Best Italian Restaurants in Milton

Price: Moderate (41)Price: Expensive (33)Price: Very Expensive (8)

13 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Vinny's on Windward restaurant

1. Vinny's on Windward

4.6

Exceptional(2511)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Alpharetta

Booked 3 times today

Vinny's on Windward is a highly praised restaurant that is well-known for its good American cuisine. Located in Alpharetta, Vinny's has been labeled a neighborhood gem and the favorite restaurant of many locals. According to the reviews, this restaurant doesn't disappoint. The food is always excellent and the portions are generous. Customers refer to it as a quality "go-to" restaurant and appreciate the consistency in every aspect of the dining experience. The service is top-notch, with servers going above and beyond to make each dining experience enjoyable. Additionally, its ambiance is universally appreciated, creating a dining experience quite akin to being in "an American Rome's local".

A photo of Colletta - Alpharetta, GA restaurant

2. Colletta - Alpharetta, GA

4.6

Exceptional(2761)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Alpharetta

Booked 32 times today

Colletta in Alpharetta, GA, is a gem for Italian food lovers, offering a splendid gastronomic experience. The restaurant has been praised for its "fantastic" food, with customers raving about their delicious meatballs, shrimp scampi, and homemade spaghetti. The menu offers a variety of Italian dishes such as ravioli, lasagna, and Margherita pizza, which have been described as "amazingly good." Patrons noted that the "authentic Tuscan Italian" food is "cooked and seasoned perfectly," thus offering a taste of Italy in Atlanta. From "excellent" service to an "excellent ambiance," Colletta has been highly recommended. These customer reviews testify to its reputation as the "best Italian" restaurant in the Atlanta area.

A photo of Rena's Italian Fishery and Grill restaurant

3. Rena's Italian Fishery and Grill

4.7

Exceptional(96)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Alpharetta

Booked 27 times today

Rena's Italian Fishery and Grill, located in Alpharetta, GA, is a tribute to Italian heritage and family values. Founded by Executive Chef Darren Henderson, Rena's offers a warm, inviting atmosphere where guests can enjoy traditional Italian dishes and fresh, hand-made pastas. The restaurant features a wood-burning grill and an open kitchen, enhancing the dining experience. Upstairs at Rena's is a versatile event space perfect for gatherings and celebrations. With a focus on quality and authenticity, Rena's promises a memorable culinary journey.

A photo of Luci's Ristorante Italiano restaurant

4. Luci's Ristorante Italiano

4.7

Exceptional(627)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Alpharetta

Booked 7 times today

Luci's Steakhouse comes highly recommended by customers for its impeccable service, delicious food, and generous portions. The restaurant has garnered a reputation for consistently providing top-quality beef, lamb, and shellfish dishes, with customers describing their experiences as "excellent" and "outstanding". There are frequent mentions of the restaurant's attentive service, with staff taking great care to assure a positive dining experience. Customers often vow to return, indicating a high level of satisfaction with the cuisine and atmosphere. High-end dining experiences at Luci's Steakhouse have been compared favorably with other well-known Steakhouses, and it has been referred to as "the best steakhouse in the area."

A photo of Altobeli's Restaurant and Piano Bar restaurant

5. Altobeli's Restaurant and Piano Bar

3.4

Very Good(1519)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Johns Creek

Immerse yourself in the authentic Italian experience at Altobeli's Restaurant and Piano Bar, widely regarded as a hidden gem in the Roswell-Alpharetta area. Patrons rave about this family-owned establishment's amazing food that closely resembles the best Italian cuisine one could find in a New York hole-in-the-wall. The Saltimbocca and Veal Marsala come highly recommended. Besides the food, Altobeli's distinguishes itself with live music each night, creating a warm, inviting atmosphere that delights guests. With its excellent service, reasonable prices, and diverse menu, Altobeli's is the quintessential upscale neighborhood Italian restaurant that never disappoints. Whether you're a regular or a first-time visitor, you're sure to fall in love with Altobeli's.

