Enable JavaScript to run this app.
Skip to main content
OpenTable logo
  1. Home
  2. United States
  3. New York City

Best Comfort Food Restaurants in Sheepshead Bay

Price
Regions
Neighborhoods
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Award-winning
Accessibility

15 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

A photo of Gargiulo's Coney Island restaurant
1. Gargiulo's Coney Island
4.6
Exceptional(832)
Price: Expensive
• Comfort food • Coney Island
Booked 4 times today
Gargiulo's Coney Island offers an authentic journey into the heart of Contemporary Italian cuisine right in Brooklyn. Known for its "divine" traditional Neapolitan fare, Gargiulo’s combines family recipes that have delighted diners since 1907 with a modern twist. The restaurant is celebrated for its "phenomenal" dishes like pan-seared mozzarella and trofie pasta with pesto, which highlight the fresh, high-quality ingredients and meticulous preparation. Guests rave about the "exceptional service" and the warm, welcoming atmosphere that makes every visit feel like dining with family. With its rich history and dedication to culinary excellence, Gargiulo’s is a cherished gem that continues to impress.
A photo of Rustik Tavern restaurant
2. Rustik Tavern
4.5
Awesome(25)
Price: Expensive
• Comfort food • Bedford-Stuyvesant
Booked 1 time today
Rustik Tavern is a gem in Bedford-Stuyvesant, Brooklyn, offering an authentic taste of American cuisine that will transport you back to "mama's home cooking." With a fiercely flavorful menu, this beloved spot serves everything from classic chicken and waffles to delightful shrimp avocado plantains. Diners rave about the "amazing ambience and vibe," making it perfect for date nights or brunch with friends. The service is consistently praised as "attentive" and "prompt," ensuring a seamless dining experience. Whether you're a long-time local or a newcomer, Rustik Tavern is the quintessential neighborhood "Cheers," where everyone feels right at home.
A photo of La Nonna Ristorante & Bar - Brooklyn restaurant
3. La Nonna Ristorante & Bar - Brooklyn
4.8
Exceptional(1223)
Price: Expensive
• Comfort food • Williamsburg
Booked 13 times today
La Nonna Ristorante & Bar in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, offers an unparalleled experience in Contemporary Italian cuisine. Executive Chef Cono Morena crafts each dish with an authentic touch, inspired by his cherished memories with his grandmother in Teggiano, Italy, and using only the highest quality ingredients. Diners rave about the "amazing food, hospitality, and ambiance," noting that each visit feels like dining at Nonna’s table. The restaurant’s warm and intimate setting, complemented by a remarkable selection of wines, makes it perfect for any occasion. Guests consistently highlight La Nonna as a "must-try" for its exquisite flavors and "top-notch" service, ensuring a memorable culinary journey every time.
A photo of Daisy Duke's Honky Tonk restaurant
4. Daisy Duke's Honky Tonk
4.0
Excellent(1)
Price: Moderate
• Comfort food • Financial District
Welcome to Daisy Duke's, a Western honky-tonk bar nestled in the cobblestones of 47 Stone Street, NYC's oldest street in the Financial District, where the rugged charm of the Wild West meets the vibrant energy of New York City.Every corner tells a different story, from repurposed antique props and memorabilia sourced from famous trade shows and movie sets. Bask in an ambiance of live music, comfort food, and classic cocktails, and choose from intimate hideaways to main stage energy.Daisy Duke's is more than a bar—it's an experience that fuses New York's cosmopolitan edge with the warmth and authenticity of America's heartland.
A photo of Urban Cove Society and Kitchen restaurant
5. Urban Cove Society and Kitchen
3.8
Excellent(44)
Price: Expensive
• Comfort food • Financial District
Booked 3 times today
Urban Cove Society and Kitchen is a vibrant culinary gem in the heart of New York City's Seaport District. Known for its exceptional blend of Modern American and Global, International cuisine, this restaurant offers "unique flavors and fresh ingredients" that celebrate the diverse cultural tapestry of its locale. The menu, praised for dishes like the tender roasted half chicken and juicy double burger, ensures "not a bad bite to be had." The ambiance is described as "cool and relaxing," making it a perfect spot for both casual brunches and experiential dinners. Urban Cove's commitment to quality and authenticity makes every dining experience unforgettable.
A photo of Piccoli Trattoria restaurant
6. Piccoli Trattoria
4.8
Exceptional(305)
Price: Moderate
• Comfort food • Park Slope
Booked 10 times today
Piccoli Trattoria, nestled in the charming neighborhood of Park Slope, Brooklyn, is a true haven for Comfort Food aficionados. With a commitment to quality and simplicity, Piccoli elevates traditional Italian dishes to new heights, using the finest ingredients like Prosciutto di Parma and buffalo mozzarella from Napoli. Diners rave about the "delicious pasta dishes and risottos," noting they can always rely on the restaurant's consistent excellence. The cozy ambiance and friendly service create a welcoming atmosphere that makes you feel right at home. Whether savoring their summer special of sweet corn ravioli or indulging in a decadent dessert, each bite promises an authentic and memorable experience.
A photo of Westville Wall Street restaurant
7. Westville Wall Street
4.7
Exceptional(245)
Price: Moderate
• Comfort food • Financial District
Booked 15 times today
