability to cater to dietary restrictions whilst maintaining high flavor profiles. The inviting staff and owners contribute to the restaurant's appeal, making every dining experience memorable. Additional standout features include their extensive wine list, a dessert of pistachio iced rum cake filled with cannoli cream, which earned specific admiration from customers, and their flexibility with large parties. The consistent excellence in both food and service solidifies L'Allegria as a staple for Italian cuisine.

A photo of Panevino Ristorante restaurant

8. Panevino Ristorante

4.3

Awesome(951)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Livingston

Booked 2 times today

Panevino Ristorante is highly praised for its authentic Italian cuisine. With a wide-ranging menu that includes Pasta like "Papardelle Bolognese" and "Spaghetti Carbonara", as well as traditional Italian Antipasti like "Arancini" and "Burrata". There are also exquisite main courses such as "Eggplant Parmigiana", and a selection of Authentic Neapolitan Pizzas. Reviewers frequently comment on the restaurant’s consistently high-quality food and excellent service, with one regular patron dubbing it their favorite Italian restaurant. The "legendary eggplant parm" and "healthy salad options" were particularly recommended. Coupled with the friendly management, refreshing iced tea, and generous portions, Panevino Ristorante is an undisputed destination for lovers of Italian cuisine.

9. Felina - Summit

new

(0)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Summit

Felina Summit extends the legacy of Felina Ridgewood and Felina Steak in Jersey City. Guests can indulge in elevated Italian comfort food prepared with modern techniques, showcased in a large scale open kitchen adorned with terrazzo and mosaic marble detailing. A floating kitchen hood adds a contemporary touch, while the restaurant’s grandeur dining room features a fireplace, a 60-seat bar featuring five signature negronis on tap, and a step-down dining area that enhances its inviting ambiance.

10. Mosaico

4.6

Exceptional(722)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Westfield

Booked 1 time today

Mosaico is a highly recommended Italian restaurant loved by locals. Visitors commend it for its consistent quality Italian food and professional service staff. The menu selection is expansive, and the food is always outstanding, fresh, and authentic. The service is frequently praised; one reviewer even describing their waiter, Oscar, as having a sparkling personality. The ambiance contributes to the experience with a lively, friendly atmosphere and a nice bar. There's also live music for entertainment. One happy customer mentioned Mosaico is their new local Italian go-to place, while others keep returning for the daily specials. Undoubtedly, Mosaico excellently represents Italian cuisine.

How is content generated

Discover best Italian restaurants in Short Hills

Discover the charm of Italian cuisine in Short Hills, New Jersey, where a selection of restaurants offers an authentic taste of Italy right in the heart of Essex County. These dining spots cater to a variety of Italian culinary preferences, from traditional dishes like linguine primavera and lobster ravioli to innovative pizzas with unique toppings. Each restaurant promises a delightful dining experience with menus rich in fresh, quality ingredients and recipes passed down through generations. The dining scene in Short Hills is vibrant and diverse, reflecting a strong appreciation for gourmet food and a cozy, welcoming atmosphere. Whether you're looking for a casual dining environment or a more sophisticated setting, the Italian restaurants in Short Hills provide an array of options to satisfy every palate. This area is a true hotspot for food enthusiasts who cherish rich flavors and expertly crafted meals, ensuring every visit is both memorable and satisfying.

Explore OpenTable

Short Hills

Italian