Best Contemporary Italian Restaurants in Old Fourth Ward

Price: Moderate (3)Price: Expensive (4)Price: Very Expensive (2)

9 restaurants available nearby

1. Atalian

4.6

Exceptional(944)

Price: Expensive

• Contemporary italian • Downtown

Booked 12 times today

Atalian is a highly-rated restaurant serving excellent Italian cuisine. Customers consistently rave about the remarkable service, with many highlighting the staff's attentiveness, kindness, and professionalism. The high-quality food is another point of praise, with reviewers commonly rating it five stars and noting its authenticity. Mentioned dishes include their shrimp scampi, described as the best some have ever had, and the steak marsala. The ambiance is also highly regarded for its stylish decor and relaxed atmosphere. From individual reviews, it is clear Atalian provides a memorable dining experience, making it an essential visit for those in Atlanta craving a taste of Italy.

2. Capolinea

4.7

Exceptional(91)

Price: Moderate

• Contemporary italian • Downtown

Booked 6 times today

Where indulgence is found in a perfectly chilled Martini, prime cut steaks, or delectable handmade pasta. Located on the fourth floor and featuring a vibrant bar scene, sprawling skyline views, and a convivial outdoor terrace, our Signature Restaurant is a destination in its own right. House-made seasonal gelato and sorbet, and Chef-prepared regionally-sourced antipasti pairings make our Italian inspired kitchen the place to be and be seen. When you’re looking for delectable dining in downtown Atlanta, let Capolinea be your final stop.

3. Double Zero

4.5

Awesome(2243)

Price: Moderate

• Contemporary italian • Druid Hills

Booked 12 times today

Double Zero, a renowned Italian restaurant in Atlanta, has consistently been praised for its genuine, scrumptious offerings, with many seeing it as one of the city's top culinary destinations for Italian cuisine. The DZ meatballs and homemade pizzas, made in a wood-fired oven, are specifically noted for their superior taste and authenticity in a number of reviews. Several reviews also highlight the diligent, friendly, and knowledgeable staff for their role in enhancing the dining experience. Despite some criticism about the pricing, the majority of reviews agree that Double Zero offers a delightful, flavorful, and well-serviced dining experience.

4. Pendolino

4.5

Awesome(177)

Price: Expensive

• Contemporary italian • Brookhaven

Booked 29 times today

Pendolino is the new restaurant from chef-owner Kevin Maxey, debuting spring of 2024 in Atlanta. Taking up an Italian disposition – one where eating and culture are inseparable – we are proud to offer Chastain Park a classy-casual neighborhood place.Come join us in our dining room or our sun-filled patio for an unbeatable setting. One side of the restaurant boasts a curved oak wood bar with casual café style seating, and views of the wood burning oven. The main dining room has a lux mix of comfy banquettes, graciously sized booths, and marble topped tables and there is a private dining room that can be enclosed for festive celebrations. Whether you are out for a date night or late night, feasting with friends or family, popping by for an afternoon snack or lingering for a special occasion, we can’t wait to host you.

5. Pricci

4.8

Exceptional(7022)

Price: Very Expensive

• Contemporary italian • Buckhead

Booked 52 times today

Pricci, located in Buckhead, consistently receives high praise for its authentic Italian cuisine. With its upscale yet comfortable ambiance and exceptional customer service, it's a crowd favorite. Their menu features culinary masterpieces such as Regina Margherita Pizza, Veal Scaloppini Piccata, Polpettine, and a range of risottos. Numerous reviews emphasize the exceptional quality of their pasta dishes, and their truffle fries are reportedly the best in Georgia. Many reviewers claim that Pricci offers the "best Italian food in Atlanta," and it seems to impress old and new patrons alike with its superb Italian fare.

6. St. Cecilia

4.7

Exceptional(4174)

Price: Very Expensive

• Contemporary italian • Buckhead

Booked 50 times today

St. Cecilia, a gem located in Atlanta, stands out as an exceptional representation of European cuisine. The restaurant consistently impresses its guests with its authenticity, creativity, and exquisite flavors. Praised as the best Italian restaurant many have ever visited, it's lauded for its flawless service, incredible food, and warm, welcoming ambiance reminiscent of the Italian Riviera. Their menu, featuring dishes like oysters, Branzino, ribeye, and their in-house baked bread, routinely exceeds high customer expectations. The staff's attention to detail, intimate table setups, and knowledgeable recommendations create an unforgettable dining experience. St. Cecilia is truly a beloved favorite for those seeking a slice of Europe in the city.

A photo of North Italia - Buckhead restaurant

7. North Italia - Buckhead

4.4

Awesome(244)

Price: Moderate

• Contemporary italian • Buckhead

Booked 10 times today

North Italia - Buckhead is a testament to good Italian cuisine with its diverse and authentic menu offering everything from Beef Tenderloin Marsala to Spaghetti Bolognese. Reviews highlight the exceptional service and highly enjoyable ambiance. Many customers describe it as the best Italian food they have had since moving to the south, with particular praise given to the white truffle garlic bread and meatballs. Even the drinks have been lauded as "super amazing". This location has also been noted to be just as good as its acclaimed Manhattan Beach counterpart. So, for a delightful and authentic Italian dining experience, North Italia - Buckhead certainly delivers.

8. Dirty Rascal

3.9

Excellent(85)

Price: Expensive

• Contemporary italian • Buckhead

Dirty Rascal is a standout restaurant in Atlanta, praised for its exemplary Contemporary Italian cuisine. Patrons celebrate their return visits with decadent dirty martinis, followed by favorites such as lasagna florettes and ravioli bolognese, paired with a rich bottle of red wine. Reviewers rave about the lasagna, the ricotta tortellini with lamb bolognese, and the chicken Marsala. The ambiance is also commendable, with a live jazz quartet setting an enjoyable tone and a private top-floor lounge for an after-dinner retreat. Though opinions on some dishes vary, Dirty Rascal is generally lauded for its delicious food, excellent service, and vibrant atmosphere, making it a must-visit destination for those seeking authentic Italian fare.

A photo of The Americano - Atlanta restaurant

9. The Americano - Atlanta

4.5

Awesome(629)

Price: Expensive

• Contemporary italian • Buckhead

Booked 19 times today

The Americano, located in Atlanta, is a highly recommended steakhouse that delights its guests with its exquisite steaks and delectable dishes. Reviewers have commended the restaurant for its "unique and delicious flavor" of steaks, further establishing its prominence in the local dining scene. Several reviews highlight the perfection in the preparation of the steaks, which consistently arrive at the desired level of doneness. The exceptional service from the staff, described as "top shelf," also contributes significantly to the overall dining experience. The Americano has certainly left a lasting impression, with many customers keen on revisiting, giving it a 10/10 rating. Truly, it is a place of superior Steakhouse cuisine.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Explore OpenTable

Old Fourth Ward

Contemporary italian