Best Italian Restaurants in Port Jefferson

Price: Moderate (16)Price: Expensive (12)Price: Very Expensive (4)

7 restaurants available nearby

1. Pasta Pasta

4.8

Exceptional(2101)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Port Jefferson

Booked 8 times today

Pasta Pasta is renowned for its exceptional Contemporary Italian cuisine. This beloved local establishment stands out for its consistently fresh and perfectly cooked dishes as evinced by numerous glowing reviews. Patrons frequently commend the restaurant's impressive quality maintained over the years, even through ownership changes and pandemic challenges. The menu, cherished for its delectable pasta dishes, never disappoints--with dishes such as the praised pappardelle bolognese lauded for their excellence. The excellent staff, exceptional service, and inviting atmosphere further enhance the overall dining experience, making it a favorite among many and solidifying its reputation as one of the best places for Italian food in the area.

2. Osteria Umbra

4.8

Exceptional(1770)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Smithtown

Booked 11 times today

Located in Long Island, Osteria Umbra has repeatedly been hailed as the best Italian restaurant in the area. Renowned for its "true Italian cuisine", the establishment is noted for its exceptional dishes, ranging from the succulent lobster pasta to the delectable fiorentina steak. The meticulous cooking is complemented by an exclusively Italian wine list, curated by Chef Marco, a sommelier himself. The restaurant's warm and accommodating service, led by knowledgeable staff, enhances the overall dining experience. Osteria Umbra's dedication to culinary perfection, as seen through their ever-changing seasonal menu, truly makes it a beacon of authentic Italian gourmet fare.

A photo of Ragazzi Italian Kitchen & Bar restaurant

3. Ragazzi Italian Kitchen & Bar

4.7

Exceptional(3085)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Nesconset

Booked 20 times today

Ragazzi Italian Kitchen & Bar is highly regarded for its authentic Italian cuisine, providing an exceptional dining experience that consistently leaves customers captivated. A review recurring theme is its remarkable consistency, whether in the quality of the ingredients used, the impeccable service, or the delightful flavors that capture the essence of Italy. A testament to its excellence is the phrase "best Italian place around hands down", with others noting that they frequently visit, some traveling 35 miles. Customers also appreciate its considerate service for gluten-free diners. In all, Ragazzi's is seen as a trusted go-to for Italian food and a top-notch dining experience.

4. Mamma Lombardi's

4.6

Exceptional(499)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Holbrook

Booked 8 times today

Mamma Lombardi's is widely recognized for its exceptional Italian cuisine. The restaurant consistently receives fantastic reviews, with multiple patrons emphasizing the remarkable authenticity of the food. Its loyal customers often highlight the large portions, outstanding service, and an impressive array of menu options that provides an excellent representation of Italian culinary tradition. As one customer noted, "Italian authentic food. Delicious and reasonable priced." Another long-term patron said, "The food is as excellent as it was the very first time." Mamma Lombardi's commitment to quality and authenticity makes it a top choice for Italian dining.

A photo of Pietro Cucina Italiana restaurant

5. Pietro Cucina Italiana

4.6

Exceptional(549)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • St. James

Booked 6 times today

Pietro Cucina Italiana consistently impresses its customers with its authentic Italian dishes, as the numerous reviews testify. Customers frequently praise the restaurant for its incredible, delicious food and exceptional service, with some comparing the experience to dining in Rome or Florence. The eggplant pistachio and pappardelle with short rib ragu stand out as particular favorites among patrons. Reviews also highlight the restaurant's homemade limoncello, a traditional Italian lemon liqueur that provides the perfect finishing touch to any meal. While some patrons wished for a wider variety, the overall consensus is that Pietro Cucina Italiana provides a truly exceptional Italian dining experience.

A photo of Sea Basin Restaurant restaurant

6. Sea Basin Restaurant

4.4

Awesome(737)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Rocky Point

Booked 4 times today

Sea Basin Restaurant, located on Long Island, regularly receives high praise for its impeccable seafood cuisine. From potato-crusted halibut to seafood Porto, reviewers repeatedly endorse the light sauces, excellent seafood quality, and the value for money. "Happy hour specials were excellent", one reviewer said, and another claimed they were "impressed" with their Seafood Porto. The restaurant is renowned not only for its food but also for its service, with one customer lovingly mentioning the hostess and waiter by name. The recurring sentiments of "great food" and "great service", combined with the extensive positive feedback, signal a superb seafood dining experience at Sea Basin.

A photo of Smithtown Pasta House restaurant

7. Smithtown Pasta House

4.7

Exceptional(317)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Smithtown

Booked 5 times today

Located in New York, Smithtown Pasta House is lauded widely for its exceptional Italian cuisine. Multiple reviews cherish the restaurant's "delicious", "amazing", and "excellent" food. It appears to offer a fusion of traditional Italian recipes with a unique spin which heightens their appeal. Patrons have mentioned "outstanding" dishes such as the baked clams, meatballs, shrimp parmigiana with vodka sauce, and their special bronzino. The moderate prices and good portions are also much appreciated. Complimenting the quality of dishes, reviewers consistently commend the excellent service provided by their staff members Gianna, Sue, and Lou. Given these praises, Smithtown Pasta House is definitely a go-to Italian restaurant for many.

How is content generated

Discover best Italian restaurants in Port Jefferson

Discover the charm of Italian dining in Port Jefferson, Suffolk, where every restaurant offers a unique slice of Italy right in the heart of New York State. Renowned for their authentic Italian flavors, these eateries provide an array of options from traditional pasta dishes to innovative Italian fusion cuisine. Each establishment reflects a commitment to quality, using fresh, locally-sourced ingredients to craft meals that satisfy the heartiest of appetites. The dining scene in Port Jefferson is vibrant and diverse, with restaurants set in picturesque locations that combine scenic views with exquisite culinary experiences. Visitors can expect top-notch service and an atmosphere that ranges from casual to upscale, ensuring a perfect setting for both relaxed lunches and elegant dinners. Whether you're a local or a tourist, the Italian restaurants in Port Jefferson promise an unforgettable dining experience, showcasing the best of Italian hospitality and cuisine.

Explore OpenTable

Port Jefferson

Italian