Best Burgers Restaurants in Carnegie Hill

Honestly, this place was amazing from every single standpoint they could control. We had reservations and were easily sat on time. Our server was prompt and approached the table with waters and ever alerted us that burgers do not come with fries. We ordered drinks and food and the food hit the table before the drinks. Everything was delicious and priced fairly. The ONLY negative to this place was the other customers. It was a Saturday at Christmas time and the place was packed. There were tons of tables done eating, with checks just refusing to leave despite the overwhelming numbers of patrons waiting. The waiting patrons were semi inconsiderate of those seated as most insisted on standing inside almost directly on top of tables and those eating. The staff continuously advised people not to do this but they continued. I'm not sure the staff could have done anything else, they were amazing but hopefully someone reading this considers that the next time they are waiting.

Wonderful burger cooked to my and my friend’s perfection. (Me: medium rare and hers: medium well)

Had a delicious brunch and wonderful time at The Blue Dog Cookhouse and Bar! The menu was so impressive!!! Tons of choices and everything we had was prepared perfectly. The staff was very attentive and worked very hard to fulfill all of our requests! We even spent several minutes visiting with the guy in charge ~ a fellow Tennessean who was so welcoming and helpful! He offered us lots of ideas to enhance the rest of our visit to New York and made us feel like we were old friends!

As always , we had a wonderful time dining at Five Napkin Burger. Our server was excellent and the food was delicious.

VERY consistent. Food always good. Service is amazing. Great crowd. A tiny bit loud, but basically energetic and perfect. always!