Best Italian Restaurants in Peapack-Gladstone

Price: Moderate (18)Price: Expensive (13)Price: Very Expensive (2)

15 restaurants available nearby

A photo of RISTORANTE IL MONELLO restaurant

1. RISTORANTE IL MONELLO

4.6

Exceptional(66)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Peapack-Gladstone

Booked 5 times today

Ristorante Il Monello is a renowned Italian cuisine destination known for its exquisite food and exceptional service. Its patrons are consistently wowed by the authentic flavors that transport them straight to Italy. Its unique additions like the cheese wheel and complimentary treats like cheese, salami, and zucchini, among other things, add to its charm. Patrons rave about the restaurant's "outstanding service" and "delicious food", with one even declaring it as a place worthy of rivaling any NYC restaurant. From seafood to pasta and veal dishes, every meal is brilliantly prepared. With a cozy ambiance to top, Il Monello offers a memorable dining experience.

2. Ristorante MV

4.7

Exceptional(765)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Bernardsville

Booked 29 times today

Ristorante MV, located in New Jersey, has been acclaimed as "the best Italian food in New Jersey" and "one of the best Italian restaurants in northern New Jersey" by many customers in their reviews. The high quality Italian cuisine, characterized by fresh ingredients, delicious flavors, and beautiful presentations, has consistently impressed diners. The burrata, scallops, homemade pasta, special sauces, and even the desserts have received rave reviews. In addition to the cuisine, the impeccable service, warm atmosphere, and the dedication of the staff have further elevated the dining experience. Return visits are common, with customers eager to explore more of the extensive menu and daily specials. The food, ambiance, and overall experience at Ristorante MV are, indeed, "EXCELLENT."

A photo of Trattoria Mediterranea restaurant

3. Trattoria Mediterranea

4.9

Exceptional(1069)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Bedminster

Booked 9 times today

Trattoria Mediterranea is a highly recommended Italian restaurant in New Jersey. With consistent praises about the freshness, quality, and authenticity of its Italian cuisine, it is clear that this establishment captures the essence of traditional southern Italian cooking. Particularly praised by patrons are the home-made pasta, veal chop parmesan, and seafood dishes. The reviews highlight the ample portions, with special mention of being "enough for 2 meals" and providing "a lot of food". The restaurant's ambiance is also acclaimed, described as happy, comfortably elegant, and making customers "feel like family". Despite its popularity, it is noted not to be "terribly expensive", particularly as it operates BYOB with no corkage fee. This family-owned gem offers an excellent dining experience, ensuring a warmth and welcome reminiscent of dining in Nonna's home.

4. Luna Rossa

4.7

Exceptional(14)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Bedminster

Welcome to Luna RossaWe are an Italian restaurant, B.Y.O.B with authentic Italian food with attentive staff, romantic and friendly atmosphere, we have different specials preparex creatively and the most important we accommodating to everyone's wants and needs.We have gluten free food, reasonable prices and lot of parking.We offer party catering and party rooms Don't miss it and live the experience

A photo of Focacceria Ristorante restaurant

5. Focacceria Ristorante

4.8

Exceptional(343)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Basking Ridge

Booked 14 times today

Focacceria Ristorante is frequently lauded as one of the best eateries for Italian cuisine in central and northern New Jersey. The consistently high quality and freshness of the dishes set this place apart. Dishes like the mustard crusted salmon, lamb rack special, and graham cracker gelato receive glowing reviews from regular patrons. The outdoor patio, offering a romantic ambiance, is highly recommended for summer visits. The Thai chili calamari and rigatoni also come with strong recommendations. The establishment stands out with its friendly, professional service and value for money, which contribute to an overall outstanding dining experience.

A photo of Osteria Morini - New Jersey restaurant

6. Osteria Morini - New Jersey

4.8

Exceptional(765)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Bernardsville

Booked 1 time today

Osteria Morini in New Jersey offers an incredible journey through Italian cuisine. Reviews repeatedly rate the restaurant highly for its wonderful dishes, excellent service, and innovative menu. As one of the few establishments in New Jersey that makes its own fresh pasta, Osteria Morini stands out for its dedication to authentic Italian fare. From spectacular roasted sardines and spaghetti pomodoro with a burrata topping to the special crab with bucatini, the inventive dishes leave diners craving for more. The friendly and attentive staff, coupled with an NYC vibe, further helps to craft a unique experience. Visitors highlight it as the best Italian restaurant in New Jersey and an actual 'hidden gem'. The "fresh pasta entrees, roast chicken, Chocolate pudding 'Budino' and Bombolini donuts" are reportedly phenomenal. However, it's not just the food that's impressive; the cocktails, drinks, and beautiful ambiance also receive enormous praise from guests.

A photo of Dante's Ristorante restaurant

7. Dante's Ristorante

4.5

Awesome(42)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Mendham

Dante's Ristorante is highly spoken of by its customers for its excellent service and delightful Italian cuisine. Guests rave about the atmosphere and the willingness of the staff to accommodate special requests, even those not on the menu. Notable dishes include the Gamberi Scampi, Lemon Sole Oreganata, Chicken Breast with asparagus, and Fig and Goat Cheese Ravioli. The mention of Dante's as a 'neighborhood choice' suggests its local popularity, while the pizza receives specific praise as the best in the area. A standout aspect of Dante's is its BYOB policy, letting guests pair their meal with their favorite wine. With excellent food, service, and atmosphere, Dante's Ristorante certainly contributes to the good reputation of Italian cuisine.

A photo of Maggiano's - Bridgewater restaurant

8. Maggiano's - Bridgewater

4.5

Awesome(4520)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Bridgewater

Booked 3 times today

Join us for lunch or dinner at Maggiano's Bridgewater and savor the rich flavors of Italian-American dishes inspired by Nonna’s traditional recipes. Our location is part of The Village at Bridgewater Commons which is a luxury market with a variety of upscale stores. We offer four private event rooms, which expand to accommodate any size event. Visit us at 600 Commons Way or book your reservation today!

9. Cafe Emilia

4.7

Exceptional(653)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Bridgewater

Booked 9 times today

Café Emilia, located in Bridgewater, New Jersey, offers an outstanding Italian dining experience that has captivated its patrons for years. Customers consistently rave about the delicious, authentic Italian dishes, with the Veal Parmesan being touted as the best in the area. Its "friendly and professional" staff, who make diners feel like part of the family, are also a significant draw. The great cocktails, extensive wine list, and delightful desserts further set Café Emilia apart. As reflected in the reviews, the restaurant's exceptional food, service, and atmosphere continue to make it a reliable choice for a special occasion, date night, or even a business meeting. Whether dining indoors or on the beautiful patio, visitors to Café Emilia can expect a truly amazing Italian dining experience.

A photo of Mountain Hill Bistro restaurant

10. Mountain Hill Bistro

4.3

Awesome(9)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Stirling

Mountain Hill Bistro is a sterling example of fine Bistro cuisine. Despite the absence of a menu for reference, the excellence in their culinary offerings is well-reflected in the acclaim from customers, who praise both the food and the warm, attentive service. A beacon of quality, the restaurant is known for consistently providing enjoyable dining experiences. The glowing accolades from reviewers, one of whom excitedly noted, "Always great food and great service with a smile!!", justly emphasize the Bistro's commitment to culinary excellence and definitive customer satisfaction.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Explore OpenTable

Peapack-Gladstone

Italian