Best American Restaurants in West Windsor

Price: Moderate (26)Price: Expensive (20)Price: Very Expensive (6)

26 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Seasons 52 - Princeton restaurant

1. Seasons 52 - Princeton

4.8

Exceptional(4153)

Price: Expensive

• American • Princeton

Booked 94 times today

Seasons 52 in Princeton consistently delivers high-quality American cuisine according to numerous reviews. Patrons highlight the diverse offerings on the menu, from the sesame grilled salmon salad and the lobster and mozzarella flatbread, to the Kona-Crusted Lamb Loin and wood-grilled filet mignon. The small portion desserts, such as the pecan pie, are a particular favorite. The restaurant is noted for its outstanding service, with several reviewers naming their servers and commending their attentiveness. It's a preferred destination for special occasions, with one couple noting it was their best anniversary dinner in 13 years. Seasons 52's commitment to delicious food and exceptional service makes it a standout in American cuisine.

2. Mistral

4.6

Exceptional(3100)

Price: Expensive

• American • Princeton

Booked 46 times today

Mistral is renowned for its Contemporary American cuisine that adeptly incorporates a tapas-style approach. Reviews abound with praise for the restaurant's innovative dishes, which combine creativity and excellent execution. The restaurant's intimate setting enhances the dining experience, making it conducive for conversations. The food at Mistral has been described as dynamic, interesting, and nothing short of spectacular, with specific dishes like the prawns, spicy clams, and Mexican Bread Pudding earning high praise. The service is consistently excellent, marked by professionalism, humor, and warmth. From the energetic ambiance to the expertly prepared dishes, Mistral has carved a solid reputation as a great place to enjoy good Contemporary American cuisine.

3. Metro North

4.7

Exceptional(2412)

Price: Expensive

• American • Princeton

Booked 23 times today

Metro North in Princeton, NJ, is a renowned destination for authentic Italian cuisine. Patrons often praise the restaurant's exceptional food and service, as seen in a myriad of rave reviews. With a menu that expertly transcends traditional Italian fare, the restaurant offers perfectly cooked scallops on a bed of mushroom risotto, traditional eggplant lasagna, and the popular Cajun Blue Cheese filet. Diners also laud the beautiful decor and cozy, casual environment, perfect for enjoying Italian comfort food. Metro North has been extolled for its fresh seafood, beautiful outdoor dining, and a wide variety of superb menu options. It's considered a "prime contender" and a "hidden gem", making it a must-visit for anyone seeking Italian cuisine in Princeton.

A photo of The Mauryas Bar and Lounge restaurant

4. The Mauryas Bar and Lounge

4.0

Excellent(51)

Price: Very Expensive

• American • Princeton

Booked 5 times today

Mauryas Bar and Lounge offers Indian and New American cuisines with dedication to uncompromised details, we take pride merging traditions and innovations, combing exotic ingredients with contemporary techniques to create an unforgettable gastronomic experience. Located in the Forrestal Village in Princeton, drawing inspiration from surrounding farmlands and the historic Mauryan Empire. The Three-levels establishment catering to various dining experiences, from corporate events to elegant occasions, so join us for an evening of great dining or the 4pm to 7pm Fun Hour experience, we adhere to a casual elegant dress code, please no short or sandals, thank you so much for your patronage.

5. Ficus

4.3

Awesome(120)

Price: Expensive

• American • Princeton

Booked 6 times today

Ficus is a celebrated restaurant that offers a unique take on Contemporary American cuisine. Hailed by patrons for its great service and exceptional food, this establishment is highly recommended for an intimate, memorable dining experience. From fresh seafood like scallops and duck to classics like succulent steaks and burgers, Ficus prides itself on the quality of its ingredients and the creativity of its menu. One customer lauded the "very unique and good served food," while another praised the "quiet, relaxing atmosphere." With nods to the French cuisine approach to portion sizes, Ficus provides a harmonious blend of global gastronomy and American culinary flare. Its standout dishes, including seafood, lamb, and exquisite desserts have become favorites among locals and visitors alike.

A photo of Jagrah's Restaurant restaurant

6. Jagrah's Restaurant

4.7

Exceptional(87)

Price: Expensive

• American • Princeton

Booked 5 times today

Jagrah's Restaurant is a remarkable find for those seeking top-notch American cuisine. Patrons have lauded the extraordinary cuisine and praised the masterful twists executed on classic comfort foods by Chef James Graham. His southern North Carolina coastal roots shine through in dishes like cornbread, catfish, and mac n' cheese. Reviewers hailed the restaurant as having "great food, great atmosphere," with some of the stand-out meals being the catfish and oxtail. The restaurant's dedication to providing a pleasant and professional dining experience, excellent service, and creative food selections help to single it out as a prime destination for American dining. In true American spirit, the restaurant is also commended for its welcoming, lively atmosphere, with live music adding a nice touch.

A photo of Elements Restaurant restaurant

7. Elements Restaurant

4.6

Exceptional(2018)

Price: Very Expensive

• American • Princeton

Booked 7 times today

Elements Restaurant, located in Princeton, comes highly recommended for its astounding American cuisine. The menu offers a clever presentation of each course, with variety and impeccable service. As one review notes, "the variety of the courses paired with the exquisite plating makes this trip to Princeton well worth it." The restaurant is known for its creative and well-executed dishes that seem to never disappoint. The innovation extends to their wine pairings, with selections from lesser-known producers, which guests describe as "revelatory." As one review sums it up, "Everything was fabulous - food, service, presentation." Elements Restaurant provides a unique dining experience that is both inventive and delicious, setting it apart in the realm of American cuisine.

8. Iron & Ivy

3.0

Good(0)

Price: Expensive

• American • Princeton

Booked 2 times today

Savor signature steak and delectable fare for breakfast, lunch or dinner at Iron & Ivy. Recently renovated with scenic outdoor seating available, our stylish restaurant and bar is the perfect place to start your morning or wind down your evening.

A photo of Acacia of Lawrenceville restaurant

9. Acacia of Lawrenceville

4.9

Exceptional(1098)

Price: Moderate

• American • Lawrenceville

Booked 7 times today

Acacia of Lawrenceville is a stellar addition to the American culinary scene. Known for its creative and well-prepared nouveau American cuisine, Acacia has consistently won raves from diners. Highlights include the butternut squash soup with toasted pumpkin seeds, the white-wine steamed mussels with garlic, and the homemade pasta like vodka rigatoni with burrata. Patrons appreciate Acacia's attention to COVID-19 precautions and the pleasant ambience both indoors and outdoors. Acacia's excellence extends beyond its menu to the fantastic, accommodating servers and the beautiful location. As quoted by many, every experience at Acacia is "outstanding", "fabulous", and "never disappoints". It's a definite must-visit for those seeking an exceptional dining experience.

A photo of Hooters - Lawrenceville restaurant

10. Hooters - Lawrenceville

5.0

Exceptional(0)

Price: Moderate

• American • Lawrenceville

Hooters is the place to be for great seafood, mouth-watering burgers and sandwiches, specialty salads, ice cold beer, a full liquor bar and of course, our signature chicken wings served up in one of our signature sauces by world-famous Hooters Girls. With a casual, upbeat atmosphere, a video wall and plenty of HD TV’s, you’ll have a front row seat to all the games. Hooters, the original wing joint. Lick your fingers, we won’t judge.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Explore OpenTable

West Windsor

American