Best Italian Restaurants in Caldwell

Price: Moderate (78)Price: Expensive (59)Price: Very Expensive (10)

43 restaurants available nearby

1. The Highlawn

4.5

Awesome(1380)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • West Orange

Booked 15 times today

The Highlawn is acclaimed for its distinctive American cuisine. The restaurant has received rave reviews from customers, emphasizing its excellent food and service. One patron noted, "the food was really good and would definitely come back," while another celebrated the restaurant's "typical American fare." A variety of dishes like the Black Sea Bass and the Chilean Sea Bass, oysters, and tomahawk steak are praised for their quality and taste. The restaurant’s high-quality service is consistently pointed out in reviews, with one customer stating: "Service was amazing. The food (crabcakes, tuna tartare, steak) were all excellent and cooked to perfection." Its ambiance and stunning views of the NYC skyline further enhance the dining experience at The Highlawn, making it a must-visit for lovers of American cuisine.

A photo of Calandras Italian Village restaurant

2. Calandras Italian Village

4.4

Awesome(662)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Caldwell

Booked 2 times today

Calandras Italian Village combines authentic Italian cuisine with a relaxed, comfortable atmosphere, creating a truly enjoyable dining experience. Reviews highlight the quality of the food and the excellent service, with many customers specifically recommending it for both lunch and dinner. The pre-fixed menu offers a variety of choices, including a wide range of main courses and tasty desserts such as chocolate or vanilla cannoli. Whether it's for a birthday celebration, family gatherings, or a simple night out, Calandras has managed to impress with its outstanding food and service. Moreover, the ambiance, particularly during special events, adds to the overall dining experience and makes reservations highly worthwhile. The restaurant is also noted for its bakery, suggesting a broader 'Italian village' experience beyond just dining.

A photo of Laboratorio Kitchen restaurant

3. Laboratorio Kitchen

4.8

Exceptional(2288)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Montclair

Booked 13 times today

Laboratorio Kitchen has been heralded as one of the finest Italian establishments in Montclair, consistently praised for its unique and elevated take on Italian cuisine. According to customer reviews, not only is the menu diverse and creative, showcasing fresh, high-quality ingredients in dishes like Mushroom Risotto or hand-rolled Ricotta Cavatelli, but the service is unwaveringly excellent. Patrons rave about the restaurant's superb ambience, and it is clear that the staff at Laboratorio Kitchen are experts in their craft. Dishes are constantly lauded as "superb," "delicious," and "outstanding," with the venue often being deemed a "winner" in the local culinary landscape. With its innovative menu and impressive service, Laboratorio Kitchen has cemented its status as a must-visit for lovers of Italian cuisine.

A photo of LuNello Restaurant restaurant

4. LuNello Restaurant

4.8

Exceptional(1129)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Cedar Grove

Booked 14 times today

LuNello Restaurant is frequently praised for its remarkable Italian cuisine. Customers regularly rave about the "delicious orichetti, sausage, and broccoli rab", and it's well recognized as one of the best Italian restaurants in the area. The menu offers an impressive range of dishes that are described as "extraordinary Italian food". From the meticulously prepared salmon and veal valdostano—an overall crowd favorite—to a great range of meats, salads, and a wonderful wine list. The quality of service also contributes to its impressive reputation, with the staff often described as outstanding and attentive. Customers constantly express their anticipation to return, making it clear that LuNello Restaurant never fails to exceed expectation.

5. Fresco Da Franco

4.5

Awesome(1452)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Montclair

Booked 13 times today

Fresco Da Franco, located in Montclair, has received an outpouring of rave reviews for their exceptional authentic Italian cuisine. The restaurant is renowned for a well-rounded menu boasting of traditional Italian dishes infused with unique flavors and sauces, as well as unusual brunch options like chicken & waffles. Patrons lauded the aesthetically pleasing ambiance and the top-notch service. They also complemented the fantastic dining experience, gluten-free options, and the large portions. Highlights included pesto shrimp pasta, grilled peach and Gorgonzola salad, salmon dish, and octopus appetizer. Many reviewers tagged it as an ideal place for date nights, meetings, and friendly gatherings.

6. La Cucina Piccola

4.9

Exceptional(568)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Roseland

Booked 5 times today

La Cucina Piccola is an exceptional Italian restaurant known for its innovative, delicious Italian cuisine. It has been hailed by its patrons as one of the best in the area, loved not just for its food but also for the friendly service, comfortable decor, and reasonable pricing. Patrons consistently highlight the innovative menu and daily specials, lauding dishes from veal with sweet peppers to lobster ravioli with shrimp, each prepared hot and to perfection. Being a BYOB establishment, guests are invited to bring their favorite drinks to complement their meals. La Cucina Piccola's free parking and warm ambience add to its charm, making it a "neighborhood gem" where "you're treated like family". Serving large portions at modest prices, the restaurant often requires reservations due to its popularity, especially at peak dining hours. This restaurant is a testament to high-quality Italian cuisine, with its patrons' highest recommendations standing as proof of its excellence.

