Best American Restaurants in Theater District

Price: Moderate (430)Price: Expensive (394)Price: Very Expensive (176)

540 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Del Frisco's Double Eagle Steakhouse - New York City restaurant

1. Del Frisco's Double Eagle Steakhouse - New York City

4.7

Exceptional(12540)

Price: Very Expensive

• American • Midtown West

Booked 136 times today

Del Frisco's Double Eagle Steakhouse in New York City stands as an epitome of excellent steakhouse cuisine. Reviews consistently highlight its outstanding food, top-notch service, and vibrant atmosphere. The restaurant has been praised for serving perfectly cooked steaks that have won the "Best Filet" award. Visitors also commend the drinks, particularly the cocktails and the diverse wine list. Long-term patrons underscore the restaurant's consistency over the years, making it a favorite choice for special occasions. The staff's attentiveness and professionalism are frequently mentioned, contributing to a memorable dining experience. Del Frisco's displays a commitment to excellence, making it a must-visit steakhouse in the heart of New York City.

2. Bond 45

4.5

Awesome(9244)

Price: Expensive

• American • Theater District

Booked 84 times today

Bond 45 is an exceptional Italian restaurant located in the heart of the Theater District on 46th St in New York. Its convenient location and delightful service contribute to its popularity, as attested by the multitude of positive reviews. This acclaimed restaurant maintains a high standard for serving authentic, flavorful Italian dishes; from their decadent Lasagna, praised for its richness, and Dover Sole cooked to perfection, to their unique Italian Wedding Soup and Burrata Ravioli. The ambience is heartening and energetic, with ample spacing and moderate noise levels. Whether you're looking for a splendid breakfast, dinner before a show, or a "post-theatre meal of your dreams," Bond 45 consistently delivers a superb culinary experience.

3. Bad Roman

4.5

Awesome(1925)

Price: Expensive

• American • Upper West Side

Booked 238 times today

Bad Roman consistently exceeds customer expectations with their exemplary service and delicious Italian cuisine. The culinary team's compelling modern twist on traditional dishes, such as their mouth-watering short rib pappardelle and the unique garlic babka, has been praised in numerous reviews. Their fun atmosphere and attentive staff members further enhance the dining experience. Patrons have commended the team for making every client feel special, with several singling out the stellar service from Ricky and Jay at the bar. Special occasions are made memorable here, with one guest endorsing it as "one of the best New York experiences." Despite the bustling crowd, Bad Roman ensures a unique, indulgent and flawless dining experience for everyone. Their passion for excellence is evident in their dishes and the positive reviews speak volumes about their superior Italian cuisine.

A photo of Mermaid Oyster Bar - Times Square restaurant

4. Mermaid Oyster Bar - Times Square

4.7

Exceptional(926)

Price: Expensive

• American • Theater District

Booked 82 times today

Mermaid Oyster Bar in Times Square has earned lavish praise from patrons for its fresh and well-prepared seafood. It is deemed a great spot for non-touristy, pre-theatre dinner, offering a variety of seafood options, including oysters, lobster, and clams. Customers specifically note the freshness and quality of dishes like the linguini clams and Grand Platter of seafood. The service at Mermaid is universally acclaimed, with staff described as helpful, friendly, and efficient. The ambiance of the restaurant is cited as "lovely, warm, and relaxing", making it an excellent choice for any occasion, whether it's a casual meal or a special celebration. Despite being centrally located in Times Square, Mermaid Oyster Bar stays faithful to delivering an authentic and non-touristy dining experience.

A photo of Friedman's - Theater District restaurant

5. Friedman's - Theater District

4.3

Awesome(602)

Price: Moderate

• American • Theater District

Booked 83 times today

Friedman's - Theater District is a celebrated restaurant known for its American cuisine with a generous accommodation for allergies, particularly gluten and dairy. Patrons praise their comprehensive allergy precautions, confirming a safe, cross-contamination free environment, while also catering to those without dietary restrictions. Signature dishes range from expertly cooked salmon salads to hearty burgers and fries, all served promptly by their efficient service. The restaurant's unique, dynamic environment also stands out with singing waitstaff adding a touch of Broadway flair. Customers admire the high energy and variety offered, highlighting it as a go-to spot for healthy, gluten-free options with fantastic service and a great atmosphere.

6. Broadway Lounge

4.5

Awesome(1030)

Price: Expensive

• American • Theater District

Booked 43 times today

Broadway Lounge, situated in the heart of New York City, offers an exceptional American cuisine experience. Visitors compliment the delicious food, excellent service, and the lounge's unbeatable views overlooking Times Square. One recurring mention in reviews is their quick service. For many, the pizza stands out as a particular highlight, with the overall menu earning praise for its quality. Some patrons even note that the dining experience at Broadway Lounge enlivened their NYC adventures and anniversaries. The welcoming staff, great food, prime location, and stunning views make Broadway Lounge an ideal spot for both locals and tourists seeking a taste of the American culinary scene.

