Best Italian Restaurants in Sea Girt

Price: Moderate (19)Price: Expensive (22)Price: Very Expensive (4)

16 restaurants available nearby

1. Whispers

4.5

Awesome(2128)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Spring Lake

Booked 5 times today

Whispers is an acclaimed beacon of Contemporary American cuisine situated in the scenic area of Spring Lake, New Jersey. Patrons maintain an affinity for this charming eatery and often express their satisfaction with phrases such as "always excellent" and "never been disappointed". Reflecting the quintessence of American dining, Whispers serves up a diverse menu featuring extraordinary dishes - from lobster crepes to New York strip steak - which have been termed as "delicious" and "spectacular". While the prices are on the higher end, the consistent quality justifies the expense. The restaurant's cozy, Victorian-style ambiance serves as the perfect setting for a memorable dining experience, making Whispers a cherished jewel of the Jersey Shore.

2. Theresa’s South

4.7

Exceptional(2719)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Bay Head

Booked 32 times today

Theresa’s South offers an exceptional culinary experience, satisfying the palates of customers with its contemporary Italian cuisine. Throughout various reviews, customers are found continually praising Theresa's South for consistently delivering delicious and creatively designed dishes. The high-quality service offered by the staff is another consistent theme running through the comments. Customers particularly enjoyed their unique dish, the Eggplant Pancake, and recommended it as a must-have. The restaurant provides both indoor and outdoor seating options, with many customers expressing their enjoyment of the comfortable and stylish atmosphere. Notably, it offers the convenience of a BYOB (Bring Your Own Bottle) policy, with a liquor store conveniently located nearby.

A photo of La Dolce Vita of Belmar restaurant

3. La Dolce Vita of Belmar

4.5

Awesome(1967)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Belmar

Booked 28 times today

La Dolce Vita of Belmar is an authentic Italian restaurant that is consistently lauded by its customers for its exceptional food and service. Located by the sea, the restaurant offers an oceanfront atmosphere that greatly enhances the dining experience. Patrons praise the food for its freshness, preparation, and sizable portions - with special mention given to the classic Italian dishes, seafood, veal francaise, and pork chops. Other highlights include specialty drinks, personable and memorably attentive staff, and a pleasing ambiance. Notably, first-time diners and regular patrons alike applaud the restaurant for its consistency and overall quality, making La Dolce Vita a beloved Italian spot on the Jersey Shore.

A photo of Cordi's Italian Gourmet restaurant

4. Cordi's Italian Gourmet

4.6

Exceptional(889)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Brick

Booked 12 times today

Cordi's Italian Gourmet is consistently hailed as a premier destination for authentic Italian dining. Customers rave about the delectable dishes, with particular praise going to the veal chop Milanese and the chicken Parmesan, described as "the best around." Reviewers commend the high quality of food and service, often drawing comparisons to the cuisine they've enjoyed in Italy. What resonates across all reviews is the familial atmosphere; the staff and owners of this restaurant are commended for making patrons feel at home. Whether you're an Italian cuisine connoisseur or simply looking for a gourmet dining experience, Cordi's Italian Gourmet is sure to satisfy your craving.

5. AP Rooftop

4.3

Awesome(189)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Asbury Park

Booked 52 times today

On top of the 5th Avenue pavilion in Asbury Park.A sophisticated look with a comfortable vibe including two fireplaces & a lounge area.

6. Brando's

4.7

Exceptional(3652)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Asbury Park

Booked 44 times today

Brando's, situated in Asbury Park, NJ, has earned a reputation for its outstanding Italian cuisine. Endorsed by customers as the "best Italian restaurant in Monmouth County" and even the "best Italian at the shore", Brando's is held in high regard for its variety of succulent dishes, such as the Pork Chop Brando, Rigatoni Vodka, and Veal Napoleon, to name a few. Several patrons have commended the attentive, professional service, which enhances the overall dining experience. The restaurant's warm ambiance, coupled with an authentic touch of the Godfather playing on the TV screen, adds to its charm. Whether for fine dining, special occasions, or a homely meal, Brando's is a choice that "truly never disappoints".

7. Skratch Kitchen

4.9

Exceptional(160)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Bradley Beach

Booked 25 times today

Through a lot of hard work and trial, we created our custom designed rustic menu to ensure you will enjoy high-quality food with memorable flavors.

A photo of Flavia's Cucina Romana restaurant

8. Flavia's Cucina Romana

4.6

Exceptional(476)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Asbury Park

Booked 17 times today

Flavia's Cucina Romana is renowned for its great authentic Roman-Italian cuisine. Patrons consistently praise the food as exceptional, highlighting the perfectly cooked pasta, especially the homemade gnocchi served with a variety of exquisite sauces. Many assert the dishes here mirror the tastes found in Italy itself, with special praise given to the Ragu and Truffle Cream sauces. The restaurant consistently delivers outstanding service, with a comfortable and contemporary atmosphere. A BYOB policy and exciting menu variety further enhance the dining experience. Customers frequently express a desire to return, vouching for the restaurant as a place where authentic Italian food is served at its finest.

A photo of Stella Marina Bar & Restaurant restaurant

9. Stella Marina Bar & Restaurant

4.3

Awesome(1706)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Asbury Park

Booked 13 times today

Stella Marina Bar & Restaurant is a beloved establishment known for its genuine Italian cuisine. The excellence of both its food and service is consistently highlighted by patrons. With dishes described as "outstanding," "prepared in true Italian style," and "always cooked perfectly," Stella Marina exemplifies the true essence of Italian cuisine. As one review states, "Most of the menu IS as you would find it in most common eateries in Italy, well done." Moreover, the service is said to be professional, charming, and efficient, demonstrating the caliber of employees at Stella Marina and their care for customers. The atmosphere and location, right on the boardwalk, add to the overall appeal of the restaurant. With the custom of always pleasing its clientele, Stella Marina Bar & Restaurant has established itself as a go-to place for great Italian food at the Jersey Shore.

A photo of Belmonte's Ristorante restaurant

10. Belmonte's Ristorante

4.0

Excellent(18)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Asbury Park

Booked 19 times today

Belmonte’s Ristorante crafts fine Italian cuisine in its elegant and charming eatery, located in the seaside resort town of Asbury Park. For starters, the portabella mushrooms stuffed with eggplant, spinach and mozzarella and the battered artichoke hearts Francese make excellent choices. If pasta is what you are craving, Belmonte’s Ristorante has many delightful choices, such as the potato gnocchi in a meaty Bolognese sauce, the shrimp pappardelle Roma with mushrooms and asparagus and the fettuccini Frankie with crumbled sausage, escarole and beans. Some of Belmonte’s Ristorante other specialty entrées include the chicken Philadelphia sautéed with shallots, mushrooms and green peppercorns, the filet mignon in sherry wine sauce and the prosciutto and mozzarella stuffed pork chops in a madeira sauce. Be sure to enjoy your sumptuous Italian meal and the beautiful ambience with a glass or two of a fine wine.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Explore OpenTable

Sea Girt

Italian