A photo of Bivio Pizza Napoletana restaurant

7. Bivio Pizza Napoletana

4.9

Exceptional(107)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Montclair

Booked 3 times today

At Bivio our passion is authentic Neapolitan pizza. Napoli... our love of the city, its cuisine, and in particular, its pizza is where our story began. We heard time and time again “It’s all about the dough.” True to Neapolitan tradition, and the passion of the pizzaioli, we construct our pizza using “00” flour from Naples, San Marzano DOP tomatoes, extra virgin olive oil, fresh basil, fior di latte or bufala mozzarella, and sea salt. Our dough is gently mixed using a 28 year old “lieveto madre” (natural yeast culture) then with intense heat is baked in our wood burning il forno. At Bivio all of our dishes are made with the freshest and highest quality ingredients.

A photo of Frank Anthony's Gourmet Italian restaurant

8. Frank Anthony's Gourmet Italian

4.8

Exceptional(293)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Verona, New Jersey

Booked 1 time today

Frank Anthony's Gourmet Italian is widely heralded as a gem within Essex County for its exceptional contemporary Italian cuisine. With a menu boasting classics such as Veal Parmesan, Spaghetti & Meatballs, and Chicken Marsala, coupled with unique offerings like Pork Chop d'Lupo and Frank Anthony's Filet Mignon, it's clear why reviewers characterize this restaurant as unbeatable in its category. The effusive praise extends beyond the menu, with reviewers lauding its fast, pleasant service, generous portions, and consistently fresh food preparation. The restaurant's extensive, flavorful offerings, commitment to excellence, and warm, inviting ambiance secure it as a standout favorite for those seeking quality Italian dining.

A photo of Rare, the Steak House restaurant

9. Rare, the Steak House

4.7

Exceptional(1882)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Little Falls

Booked 12 times today

Rare, the Steak House, is a top-notch steakhouse praised by many for its excellent quality and services. Quoting from multiple reviews, the eatery constantly gets raving feedback for its great service, unique ambiance, and outstanding food, particularly its steaks. Whether it's a cowboy steak or a bone-in tomahawk ribeye, the steaks are said to be “cooked to perfection”. The menu also offers a wide variety of other options including an exquisite seafood selection and indulging desserts. Though some customers find it a bit pricey, the overall dining experience at Rare, the Steak House is highly recommended and described by many as worth the cost.

A photo of Calandra's Mediterranean Grill restaurant

10. Calandra's Mediterranean Grill

4.5

Awesome(591)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Fairfield, New Jersey

Booked 1 time today

Calandra's Mediterranean Grill offers a delightful Italian culinary experience. Located inside the Hampton Inn & Suites Hotel at Fairfield, New Jersey, the family-owned restaurant is praised for its authentic Northern Italian cuisine. Reviewers rave about their "delicious" calamari and light pollo paillard, amongst a variety of fish, chicken, steaks, and house-made pasta. The setting is described as a "beautiful outdoor setting" reminiscent of a Tuscan villa, providing an immersive dining atmosphere. Noteworthy is their handcrafted bread served with olive oil and grated Parmigiana, which receives constant high praises. Excellent service complements the fantastic food, with one reviewer stating, "The staff is always friendly and on top of their game." From the ambiance to the cuisine, Calandra's Mediterranean Grill guarantees a satisfying Italian experience.

How is content generated

Discover best Italian restaurants in Caldwell

Discover the authentic Italian dining scene in Caldwell, New Jersey, where the culinary landscape is rich with traditional flavors and contemporary twists. Nestled in Essex County, this area boasts a selection of Italian eateries that cater to all palates, emphasizing homemade pastas, artisan pizzas, and a variety of Italian specialties that transport diners straight to Italy. Each restaurant in Caldwell offers a unique ambiance, from cozy, family-friendly settings to more sophisticated, romantic atmospheres, ensuring an ideal backdrop for any occasion. These establishments prioritize the freshness of their ingredients, often incorporating locally sourced produce and high-quality imports from Italy, which speaks to the authenticity and care in their culinary practices. Customer reviews frequently highlight not only the exquisite taste of the food but also the exceptional service, noting the warm and welcoming staff that enhances the dining experience. For those passionate about Italian cuisine, Caldwell, New Jersey, is a must-visit destination. The dining scene here reflects a deep appreciation for Italian culinary traditions while also embracing innovation, making each meal a memorable event. Whether you're a local or just passing through, the Italian restaurants of Caldwell promise an enchanting culinary journey that's well worth exploring.

Explore OpenTable

Caldwell

Italian