A photo of Buca di Beppo - Alpharetta restaurant

6. Buca di Beppo - Alpharetta

3.9

Excellent(769)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Alpharetta

Buca di Beppo - Alpharetta is renowned for its truly authentic Italian cuisine, offering a consistently delightful and festive dining experience, as attested by numerous customer reviews. Patrons repeatedly praise the restaurant's wonderfully attentive and personable staff and admire the fun, authentic Italian decor that sets the perfect ambience. The generous portion sizes, offering traditional Italian dishes, are a significant draw, with customers often leaving with leftovers for the next day. The food is highly recommended by customers as consistently delicious, and the Apple and Gorgonzola Salad is hailed "Best Salad in town". Amid the high praise, one reviewer states, "I would have given six stars if they had them – the ambiance was phenomenal, food, and the service were outstanding".

7. Osteria Mattone

4.8

Exceptional(3827)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Roswell

Booked 40 times today

At the heart of Roswell, Osteria Mattone is a true emblem of authentic Italian cuisine. The restaurant is adored for its traditional recipes and exceptional menu selection, featuring dishes from "Farfalle All'Arragosta" and "Gnocchi" to "Torta al Cioccolato e Nocciole" and "Budino Caramellato". As one reviewer claims, this place serves the best local Italian food, with their bread, pasta, and desserts being strikingly authentic. Another reviewer confirms the food here is "scrumptious" and the service "excellent." Whether it's a cozy meal indoors or a charming al fresco experience, Osteria Mattone ensures an unforgettable dining adventure reminiscent of the beautiful landscapes of Italy.

8. Sugo

4.9

Exceptional(4215)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Johns Creek

Booked 14 times today

Sugo offers excellent Italian cuisine that consistently delights its patrons. The reviews speak volumes about the quality of food, with a range of dishes praised from meatball al sugo, eggplant parmigiana, to their divine salmon meal. Several diners have celebrated special occasions at Sugo, with the attentive staff ensuring an unforgettable dining experience. The high recommendation frequency underlines Sugo's superior service and ambiance alongside its culinary prowess. The blend of Italian and Greek cuisine offers a unique twist, with dishes such as Greek flatbread with figs, arugula, basil pesto, and cheese gaining particular mention. Overall, Sugo is a beloved restaurant offering an immaculate dining experience with authentic Italian food.

9. Di Paolo

4.9

Exceptional(1765)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Roswell

Booked 14 times today

Di Paolo is a beloved local gem famously known for its authentic Italian cuisine. Patrons often describe their experiences as exceptional, praising the restaurant for its consistently delicious food, attentive service, and unique, old-school vibe. The restaurant's menu is creatively designed with dishes like pollo arrosto, gamberi e polenta, and special items like summer flounder, all freshly prepared, excellently presented and praised by even the pickiest eaters. "This is the best Italian food we have had since moving from NY," says one customer. Moreover, Di Paolo is not just a restaurant but a vital part of the community. Regular customers, some of them visiting since 1995, love coming back for the excellent food, top-notch service, and the warm welcome remembered even from their last visit. Whether it's a special occasion or just a regular day, this neighborhood restaurant ensures a memorable Italian dining experience that always keeps people coming back.

A photo of Trattoria one41 - Johns Creek restaurant

10. Trattoria one41 - Johns Creek

4.9

Exceptional(894)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Johns Creek

Booked 14 times today

Trattoria One 41 is vibrant and bustling with twenty tables and a "Cheers" like bar serving a menu of traditional and seasonal Italian dishes. The unmistakable in-town feel is complemented by its neighborhood warmth and charm. Chef Marc Sublette's innovative take on classical, regional cooking begins with the finest, artisan ingredients and freshest, seasonal products. The distinctive and flavorful dishes are pure and satisfying and perfectly complemented by an outstanding international wine list. The setting is warm and elegant and the mood quintessential Italian. In pleasant weather, alfresco dinning is offered, further adding to Trattoria One 41's year-round appeal. Trattoria One 41 promotes a "grown up" environment. Open 7 nights, Monday - Saturday 14 years of age and older please; Sundays all ages are welcome. Buon Appetitio!

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Explore OpenTable

Milton

Italian