Best Italian Restaurants in Reisterstown

Service, food and ambiance were great but it was very loud. If we weren’t yelling we could not hear each other.

Great food and great service. A little on the expensive side but overall a great experience. Was pretty loud for a while to the point o could barely hear my 15 year old son sitting across from me . Other than that it was great .

If you’re anywhere near Hunt Valley and don’t stop at Sammy’s, you’re seriously missing out. This gem of an Italian spot feels like stepping into your grandmother’s kitchen—if your grandmother was a culinary goddess with a killer drink menu. The food is authentic, comforting, and full of love—every bite reminds you of home-cooked Sunday dinners. Whether it’s the rich pastas, the perfectly seasoned sauces, or the melt-in-your-mouth meatballs, everything is made with care and tradition. The service is top notch, warm, attentive, and never rushed. And the drinks? Creative, strong, and beautifully made—whether you want a bold Negroni or a refreshing spritz, they deliver every time. Sammy’s isn’t just a meal; it’s an experience. It’s a must-visit, and honestly, once you go, you’ll be planning your next trip back before you leave the parking lot.

We dropped in for dinner and had an excellent experience, from the greeting at the door to our departure we found service to be on point at every turn. We ordered pasta dishes that greatly exceeded our expectations in freshness, flavor profile and composition. Highly recommend!

The food was really delicious and exquisite in quality. Idk if it was the owner or the manager but he helped fix the wobbly table that we got. The drinks are really good, the appetizers are delicious, and the pasta was to die for personally.