A photo of Quality Italian - New York restaurant

7. Quality Italian - New York

4.6

Exceptional(5906)

Price: Expensive

• American • Midtown West

Booked 161 times today

Located in the heart of New York City, Quality Italian offers an exceptional dining experience, renowned for its excellent Italian cuisine. Customers frequently highlight the exquisite taste of dishes such as the Caesar salad, steak, pesto mafaldine, and highly recommended chicken Parmesan. As one reviewer put it, it's "honestly the best food my husband and I have ever had." The restaurant also boasts of a great wine list and an attentive, professional service team, as evidenced by multiple rave reviews. Despite the slight concern over table proximity, customers commonly describe Quality Italian as a "great place", "perfect ambiance", and an "amazing experience". With praises for the food still echoing long after meals, Quality Italian is no doubt a premium choice for lovers of Italian cuisine.

8. Quality Bistro

4.7

Exceptional(2879)

Price: Expensive

• American • Midtown West

Booked 114 times today

Quality Bistro, nestled in New York City, truly embodies remarkable American cuisine that resonates with many patrons. In numerous review snippets, the restaurant's diverse and delicious menu stands out, with the Chateau Briand, pistachio crème brulee, and corn crème brulee receiving special praise. One reviewer tagged it as their 'favorite' amongst all Quality establishments in NYC, reflecting its distinct appeal. The venue’s ambiance is frequently highlighted as 'lovely', 'beautiful' and 'cozy', playing host to memorable dining experiences, satisfying gatherings, and special occasions. The warmth, professionalism, and efficiency of service complement the culinary excellence, affirming Quality Bistro as a superior choice for delectable American dining.

A photo of Tavern on the Green restaurant

9. Tavern on the Green

4.7

Exceptional(18353)

Price: Expensive

• American • Midtown West

Booked 290 times today

Tavern on the Green, situated in the heart of New York City in Central Park, offers a delightful American cuisine experience. Known for its iconic location, the restaurant has earned a reputation for its classic American food. Patrons celebrate its well-prepared dishes, from Saturday brunch classics like eggs benedict and French toast, to lunch and dinner delicacies like their golden brown crispy chicken sandwich, and sliced prime steak with French dip. Many visitors recommend their truffle oil and Parmesan cheese shoestring fries as a delightful treat. The restaurant has been described as one of the most historic, beautiful, and fascinating American restaurants that "absolutely exceeded our high expectations," making it a regular stop for many on their visits to Manhattan. The ambiance, exemplified by the scenic view of Sheep Meadow, is praised as much as the food, making Tavern on the Green a beloved spot for both tourists and New Yorkers.

A photo of Dos Caminos - Times Square restaurant

10. Dos Caminos - Times Square

4.2

Awesome(2344)

Price: Expensive

• American • Theater District

Booked 38 times today

Dos Caminos - Times Square is renowned for serving excellent Mexican cuisine in the heart of New York City. The restaurant is noted for its vast, intricate layout and accommodating ambiance, suggested in one review as "a huge beautiful underground area". This authentic Mexican spot has won over patrons not only with its "amazing", "delicious", and "excellent" food, but also with its exceptional service: the wait staff is praised as being "attentive", "accommodating", and "quick". Recurring mentions of flavorful dishes such as the Birria tacos, the flank steak with chimichurri sauce and fresh guacamole, attest to its culinary authenticity. Several reviewers express their intent to return, indicative of a consistently satisfying dining experience.

How is content generated

Discover best American restaurants in Theater District

Discover the heart of American cuisine in Manhattan's Theater District, an area renowned for its dynamic dining scene and vibrant cultural backdrop. This bustling locale offers a diverse array of restaurants that specialize in American cuisine, presenting everything from contemporary innovations to comforting classics. Each establishment in this area prides itself on exceptional service, high-quality ingredients, and a commitment to culinary excellence, ensuring a memorable dining experience. Whether you're craving succulent seafood, gourmet burgers, or artisanal barbeque, the Theater District has a spot that caters to every palate. The restaurants here are conveniently located near Broadway's array of entertainment options, making them perfect for a pre-theater meal or a post-show dinner. With stellar reviews highlighting the inviting atmospheres and creative presentations, these eateries are celebrated not just for their food but also for enhancing the overall dining experience. Reflecting the eclectic and ever-evolving nature of New York City itself, the dining scene in the Theater District offers a unique blend of tastes and experiences, serving as a culinary mirror to America's rich gastronomic heritage.

Explore OpenTable

Theater District

American