4 Best British Restaurants In Castle Cary

4 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

1. Macready's

new

4.3

Awesome(3)

Price: Expensive

• British • Sherborne

Booked 12 times today

"The Sherborne is a reborn wonder. Once a grand house with a staircase mural by Sir James Thornhill, whose other works include the paintings on the dome of St Paul’s Cathedral, Sherborne House became so dilapidated that it was placed on the Heritage at Risk register. Now sensitively refurbished, it’s the town’s premier arts venue, with extensive galleries, an impressive events space and shop. The Sherborne also welcomes visitors to the popular Macready’s Restaurant and Bar, serving everything from light bites (from £12) to substantial main courses such as smoked ham hock with confit garlic and leek and pearl barley risotto (£22) and pan-fried gnocchi (£19.50), in an atmospheric and glamorous setting with attentive, unfussy service." As noted by Jon Woolcott in The 50 best museum cafes in the UK, The Guardian (15 April 2025)

A photo of The Lion at Pennard restaurant

2. The Lion at Pennard

4.6

Exceptional(396)

Price: Expensive

• British • Wells

Booked 4 times today

Steeped in history, The Lion dates back about 500 years, and was built when King Charles I was on the British throne and even before the famous Gunpowder Plot of 1605. Originally constructed as a house, for centuries the quirky building has been welcoming visitors as a traditional British pub. With its low ceilings, exposed beams and homely inglenook fireplaces, it has all the charm of what you expect from a historic pub and restaurant. Listed as one of the Britain’s most important buildings, this is a slice of history set right in the heart of the Somerset countryside in a popular English village. The characterful and homely rooms offer a comfortable stay for those wanting to holiday or spend a night or two in this stunning part of the UK. We’re also dog lovers, so your well behaved pooches will get a warm welcome.If you are looking to make a booking for more than 6 people, please contact us directly on 01458 832941

3. Pen Mill Hotel

4.8

Exceptional(2040)

Price: Moderate

• British • Yeovil

Booked 11 times today

Pen Mill Hotel in Yeovil is an exemplary destination for those seeking authentic Home cooking cuisine. Celebrated for its locally sourced ingredients and dishes crafted with care, 90% of the menu is prepared on-site, ensuring a genuine taste of home. With a Taste of the West GOLD award to its name, the restaurant is praised for its welcoming atmosphere and exceptional service. One reviewer fondly noted, “Always first class and a great experience,” underscoring the consistent quality diners can expect. The Pen Mill Hotel’s dedication to high standards in both food and service makes it a must-visit for lovers of heartfelt, home-cooked meals.

A photo of The Restaurant at Charlton House restaurant

4. The Restaurant at Charlton House

4.3

Awesome(4)

Price: Expensive

• British • Shepton Mallet

Quality ingredients put to good effect.At the more formal Charlton House Restaurant our talented chefs invite you to sit down and taste the very best Somerset has to offer. Salmon fresh out the Severn and lamb reared amongst the Mendip Hills is certain to impress. We leave it to good quality, locally sourced ingredients to elevate the flavour profile of our bistro menu.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Best British Restaurants in Castle Cary

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

4 restaurants available nearby

1. Macready's

2. The Lion at Pennard

3. Pen Mill Hotel

4. The Restaurant at Charlton House

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable