Best American Restaurants in Westhampton Beach

Price: Moderate (5)Price: Expensive (9)Price: Very Expensive (1)

9 restaurants available nearby

A photo of The Patio at 54 Main restaurant

1. The Patio at 54 Main

4.7

Exceptional(1087)

Price: Expensive

• American • Hamptons

Booked 13 times today

The Patio at 54 Main in Westhampton is renowned for its superb American cuisine, earning rave reviews from satisfied customers. Highlighted favorites include fish dishes, lamb chops, duck, and particularly, the Halibut with sun gold tomatoes that's described as "terrific". Reviewers also highly praise the excellent service with hosts Erica and Pietro often mentioned for their hospitality. They are particularly recognized for their knowledge of the diverse menu and extensive wine list. An elegant yet cozy ambiance adds to the dining experience. As one reviewer best put it, "Always great food, service. Wait staff very helpful and pleasant." Restaurant-goers consistently express delight at the quality of both the food and the service.

A photo of Trumpets on the Bay restaurant

2. Trumpets on the Bay

4.7

Exceptional(932)

Price: Expensive

• American • Hampton Bays

Booked 18 times today

Trumpets on the Bay located in Eastport, has been hailed as a hidden gem, loved by both locals and visitors for its excellent Continental cuisine. According to reviews, the restaurant consistently provides a fabulous dining experience with perfect food and outstanding service. Besides the delicious food, customers also rave about the beautiful views, which they find relaxing, and the inviting ambiance. They mention a few speciality dishes, including pork chop, filet mignon, chicken riviera and the Tartufo Italian ice cream. Celebratory occasions and family gatherings are particularly enjoyed here, with the restaurant earning a reputation as a favorite venue for special events.

A photo of Mary's Pizza & Pasta restaurant

3. Mary's Pizza & Pasta

4.9

Exceptional(148)

Price: Moderate

• American • Speonk

Booked 6 times today

Mary's Pizza & Pasta exceeds the expectations of a typical "Pizza Joint", offering a consistently delicious and diverse range of high-quality Italian cuisine at reasonable prices. Located in Speonk, this popular local haunt is frequented by both locals and travellers seeking to escape the bustle of the Hamptons. Lauded for its fantastic food, excellent service, and energetic vibe, diners are never disappointed and often return for more of their favorites from the extensive menu. Complimented for its beautiful location and outdoors dining option, Mary's Pizza & Pasta is a "must-visit" location renowned for their attentive staff, relaxed ambiance, and most importantly, their stellar Italian dishes.

A photo of ITA Kitchen - East Moriches restaurant

4. ITA Kitchen - East Moriches

4.3

Awesome(349)

Price: Expensive

• American • Center Moriches

Booked 29 times today

ITA Kitchen - East Moriches is a culinary gem that offers an incredible Italian dining experience. Situated by Tuthill Cove, this waterfront restaurant offers stunning views and a delightful ambiance. A recurrent theme in reviews is the amazing quality of food which is described as a unique blend of Italian flavours with a modern, creative twist. The service is praised as superb, with friendly, knowledgeable servers like Gavin and Rashad, who help enhance the experience with their professionalism. The restaurant's unique offerings, such as the tableside mozzarella and the espresso martini flight are lauded. Reviews also highlight generous portions and fair pricing, as well as the beautiful outdoor dining in the perfect weather. With dishes like linguine with clam sauce, blackened shrimp, and salmon cooked to perfection described as "superb" and "the best," it's no wonder diners are eager to return.

5. Centro 336

4.4

Awesome(38)

Price: Expensive

• American • Hampton Bays

Booked 11 times today

Centro 336 is a farm to fork Italian restaurant located in Hampton Bays, New York. Serving dinner daily, all of our menu items are made in house using many of the East End’s local, in season produce. Our menu centers around family recipes including fresh homemade pasta, individual pizzas from our wood burning oven and dishes with Mediterranean touches, such as clams oreganata, grilled octopus and zucchini chips. Our bar boasts a craft cocktail menu with drinks infused with basil, mint and rosemary grown at the restaurant. While our extensive wine list compliments our plates and customers’ tastes with wines by the glass which will enable customers to sample wines from all regions, or bottles from our glass wine cellar. The location features a main dining room, catering rooms, bar area, separate lounge area, wine cellar and outdoor patio with a wood burning fireplace - perfect for a romantic dinner or your next event year round!

A photo of Bistro 72 At Hotel Indigo East End restaurant

6. Bistro 72 At Hotel Indigo East End

4.2

Awesome(684)

Price: Moderate

• American • Riverhead

Booked 2 times today

The Bistro 72 At Hotel Indigo East End is a gem of American cuisine. Patrons have lauded everything from its Angus beef hamburger with caramelized onions to its noteworthy crab cakes. The restaurant's commitment to quality is evident in every dish, served exactly as requested, with one customer describing their food as "delicious and presented in a pretty and attractive manner." Also highlighted was the establishment's excellent service with staff being described as "terrific", "friendly" and "attentive". Its ambiance, music, and menus cater to a variety of tastes, further cementing Bistro 72 as a go-to spot for both locals and visitors.

A photo of Tweeds Restaurant & Buffalo Bar restaurant

7. Tweeds Restaurant & Buffalo Bar

4.6

Exceptional(348)

Price: Very Expensive

• American • Riverhead

Booked 8 times today

Tweeds Restaurant & Buffalo Bar exemplifies the essence of a quality Steakhouse that has been consistently commended by customers for its superb dishes, particularly its steak. Patrons rave about the "perfectly cooked" Bison Cowboy steak, describing it as "tender and juicy," and the Wagyu strip steak as "off-the-hook." The bison dishes are a unique specialty that brings people back for more. The additional items on the menu, such as the crab cakes, nacho appetizers, and bourbon pie a la mode, have also received high praise. The atmosphere is described as being "nostalgic and beautiful" with "great rustic old fashioned bourbon bar" vibes. It is located in Riverhead, serving both locals and those who are willing to travel for the remarkable cuisine and experience. This steakhouse has evidently built a loyal customer base over the years due to its quality food and service.

A photo of Dark Horse Restaurant restaurant

8. Dark Horse Restaurant

4.7

Exceptional(108)

Price: Expensive

• American • Riverhead

Booked 6 times today

Dark Horse Restaurant has established a reputation for consistently serving exceptional American cuisine. Patrons rave about the variety of dishes, from the scallops and duck to the delectable white mousse and Blondie for dessert. The seasonal menu options are a hit, offering original and non-standard dishes that stand out from typical eateries. Notably, the entire menu is accommodating for gluten-free diet needs, making it a gem for celiac customers. The establishment is praised for using fresh ingredients, resulting in delicious food that entices people to regularly journey from afar. Additionally, the warm, knowledgeable staff ensures a pleasant dining experience, going the extra mile to provide excellent service. The restaurant's farm-to-table approach is also highly commended, further emphasizing its commitment to quality American cuisine.

9. Myles on Main

4.4

Awesome(7)

Price: Moderate

• American • Riverhead

Booked 3 times today

Nestled on Long Island’s Twin Forks, Myles on Main is a family friendly restaurant that offers a harmonious blend of elegance and relaxed dining. With an inviting atmosphere bathed in soft lighting and adorned with tasteful decor, guests indulge in a culinary journey of modern American cuisine. Dedicated to quality and passion, Myles on Main strives to provide a great dining experience for every guest.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Explore OpenTable

Westhampton Beach

American