Enable JavaScript to run this app.
Skip to main content
OpenTable logo
  1. Home
  2. United States
  3. New York City

Best Italian Restaurants in Coney Island


87 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Gargiulo's Coney Island restaurant
Price: Expensive
• Italian • Coney Island
Booked 6 times today
Gargiulo's Coney Island is a renowned Italian restaurant that captivates both locals and visitors with its traditional and exceptional Italian cuisine. Per the glowing reviews, it's frequently praised for its "outstanding" food, "impeccable" service, and a delightful ambiance that isn't overly stuffy but exudes an "excellent ambiance". Patrons especially adored the Italian red sauce, describing it as so "soulful", they felt "like an Italian grandma was in the kitchen stirring the pot for hours". The restaurant also provides an extensive range of wines, imported from various regions of Italy, which elevates the dining experience. Gargiulo's Coney Island is indeed an archetype of true Italian fare.
A photo of Michael's of Brooklyn restaurant
Price: Expensive
• Italian • Midwood
Booked 28 times today
Michael's of Brooklyn offers an exquisite Italian dining experience that has been praised by many as the best in New York City. A gem tucked away in Brooklyn, it brings together a combination of classic Italian food, exceptional service, and a warm, inviting atmosphere. Diners highlight a wide range of dishes from Veal Parmesan to Chilean sea bass, each prepared to perfection. The restaurant has also been commended for its amazing dessert selection and its "best red sauce in the city". The attentive and friendly staff add to the overall dining experience, making it a place many look forward to revisiting. One review perfectly encapsulates its charm stating, "Michael's is the go to restaurant for a wonderful Italian home style dining experience. Impeccable decor, truly first-class service and a warm friendly atmosphere. The cuisine is to die for." A dining locale with rave reviews for over 28 years, Michael's of Brooklyn stays true to its Italian heritage with its phenomenal Italian food.
A photo of Positano restaurant
Price: Very Expensive
• Italian • Bay Ridge
Booked 16 times today
Positano is widely loved for its exceptional Italian cuisine, hailed by many as among the top 3 Italian restaurants in the Tri-state area. Located conveniently in Brooklyn's Bay Ridge, it provides a premium Italian dining experience with its extensive menu. Customers rave about its stellar service and delicious dishes, like the unforgettable Italian egg rolls, the superbly cooked steaks, and the delectable Brazilian Sea Bass. Many also mention its creative and high-quality desserts, notably the Napoleon dessert. Their consistently fantastic food and service have led to it being viewed as a favorite and preferred location for special occasions, even serving as the setting for wedding dinners. The staff's efficiency, friendliness, and professionalism further elevate the overall dining experience at Positano.
A photo of Patrizia's Of Sheepshead Bay restaurant
Price: Moderate
• Italian • Sheepshead Bay
Booked 5 times today
Patrizia’s has been a family oriented concept for over 25 years. Each Patrizia's location is individually owned and operated to ensure that your dining experience at Patrizia’s is always great. As with Italian tradition, every single customer is treated like family. Each dish is prepared with fresh organic ingredients that uses family recipes dating back over 150 years. Aside from dining in, we also provide pick-up, delivery and catering for all occasions. Superb food, impeccable service, and a unique family atmosphere distinguishes Patrizia’s from any other restaurant and makes it a one of a kind experience. With locations in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, The Bronx, Staten Island, Long Island (Hicksville, Massapequa, Commack & Hauppauge), Sheepshead Bay, Manhattan, Maspeth Queens, Red Bank, New Jersey & our always sunny locations in Fort Lauderdale, Deerfield Beach Florida & Aruba...Amazing family style dining is just around the corner.
A photo of Campania Coal Fired Pizza - Bay Ridge restaurant
Price: Expensive
• Italian • Bay Ridge
Booked 19 times today
Campania Coal Fired Pizza in Bay Ridge stands out as an exceptional Pizzeria cuisine. Earning laudable reviews from numerous customers, it has gained loyalty for its delicious Italian food, particularly its mouthwatering pizza, that have been said to be "the absolute best since living in Italy." This sentiment is echoed by another enthusiast who applauded it as a fantastic neighborhood spot, perfect for weekday lunches or milestone celebrations. Testimonials also commend the inviting ambiance, friendly and knowledgeable staff, and large portions. This distinctive pizzeria is highly recommended, with many looking forward to return visits, reinforcing that Campania Coal Fired Pizza is a noteworthy gem in Bay Ridge.
A photo of Il Colosseo Restaurant And Pizzeria restaurant
Price: Expensive
• Italian • Bensonhurst
Booked 4 times today
Il Colosseo Restaurant And Pizzeria is an authentic Italian gem, consistently recommended by patrons for its exceptional cuisine and service. It stands out as an ideal neighborhood retreat, offering an impressive range of well-prepared dishes along with live music adding to its vibrant atmosphere. Noted especially for the seafood appetizer ‘Misto Mare’ consisting of grilled octopus, shrimp, and baked clams, it captures the soul of Italian culinary traditions. Patrons particularly praise the restaurant's NY pizza, espresso, tiramisu, and frozen lemon cello cocktail. Although not aiming to be an upscale dining spot, it excels in delivering a genuine, high-quality Italian experience. The establishment's excellent staff and heartily cooked dishes resonate deeply with its frequent customers. Undoubtedly, it is a must-visit spot for Italian food lovers.
A photo of Ponte Vecchio restaurant
Price: Expensive
• Italian • Bay Ridge
Booked 4 times today
Ponte Vecchio is an esteemed restaurant lauded for its authentic and delectable Italian cuisine. Situated in Brooklyn, it offers a high-quality dining experience, combining traditional dishes with creative spins on the classics. Its merits are effortlessly echoed by numerous patrons through reviews, with one stating, "Best Italian food since being in Italy!" while another applauds the variety of regional dishes. The ambiance is noted to be perfect for a date night while still catering to large groups. The robust dishes like the Stuffed Veal Chop and Shrimp Fra Diavolo are reported to be immensely popular. The glowing reviews culminate to declare Ponte Vecchio "one of the best Italian restaurants in NY," exemplifying its excellence.
A photo of Malone's Chop House restaurant
Price: Expensive
• Italian • Bay Ridge
Booked 1 time today
Malone's Chop House offers a stellar steakhouse cuisine that's been praised by diners. Reviews testify that the delicious steaks stand out and are worth savoring every bite. Although some believe a reduction in salt in the rub would enhance the taste, the general response about the quality of the steaks is overwhelmingly positive. Additionally, their salads have been recognized for their freshness and flavor. The bread, while not as lauded, still provides a balance to the hearty steak dishes. On that note, Malone's certainly promises an excellent steakhouse experience you wouldn't want to miss.
A photo of Cavatappi restaurant
Price: Very Expensive
• Italian • Bensonhurst
Booked 3 times today
Cavatappi stands out for its excellent Italian cuisine, consistently earning rave reviews from delighted customers. Diners consistently praise the excellent meals accompanied by superb services, in a setting that captures the warmth and intimacy typical of a small neighborhood Italian place. Even in times of high demand, such as Valentine's Day, Cavatappi remains steadfast in delivering quality food and service, without rushing their guests. Customers also compliment the restaurant for its adaptability and commitment to improvement, as reflected in the owners' openness to constructive criticism. Whether a casual outing or special celebrations like birthdays, Cavatappi guarantees a memorable Italian dining experience, with many eager to return.
A photo of Greenhouse Cafe restaurant
Price: Moderate
• Italian • Bay Ridge
Greenhouse Cafe, located in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn, is praised as a stronghold in Continental cuisine, being a fixture in the neighborhood for over 30 years. According to the wealth of positive reviews, the restaurant is applauded for its excellent food quality and diverse menu, including perfectly cooked and seasoned dishes like shrimp scampi, salmon and shell steak. The service is described as friendly, attentive and professional, while the ambiance, especially in their rear "greenhouse" seating area, is considered charming. Many customers have been frequenting the restaurant for years, captivated by the generous portion sizes, reasonable prices, and the welcoming, comfortable atmosphere. The cafe is also noted for its exceptional safety and mask protocols, providing a secure dining environment amid the pandemic.

How is content generated

Discover best Italian restaurants in Coney Island

Discover the charm of Italian cuisine right in the heart of Coney Island, Brooklyn. This vibrant dining scene offers a delightful array of Italian eateries, each serving up authentic dishes that transport diners straight to Italy. From traditional pasta dishes and savory pizzas to sophisticated seafood and meat specialties, the variety is impressive and caters to all tastes. Each restaurant prides itself on using fresh, high-quality ingredients, ensuring that every meal is as flavorful as it is satisfying. Whether you're looking for a cozy spot for a romantic dinner or a lively venue for a family gathering, Coney Island's Italian restaurants provide the perfect setting. Immerse yourself in the rich flavors and warm ambiance that these establishments have to offer, making your dining experience truly memorable. With a focus on culinary excellence and genuine hospitality, Coney Island proves to be a top destination for Italian food lovers.

  • About Us
  • Blog
  • Careers
  • Press
  • Restaurant reservation software
  • Industry insights
  • Hospitality resources
  • Marketing resources
  • Operation resources
  • How to open a restaurant
  • For restaurants
  • For restaurant groups
Join us on
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookies and Interest-Based Ads
  • Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information
  • Cookie Preferences
Copyright © 2024 OpenTable, Inc. 1 Montgomery St Ste 500, San Francisco CA 94104 - All rights reserved.
OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services.
Booking Logo
Priceline Logo
Agoda Logo
OpenTable Logo