Westville Wall Street is a delightful haven for lovers of authentic Vegetarian cuisine in the bustling Financial District of New York. Known for its "fabulous quality" and "amazing meal" offerings, this restaurant consistently delivers fresh, simple, and delicious vegetarian dishes that leave a lasting impression. The Market Plates, featuring an array of vibrant market vegetables, are a standout favorite among diners, praised as being "delicious every time!" The relaxed and friendly atmosphere, coupled with exemplary service, makes it a perfect spot for brunch, lunch, or dinner. Whether you're a local or just visiting, Westville Wall Street promises a memorable Vegetarian dining experience.
A photo of Seamore's Brookfield Place restaurant
8. Seamore's Brookfield Place
new
4.4
Awesome(276)
Price: Moderate
• Comfort food • Battery Park City
Booked 9 times today
Seamore's Brookfield Place is your coastal escape in the city, offering a delightful selection of sustainable seafood. Enjoy lobster rolls, crispy fish tacos, fresh oysters, savory clam chowder, and perfectly grilled fish, all responsibly sourced. There are also options for vegetarians and meat lovers, including the juicy Seamore's Smash Burger and refreshing kale avocado salad. The lively atmosphere is perfect for casual lunches, celebratory dinners, or fun happy hours. Sip craft cocktails on the spacious patio or enjoy the vibrant ambiance of the 200-seat dining room. With a commitment to sustainability and fresh, flavorful cuisine, Seamore's is the ideal spot for a memorable dining experience.
A photo of Ketchy Shuby restaurant
9. Ketchy Shuby
new
1.5
(0)
Price: Very Expensive
• Comfort food • SoHo
Booked 6 times today
Ketchy Shuby is a sensory experience that transports you to a tropical paradise in the heart of SoHo. Inside, lush green vines hang from the ceiling, vibrant floral pillows decorate plush booths, and warm lighting creates a sunset ambiance. Our menu features eclectic flavors to satisfy every palate. Start with our savory beet tartare, a delightful mix of quinoa, cucumber, and spiced coconut yogurt, or enjoy the decadent pasture-raised chicken with dried apricots, raisins, and rich Madeira sauce. Don't miss the vibrant downstairs lounge, where curated music, evocative lighting, and intimate seating create the perfect atmosphere to connect with friends. Ketchy Shuby is more than just a restaurant; it's a community with a warm and welcoming staff dedicated to making your experience memorable. Discover the magic of Ketchy Shuby and let your senses be captivated.
A photo of Brindle Room restaurant
10. Brindle Room
4.4
Awesome(592)
Price: Expensive
• Comfort food • East Village
Booked 1 time today
Down the block from Thompkins Square Park, celebrity chef Jeremy Spector brings you Brindle Room, serving its award winning Sebastian Burger as seen on Diners, Drive Ins and Dives. Located in New York's East Village is home to eclectic, gourmet comfort food and excellent brunch. Hand crafted cocktails with champagne infusions that leave you feeling bubbly! Come hang out and enjoy the vibes.
‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you
From verified diners like you
  • Taylor
    New York City •2 reviews
    5.0
    Dined 3 days ago
    We had the best time at La Nonna! I've been lucky enough to visit a few times before, but it was the first time for the friends we dined with—and they absolutely loved everything. The food, drinks, and atmosphere were truly exceptional, as always. From the first sip of our cocktails to the last bite of dessert, every detail was perfect. La Nonna never disappoints! Thank you for yet another wonderful and memorable dining experience. We can't wait to come back!
    More info
    La Nonna Ristorante & Bar - BrooklynPrice: Expensive• Italian• Williamsburg
    •
    4.8
  • Darlene
    New York City •1 review
    4.0
    Dined on Apr 20, 2025
    It did take about 10 minutes for someone to help us check in and be seated. Took about 1/2 hour to get service. It was extremely busy and very noisy. Waiter was very good when he was able to give us service. There was some kind of party with band going on in big room made it hard to hear. Waiter was great when he was able to attend to myself and daughter. Food was very good.
    More info
    Gargiulo's Coney IslandPrice: Expensive• Italian• Coney Island
    •
    4.6
  • BarryVIP
    New York City •44 reviews
    4.0
    Dined on Apr 19, 2025
    We used a Groupon voucher for dinner. Food was excellent, although the Groupon was quite limiting for choices, BUT what we’d have was quite delicious.
    More info
    Urban Cove Society and KitchenPrice: Expensive• American• Financial District
    •
    3.8
  • OpenTable Diner
    Chicago / Illinois •1 review
    5.0
    Dined on Apr 16, 2025
    Found this spot after flying into NYC. Great choice in Brooklyn and the food was pretty good. Will definitely come back because we didn’t get to try the Peach Cobbler.
    More info
    Rustik TavernPrice: Expensive• Comfort Food• Bedford-Stuyvesant
    •
    4.5

Explore OpenTable

Discover
OpenTable
  • About Us
  • Blog
  • Careers
  • Press
More
Our sites
Businesses
  • Restaurant reservation software
  • Industry insights
  • Hospitality resources
  • Marketing resources
  • Operation resources
  • How to open a restaurant
  • For restaurants
  • For restaurant groups
Join us on
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookies and Interest-Based Ads
  • Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information
  • Cookie Preferences
Copyright © 2025 OpenTable, Inc. 1 Montgomery St Ste 500, San Francisco CA 94104 - All rights reserved.
OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services.
Booking Logo
Priceline Logo
KAYAK Logo
Agoda Logo
OpenTable Logo